Jump to content


Photo

A Feast for Crows Reread


This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
36 replies to this topic

#1 cteresa

cteresa

    Council Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 13,359 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 04:54 PM

Oh, wow, that was fast, thanks so much for the new forum Ran.

Recaping, the proposal is a reread of AFFC, all spoilerage related to AFFC allowed, keyword being reread.

Two chapters a week, on this subforum, as talked on the old board and a thread on the new AFFC board. Discussion starting each week on Monday ( 0.01 am on New Zealand will do I guess) and going till Sunday

About how to organize the discussion: the old ASOIAF reread used different threads for each viewpoint character. Another option is using threads by date of what is being discussed. I think the discussion by viewpoint character might make it easier to find later discussions on a certain page or chapter, while organizing it by date will make it easier for people to follow the reread with us or later. Dunno which would be better overall, each has advantages and disadvantages, have your say please.

If we go by chapters, there is a good suggestion that we combine some POVs on some threads for example

Dorne - Prologue ( ok, not Dorne, but I do not know where else to put it), Arys, Areo and Arianne

Iron Islands - Aeron, Asha, Victarion

then single threads for each of the other PoVs

Arya
Brienne
Cersei
Jaime
Sam
Sansa

What do you guys think?

I tried to do some chapter counting, and according to the K hardback, if I made no mistakes, it´s 46 chapters

Prologue (Pate) 1
Aeron ( The Prophet) 18
Areo (The Captain of the Guards) 30
Cersei 1 47
Brienne 1 57
Samwell 1 71
Arya 1 87
Cersei 2 99
Jaime 1 116
Brienne 2 131
Sansa 1 145
Asha (The Kraken´s Daughter) 159
Cersei 3 173
Arys (The Soiled Knight) 185
Brienne 3 199
Samwell 2 215
Jaime 2 226
Cersei 4 238
Victarion (The Iron Captain) 255
Aeron 2 ( The Drowned Man) 267
Brienne 4 280
Arianne (The Queenmaker) 298
Arya 2 312
Sansa 2 (Alayne 1) 329
Cersei 5 344
Brienne 5 363
Samwell 3 377
Jaime 3 391
Cersei 6 411
Victarion 2 (The Reaver) 427
Jaime 4 444
Brienne 6 461
Cersei 7 473
Jaime 5 487
Arya 3 (Cat of the Canals) 504
Samwell 4 519
Cersei 8 529
Brienne 7 547
Jaime 6 561
Cersei 9 575
Arianne 2 (The Princess in the Tower) 587
Sansa 3 (Alayne 2) 605
Brienne 8 628
Cersei 10 642
Jaime 7 659
Samwell 5 672


If anybody spots any mistake there, do let me know please. I can´t believe Arya has only 3 chapters and Brienne 8! And if anybody has US page numbers, that would be great as well.

The proposal for the schedule assuming we start next monday, and taking out Christmas week is

28-Nov-05 Prologue Aeron , page 1 to 29
5-Dez-05 Areo Cersei 1 , page 30 to 56
12-Dez-05 Brienne 1 Samwell 1 , page 57 to 86
19-Dez-05 Arya 1 Cersei 2 , page 87 to 115
2-Jan-06 Jaime 1 Brienne 2 , page 116 to 144
9-Jan-06 Sansa 1 Asha , page 145 to 172
16-Jan-06 Cersei 3 Arys , page 173 to 198
23-Jan-06 Brienne 3 Samwell 2 , page 199 to 225
30-Jan-06 Jaime 2 Cersei 4 , page 226 to 254
6-Fev-06 Victarion Aeron 2 , page 255 to 279
13-Fev-06 Brienne 4 Arianne , page 280 to 311
20-Fev-06 Arya 2 Sansa 2 , page 312 to 343
27-Fev-06 Cersei 5 Brienne 5 , page 344 to 376
6-Mar-06 Samwell 3 Jaime 3 , page 377 to 410
13-Mar-06 Cersei 6 Victarion 2 , page 411 to 443
20-Mar-06 Jaime 4 Brienne 6 , page 444 to 472
27-Mar-06 Cersei 7 Jaime 5 , page 473 to 503
3-Abr-06 Arya 3 Samwell 4 , page 504 to 528
10-Abr-06 Cersei 8 Brienne 7 , page 529 to 560
17-Abr-06 Jaime 6 Cersei 9 , page 561 to 586
24-Abr-06 Arianne 2 Sansa 3 , page 587 to 627
1-Mai-06 Brienne 8 Cersei 10 , page 628 to 658
8-Mai-06 Jaime 7 Samwell 5 , page 659 to 685

PS - edited correcting small mistakes, thanks OZ and HS!

Edited by Cteresa, 04 December 2005 - 01:05 PM.


#2 Mikey

Mikey

    Commoner

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 20 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 05:05 PM

Wow great work cteresa, thanks a lot, cant wait to get started.

Hopefully we wont have too many people wandering off topic all the time :P

#3 High Sparrow

High Sparrow

    Commoner

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 6 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 05:46 PM

Samwell 5 519
Samwell 4 672

Don't mean to nitpick, but you put Samwell 4 and Samwell 5 the wrong way around :)

Otherwise great job, love the idea :D

#4 Old Zog

Old Zog

    Incomparable

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,122 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 05:50 PM

Another minor error: The Queenmaker is told from Arianne's PoV, not Arys's.

Good work. I'm looking forward to this.

#5 IshtarNZ

IshtarNZ

    Antipodean Goddess

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,459 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 06:47 PM

Cteresa, those page numbers are like 1 off the UK (Australia) trade paperback as well, which is good for me! Schedule looks good too.

As for thoughts on AFFC, I guess I'll start that.

I found that the book really opened my eyes to the horrors of the war, particularly Brienne's chapters (obviously). It made me realise how bad things had really gotten. That was the big thing for me.

I was also fascinated by Cersei's descent to madness, and how quickly it happened.


Really looking forward to this re-read!

#6 Leah

Leah

    Sellsword

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 107 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 07:13 PM

Two chapters a week, on this subforum. Discussion starting on Monday ( 0.01 am on New Zealand will do I guess) and going till Sunday.

About how to organize the discussion: the old ASOIAF reread used different threads for each viewpoint character. Another option is using threads by date of what is being discussed. I think the discussion by viewpoint character might make it easier to find later discussions on a certain page or chapter, while organizing it by date will make it easier for people to follow the reread with us or later. Dunno which would be better overall, each has advantages and disadvantages, have your say please.



How about we set up the discussion according to what week we are on?

Which would make the title and the subtilte look like this:

Week One -- 28-Nov-05
Prologue & The Prophet

Week Two -- 5-Dec-05
The Captain of the Guard & Cersei 1

Week Three -- 12-Dec-05
Brienne 1 & Samwell 1


So on and so forth.

It would make it so much easier on people who get behind and then there wouldn't be a mix up of discussion about the different chapters which got kind of confusing the first time I took part in the reread over on the other board.

Just a suggestion =)

Edited by Leah, 22 November 2005 - 07:14 PM.


#7 IshtarNZ

IshtarNZ

    Antipodean Goddess

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,459 posts

Posted 22 November 2005 - 08:13 PM

I like Leah's suggestion above. Nice and clear and easy to follow, and logical as it follows how we're working through the book. And easy to go back to/catch up on too.

Once we've decided on the set up, and are ready to go, would you like me to set up each thread as midnight NZ time comes around? Its 10pm Aussie time so its a good time for me. And I can let you guys know if I'm unavailable for some (which I will be from mid-Dec to mid-Jan).

#8 Happy Ent

Happy Ent

    Godfather of the Weirwoods

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 8,292 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 03:13 AM

I prefer Cteresa's suggestion of splitting by POV instead of by date. I can imagine discussions about (say) Brienne III and Brienne IV being related and hence benefiting from a common thread (because of quoting, for example). But I see no benefit in discussing Prologue and The Prophet in the same thread. There are no common themes or characters or arcs or events in those two chapters, so our discussions might be disjointed and confusing.

But it's not big deal, I am in either way, and grateful that somebody organises it. (That will be my fourth reading.)

#9 Jon Targaryen

Jon Targaryen

    Crouching Direwolf, Hidden Dragon

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 16,399 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 04:33 AM

Thanks for setting up the schedule cteresa. I like the old way of organizing it for much the same reason Happy Ent said.

#10 Archmaester Marwyn

Archmaester Marwyn

    Hedge Knight

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 331 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 05:47 AM

I prefer Cteresa's suggestion of splitting by POV instead of by date. I can imagine discussions about (say) Brienne III and Brienne IV being related and hence benefiting from a common thread (because of quoting, for example). But I see no benefit in discussing Prologue and The Prophet in the same thread. There are no common themes or characters or arcs or events in those two chapters, so our discussions might be disjointed and confusing.

But it's not big deal, I am in either way, and grateful that somebody organises it. (That will be my fourth reading.)


Yes, we should discuss about Prologue and Sam 5 in same topic rather then Aeron and Prologue.

#11 Princess Nym

Princess Nym

    Commoner

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 13 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 11:43 AM

this might be kind of a silly question, but I'm new, and have never done a group re-read. I am very excited to do it and don't want to miss out!!! :D

My question is, if I don't join in the discussion at the same time as everyone else (it ends up being 4 in the morning here with the time change), and join later in the day, will there still be people to talk to? Or will I have missed the major points of discussion?

#12 LadySoftheart

LadySoftheart

    Landed Knight

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 436 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 01:43 PM

Oh, this is fabulous - I've dragged out reading as long as I possibly can because I'm so sad to be coming to the end, but REREADING is a brilliant project. So, the timeline is as above, then?

#13 cteresa

cteresa

    Council Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 13,359 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 04:09 PM

Yes, we should discuss about Prologue and Sam 5 in same topic rather then Aeron and Prologue.


Marwyn, help, can you explain that some other way? I do not understand what you mean, but admittedly been a long day.

So far Leah and Ishtar prefer a method where we would have a thread per week - that would make it about 23 threads for 46 chapters. HE and Jon prefer dividing by POV like the old reread, which would mean about 8 threads going at once - we might need to close threads to start new ones, is the 200 post thread limit still going on? Personally I am sort of inclined for the thread for each character thread, if only by inertia because that was what we tried before.

Nym, welcome, I am not sure how it will go yet, how many we will be, how discussion will go, by last reread people were joining and leaving ( oh, yep leaving mostly towards the end, but we were suffering AFFC withdrawal badly) freely. If you mean discussing the chapters being read, jump in at any time, if you mean old chapters, not sure. Of course chances are discussion of a juicy bit will drag or somebody making some really new observation will bring things up to the top. But no guarantees people will be as interested in chapters they read weeksago as in the chapters they just read, and not sure if it might not make things confusing. But the most interesting bits of AFFC are probably towards the end, when do you think you could join? This read would drag till May if we make no pauses other than Christmas.

welcome as well, ladysoftheart.

#14 LadySoftheart

LadySoftheart

    Landed Knight

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 436 posts

Posted 23 November 2005 - 07:10 PM

welcome as well, ladysoftheart.


Thank you very much - I used to be on the now-defunct old board, but unfortunately, I don't remember my username from there as I gave up on the series ever being completed sometime in the year 2003 ;) But I DO remember your posts - particularly Sam as Aegon Targaryen! (Which I hope does not make me sound creepy and stalkerish!)

#15 Archmaester Marwyn

Archmaester Marwyn

    Hedge Knight

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 331 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 02:28 AM

Marwyn, help, can you explain that some other way? I do not understand what you mean, but admittedly been a long day.


Sam 5 and Prologue are related - There are same characters and same place, right?

#16 IshtarNZ

IshtarNZ

    Antipodean Goddess

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 3,459 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 03:43 AM

I can see arguments for both ways of organsing, so I don't really mind. It would certainly be easier to track themes are happenings to particular characters if we organise by character, but easier to keep track of the re-read over all if organised by week. Also, if we go by character - where does the Prologue fit in? As pointed out, it has more in common with the Sam chapters than anything else, so perhaps it would need to be included as part of them? Then again, it has some Dornish links too. So hmm.

#17 cteresa

cteresa

    Council Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 13,359 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 05:17 AM

Ah, of course, Marwyn thanks for explaining it, was not seeing what chapter was exactly. Yep, good idea, let us put prologue with Sam´s chapters instead if we go that way.

And I got yet another suggestion, if we split by week threads, that would mean 23 threads, what if we go even further and suggest a different chapter for each character? On the old board we had to use an existing forum and few threads made it less likely to bother others and easy to find, but here we got our brand new shiny new subforum, dunno....

So what do we do? any good arguments? If we start monday we need to decide.

Oh, and an extra point, if we start the reread however many threads we start for the reread let us ID any thread with AFFC reread? Just in case :D later anybody wants to do other rereads and we recycle the subforum.

#18 Happy Ent

Happy Ent

    Godfather of the Weirwoods

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 8,292 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 06:38 AM

Let's see if I got it right. (Concreteness is such a wonderful way of exposing dissent.)

The threads will be:
Sam: Prologue, Samwell I-V
Ironborn: The Prophet, The Kraken's Daughter, The Iron Captain, The Drowned Man, The Reaver
Dorne: The Captain of the Guards, The Soiled Knight, The Queenmaker, The Princess in the Tower
Cersei: Cersei I-X
Brienne: Brienne I-VIII
Arya Arya I-II, Cat of the Canals
Jaime Jaime I-VII
Sansa Sansa, Alayne I-II

#19 Lupigis

Lupigis

    Council Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,680 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 07:01 AM

I'm fine with the thread-by-POV way of doing the reread.

BTW, I just realised that only members can read this forum (as I tried to read it without being logged in). Why is that?

#20 cteresa

cteresa

    Council Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 13,359 posts

Posted 24 November 2005 - 07:07 AM

I'm fine with the thread-by-POV way of doing the reread.

BTW, I just realised that only members can read this forum (as I tried to read it without being logged in). Why is that?


I don´t know Lupigis, we can try checking with ran.

HE, thanks that is just it! So far proposals seem to be

Option A - what Lupigis listed above, threads for

Sam: Prologue, Samwell I-V
Ironborn: The Prophet, The Kraken's Daughter, The Iron Captain, The Drowned Man, The Reaver
Dorne: The Captain of the Guards, The Soiled Knight, The Queenmaker, The Princess in the Tower
Cersei: Cersei I-X
Brienne: Brienne I-VIII
Arya Arya I-II, Cat of the Canals
Jaime Jaime I-VII
Sansa Sansa, Alayne I-II


Option B - 23 threads for

Week 1 Prologue + Aeron ( The Prophet)
Week 2 Areo +Cersei
Week 3 Brienne + Samwell 1

etc

Option C - thread for each chapter

Thread 1 - Prologue
Thread 2 - Aeron ( The Prophet)
Thread 3- Areo (The Captain of the Guards)

etc

So far option A seems like the best choice, anybody else having a preference? I have not checked with ran if he has any restrictions about number of threads or thread size, will do it now.

Edited by Cteresa, 24 November 2005 - 07:08 AM.