ASOIAF Elimiination Game XXIX: Best Targaryen.

[honeyed chicken]

Welcome everybody to the Best Targaryen ASOIAF Elimination Game.

As usual we start with a quick review of the rules.

In each round, you are allowed to "heal" one option and "hurt" another. For example:


1. Aerion Brightflame 5
2. Viserys III, the Beggar King 5

Heal Aerion
Hurt Viserys III

1. Aerion Brightflame 6 +
2. Viserys III, the Beggar King 4 -

Rules and restrictions

1. Every battle starts with 5 HP (healing points).
2. You can only vote once every 10 attack posts (9 between your first and last) OR once every two hours.
3. A cap of 25 HP will be imposed upon the last 5 items standing. Once this cap is in effect, you can choose to hurt one option without healing another, as long as at least one of the remaining choices is at the 25 point maximum.
4. If you spot any errors during the game, please correct them and include where you saw the error happen.
5. The game starts with 150 HP total and should stay that way until the last 5 deaths standing.
6. Please note who you're healing/hurting with +/- signs.
7. Declare what you are hurting and what you are healing.

Please post your vote first and then edit in the score, this way you will see who has voted before you. This helps to prevent ninjas.

Illegitimate votes: If someone votes too early (less than 9 votes between their votes, and less than two hours their vote will not be counted and they will have to vote again.

For this game we have 50 Targaryens from which to chose a best one. 20 have been selected to go through to a final round of 30. They are the following:

1. Aegon I the Conquerer
2. Visenya (Aegon I sister)
3. Rhaenys (Aegon I sister)
4. Jaehaerys I the Wise
5. Alysanne (Jaehaerys I wife and sister)

6. Daena the Defiant

7. Brynden "Bloodraven" Rivers

8. Maester Aemon

9. Aegon V the Unlikely, Egg

10. Aemon the Dragonknight

11. Baelor Breakspear

12. Daenerys Stormborn

13. Rhaegar

14. Princess Rhaenys (Queen that never was)

15. Daeron the Drunk (Maekar's eldest son)

16. Daeron I the Young Dragon

17. Aegor "Bittersteel" Rivers

18. Daemon I Blackfyre

19. Maekar I

20. Aerion Brightflame

This game will consist of the following 30 Targaryens. We will play till there are 10 left to join with the 20 above.

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 5
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 5
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 5
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 5
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 5
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 5

17. Baela 5

18. Daeron the Daring 5

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 5

26. Queen Naerys 5

27. Aenys I 5

28. Viserys I 5

29. Aegon II 5

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[honeyed chicken]

Heal Viserys III

Hurt Viserys I

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 5
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 5
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 5
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 5
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 6 +
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 5

17. Baela 5

18. Daeron the Daring 5

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 5

26. Queen Naerys 5

27. Aenys I 5

28. Viserys I 4 -

29. Aegon II 5

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

And we're off and running!

[The Wolf Lord's Daughter]

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 5
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 5
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 5
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 5
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 6
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 5

17. Baela 5

18. Daeron the Daring 5

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4-

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 6+

26. Queen Naerys 5

27. Aenys I 5

28. Viserys I 4

29. Aegon II 5

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[PancakeMountainThatRides]

Heal 16, hurt 27, please

[Ser Blackfyre]

Hurt 25

Heal 13

[PancakeMountainThatRides]

Heal 16, hurt 29

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 5

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 5

3. Baelor I the Beloved 5

4. Viserys II 5

5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5

6. Shiera Seastar 5

7. Daeron II the Good 5

8. Aerys I 5

9. Jaehaerys II 5

10. Duncan the Small 5

11. Aerys II the Mad 5

12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 5

13. Viserys III the Beggar King 7+

14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5

15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 7++

17. Baela 5

18. Daeron the Daring 5

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 5-

26. Queen Naerys 5

27. Aenys I 4-

28. Viserys I 4

29. Aegon II 4-

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[honeyed chicken]

Heal Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter)

Hurt Aegon III the Dragonbane

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 6 +
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4 -
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 5
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 5
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 7
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 5
18. Daeron the Daring 5
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 5
27. Aenys I 4
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[Lord Lyman]

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 6
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 6+
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4-
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 7
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 5
18. Daeron the Daring 5
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 5
27. Aenys I 4
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[Annara Snow]

heal Rhaenyra

hurt Aenys

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7 +
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 6
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4

13 Viserys III the Beggar King 7
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 5
18. Daeron the Daring 5
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 5
27. Aenys I 3 -
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[PancakeMountainThatRides]

Heal 18, hurt 29

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4

3. Baelor I the Beloved 5

4. Viserys II 5

5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5

6. Shiera Seastar 5

7. Daeron II the Good 5

8. Aerys I 5

9. Jaehaerys II 5

10. Duncan the Small 5

11. Aerys II the Mad 6

12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4

13 Viserys III the Beggar King 8

14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5

15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 7

17. Baela 5

18. Daeron the Daring 6+

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 5

26. Queen Naerys 5

27. Aenys I 3

28. Viserys I 4

29. Aegon II 3-

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[honeyed chicken]

Heal Queen Naerys

Hurt Aegon II

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 6
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13 Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 5
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 6 +
27. Aenys I 3
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 2 -
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[Annara Snow]

heal Baela

hurt Aegon II

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 5
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 6
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 6 +
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 6
27. Aenys I 3
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 1 -
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[Lord Lyman]

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4-
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 5
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 5
11. Aerys II the Mad 7+
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 6
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 6
27. Aenys I 3
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 1
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[Lord Lyman]

Hey HC. You have a note about two semifinals lists combining for a final list in the OP. Can you remove that so we don't cause any confusion please.

[Ser Blackfyre]

Hurt Aerys I

Heal Maegor the Cruel

[honeyed chicken]

Hey HC. You have a note about two semifinals lists combining for a final list in the OP. Can you remove that so we don't cause any confusion please.

Thanks for catching that. Will correct soon.

Hurt Aerys I

Heal Maegor the Cruel

Heal Naerys

Hurt Maegor

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4

3. Baelor I the Beloved 5

4. Viserys II 5

5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4

6. Shiera Seastar 5

7. Daeron II the Good 5

8. Aerys I 4 -

9. Jaehaerys II 5

10. Duncan the Small 5

11. Aerys II the Mad 7

12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4

13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8

14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5

15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5

16. Daemon 7

17. Baela 6

18. Daeron the Daring 6

19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5

20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4

21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5

22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5

23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5

24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5

25. Elaena 5

26. Queen Naerys 7 +

27. Aenys I 3

28. Viserys I 4

29. Aegon II 1

30. Maegor I the Cruel 5 +-

[Annara Snow]

heal Duncan the Small

kill Aegon II

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7
2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 4
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 6 +
11. Aerys II the Mad 7
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 7
17. Baela 6
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 7
27. Aenys I 3
28. Viserys I 4
29. Aegon II 0 -
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

Killed off:

18.

19.

20. Aegon II

[PancakeMountainThatRides]

Heal 16, hurt 27

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 4
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 6
11. Aerys II the Mad 7
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 8+
17. Baela 6
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 7
27. Aenys I 2-
28. Viserys I 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

Killed off:

18.

19.

20. Aegon II

[honeyed chicken]

heal Baela

hurt Aenys I

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 4
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 6
11. Aerys II the Mad 7
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 8
17. Baela 7 +
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 5
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 7
27. Aenys I 1 -
28. Viserys I 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5

[PancakeMountainThatRides]

Kill Aenys, heal John the Fiddler

1. Rhaenyra (Viserys I daughter) 7

2. Aegon III the Dragonbane 4
3. Baelor I the Beloved 5
4. Viserys II 5
5. Aegon IV the Unworthy 4
6. Shiera Seastar 5
7. Daeron II the Good 5
8. Aerys I 4
9. Jaehaerys II 5
10. Duncan the Small 6
11. Aerys II the Mad 7
12. Rhaella (Aerys II sister and wife) 4
13. Viserys III the Beggar King 8
14. Rhaenys (Rhaegar's daughter) 5
15. Aegon (Rhaegar's son) 5
16. Daemon 8
17. Baela 7
18. Daeron the Daring 6
19. Daemon II Blackfyre (aka "John the Fiddler") 6+
20. Aemond Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 4
21. Haelena Targaryen (child of Alicent and Viserys I) 5
22. Jahaerys Velaryon 5
23. Lucaerys "Luke" Velaryon 5
24. Joffrey Velaryon (queen Rhaenyra's children) 5
25. Elaena 5
26. Queen Naerys 7
27. Aenys I 0-
28. Viserys I 4
30. Maegor I the Cruel 5