ASOIAF Elimination Games: Voting on a Topic for Game XXXV

[honeyed chicken]

This is the place for deciding which ASOIAF elimination game topic will be played next.

This link will take you to the topics thread. There you can look over potential EG topics that have been suggested but not played yet. Many of the topics already have starter lists attached. If you have time to dream up additional new topics or fill out lists for some of the ideas there, your work is much appreciated. thank you! :)

eta

currently we've picked badass moments for EG XXXV. The list of moments is now at issue.

[honeyed chicken]

The actors game is winding down, and may finish today, so it is time to start thinking about the next one. I would be happy for anybody (and hopefully several somebodies) to suggest topics to discuss, consider and vote on.

[King Tyrion I]

How about most badass moment? Like the duel Oberyn vs. The Mountain.

[Kobayashi Maru]

So I posted in the thread about the topics and if you want I can post here too.

Best deity if it's not been done and funniest moment.

[yomi]

Do we have enough deities to make a reasonable game?

I liked the soundtrack idea.

[N/A]

So I posted in the thread about the topics and if you want I can post here too.

Best deity if it's not been done and funniest moment.

I'm not sure there are enough deities unless we include the ones in the house of the black and white . Which we can do i suppose.

[honeyed chicken]

How about most badass moment? Like the duel Oberyn vs. The Mountain.

So I posted in the thread about the topics and if you want I can post here too.

Best deity if it's not been done and funniest moment.

Hey!

How are you guys? Nice to see you here. Good ideas too.

[honeyed chicken]

Here's the current deities list from the topics thread - it's labeled "deities and supernatural beings" to give a bit more latitude to get to 30.

- deity/supernatural beings

Rebooted topic - deities and supernatural beings

1) Old Gods 5
2) Drowned God 5
3) R'hllor 5
4) The Seven 5
5) Many Faced God 5
6) The Others 5
7) Qartheen warlocks 5
8) Moqorro 5
9) Quaithe 5
10) Wights 5
11) Azor Ahai 5
12) Children of the Forest 5
13) Dragons 5
14) Direwolves 5
15) Coldhands 5
16) UnBeric 5
17) UnCat 5
18) Patchface 5
19) Melisandre 5
20) Bloodraven 5
21) Faceless Men 5
22) Wargs 5
23) Greenseers 5
24) Storm God 5
25) Great Stallion 5
26) Summer Islands god/dess 5
27) Black Goat of Qohor 5
28) Mirri Maz Duur 5
29) Maggy the Frog 5
30) The Ghost of Highheart 5

A bunch of these are a stretch to say the least. Patchface? Seriously? But this topic has been played using these characters/deities so . . .

Personally, I would rather split up the Seven (the Smith, Stranger, Maiden, etc) than include Patchface and some of the others, but that's just me.

[Kobayashi Maru]

Well we apparently can make list of 30 if we want to :)

there are certainly 30 funny moments in the books.

[N/A]

Here's the current deities list from the topics thread - it's labeled "deities and supernatural beings" to give a bit more latitude to get to 30.

- deity/supernatural beings

Rebooted topic - deities and supernatural beings

1) Old Gods 5

2) Drowned God 5

3) R'hllor 5

4) The Seven 5

5) Many Faced God 5

6) The Others 5

7) Qartheen warlocks 5

8) Moqorro 5

9) Quaithe 5

10) Wights 5

11) Azor Ahai 5

12) Children of the Forest 5

13) Dragons 5

14) Direwolves 5

15) Coldhands 5

16) UnBeric 5

17) UnCat 5

18) Patchface 5

19) Melisandre 5

20) Bloodraven 5

21) Faceless Men 5

22) Wargs 5

23) Greenseers 5

24) Storm God 5

25) Great Stallion 5

26) Summer Islands god/dess 5

27) Black Goat of Qohor 5

28) Mirri Maz Duur 5

29) Maggy the Frog 5

30) The Ghost of Highheart 5

A bunch of these are a stretch to say the least. Patchface? Seriously? But this topic has been played using these characters/deities so . . .

Personally, I would rather split up the Seven (the Smith, Stranger, Maiden, etc) than include Patchface and some of the others, but that's just me.

That's like only seven deities , seriously, the supernatural thing is bad . Just break up the seven and add the ones from tge house of black and white (for some reason I said undying:p )

[Annara Snow]

Yes. breaking up the Seven into all Seven deities/faces of the god would be better, IMO.

We know that most people in Westeros, including most followers of the Seven, consider them different gods in the first place. It's only septons who explain that they're supposed to be facets of the same god.

[honeyed chicken]

Yes. breaking up the Seven into all Seven deities/faces of the god would be better, IMO.

We know that most people in Westeros, including most followers of the Seven, consider them different gods in the first place. It's only septons who explain that they're supposed to be facets of the same god.

Exactly.

And many Westerosi seem to pray exclusively to one of the Seven, so I think that's a good switch we could do.

[honeyed chicken]

Do we have enough deities to make a reasonable game?

I liked the soundtrack idea.

Do you remember your suggestion from last time around? Favorite NW member? I need to go back and get that list into the topics thread. It was a pretty popular late addition to the race.

[Kobayashi Maru]

That's like only seven deities , seriously, the supernatural thing is bad . Just break up the seven and add the ones from tge house of black and white (for some reason I said undying:p )

I like this idea

[Lord Lyman]

Best King?

I realize this might be better played after November 27th. By then the restriction of talking about The World Of Ice and Fire will be lifted, and we can freely talk about it without the need for spoiler tags.

1. Aegon I the Conquerer

2. Aenys I

3. Maegor I the Cruel

4. Jaehaerys I the Conciliator

5. Viserys I

6. Aegon II

7. Aegon III

8. Daeron I the Young Dragon

9. Baelor I the Blessed

10. Viserys II

11. Aegon IV the Unworthy

12. Daeron II the Good

13. Aerys I

14. Maekar I

15. Aegon V the Unworthy

16. Jaehaerys II

17. Aerys II the Mad king

18. Robert I

19. Joffrey I

20. Tommen I

21. Stannis I

22. Renly I

23. Robb I the Young Wolf

24. Balon Greyjoy

25. Daenerys I Stormborn

26. Torrhen Stark, the King Who Knelt

27. Argilac Durrandon

28. Harren the Black

29. Mern IX Gardener

30. Loren I Lannister

[N/A]

Is there enough to make a Best King game?

Tons if you're willing to go back in history.

Thanks koba .

[yomi]

Do you remember your suggestion from last time around? Favorite NW member? I need to go back and get that list into the topics thread. It was a pretty popular late addition to the race.

Yes, I remember it. I surely like it better than the "Gods and beings somehow related to the supernatural" topic, but I still like soundtrack better.

[honeyed chicken]

Suggested topics to this point:

Favorite Deity or supernatural being (using the suggestion to expand the Seven and use gods from the House of Black and White will eliminate the more questionable supernatural beings, I think).

Favorite Man of the NW.

Best king.

Favorite soundtrack from GOT.

(did I miss any?)

I think it is time to start voting, but that doesn't mean you can't toss more topics into the mix. Please feel free to do so. :)

[DreamSongs]

Best King

[honeyed chicken]

Best King

We have a vote, ladies & gentlemen! (this is starting out verrry slowly). I realized just now that I inadvertently left off King Tyrion I's suggestion of badass moments.

Favorite Deity:

Favorite Man of the NW: 1 (hc)

Best King: 1 (QCII)

Favorite Soundtrack from GOT:

Most Badass Moment: