Jump to content

ASOIAF Elimination Game XXXIV: Favorite Badass Moment


honeyed chicken

Recommended Posts

Welcome to the 34rth ASOIAF Elimination Game!

This topic has not been run before as far as I know.

Intro to the Elimination Game

This game generally proceeds in two parts: in the first part you'll start with a list of 30 and voting continues till 25 characters/items have been eliminated. There is then a final five which has slightly different rules.

First 30

With each vote you will "hurt" one moment and "heal" another. You must do both. Each of the 30 moments has started with 5 points for a total of 150. That 150 gets preserved as points are taken from some moments and given to others. Players may and are encouraged to check the total throughout this phase. If the total is wrong please say so right away and if you can, please find and correct the error. If you can't or don't wish to, please say so and someone else will (generally) do it.

Final Five

When five remain we adjust the point totals and the rules change. Any points over 25 are taken away because of the cap, but moment with a point total under 25 stays with that point total whatever it is. For example: A 51, B 26, C 13, D 42, E 18, F 0 becomes A 25, B 25, C 13, D 25, E 18. At that point you no longer are required to give a heal, as long as there's an moment with 25 (hypothetically you might want to give that one a heal but are prevented from doing so by the cap), but you still must give a hurt with any vote.

An example of the voting (first round):

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

Heal 2

Hurt 24

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 6+

24. Sam killing Puddles. 4-

Rules and restrictions

1. Every battle starts with 5 HP (health points).
2. You can only vote once every 10 attack posts (9 between your first and last) OR once every two hours.
3. A cap of 25 HP will be imposed upon the last 5 items standing. Once this cap is in effect, you can choose to hurt one option without healing another, as long as at least one of the remaining choices is at the 25 point maximum.
4. If you spot any errors during the game, please correct them and include where you saw the error happen.
5. The game starts with 150 HP total and should stay that way until the last 5 deaths standing.
6. Please note who you're healing/hurting with +/- signs.
7. Declare what you are hurting and what you are healing.

Please post your vote first and then edit in the score, this way you will see who has voted before you. This helps to prevent ninjas. :ninja:

If you see any errors, misspellings or goof ups in the list you can fix them. :) thanks!

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 5

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 5

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 5

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 5

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 5

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 5

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 5

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 5

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 5

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 5

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 5

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal 30

Hurt 21

hurt 7, heal 18

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 5

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 5

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 4 -

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 5

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 5

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 5

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 5

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 5

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 6 +

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 5

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 4 -

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 6 +

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal 12

Hurt 1

Heal 28

Hurt 7

Hurt 7, heal 3 (for this round)

Heal 15

Hurt 3.

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 4 -

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 5 +-

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 2 --

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 5

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 5

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 6 +

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 6 +

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 5

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 6

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 5

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 4

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 6 +

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal 16

Hurt 30

Heal 30

Hurt 21

Heal 11

Hurt 28

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 4

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 5

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 2

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 5

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 6+

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 6

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 6

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 6+

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 6

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 5

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 3-

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5-

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal 30

Hurt 21

heal 18

hurt 3 please

Heal 11 (Cat) hurt 10 (Bronn)

Heal 11

Hurt 19

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 4

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 4-

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 2

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 4-

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 8++

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 6

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 6

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 6

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 7+

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 4-

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 2-

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 5

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 7+

Link to comment
Share on other sites

hurt 7, heal 18



1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 4


2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5



3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 4


4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5


5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5


6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5


7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 1 -


8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5


9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5


10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 4


11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 8


12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 6


13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5


14. Drogon kills the undying. 5


15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 6


16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 6


17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5


18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 8 +


19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 4


20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5


21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 2


22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5


23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5


24. Sam killing Puddles. 5


25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5


26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5


27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5


28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5


29. Weasel soup. 5


30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 7


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Drogo kills viserys? Drogo promises to take westeros?

Heal 16

Hurt 30

I'm sorry, but we had a very long process. There were several days allowed to add moments to the list (and then a vote to remove the extras). I did think of the first one you mentioned and was a little surprised no one added it . . . .the second one did not occur to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Heal 7.

Hurt 24.

adding in Annara's: Heal 12
Hurt 19

1. Areo Hotah’s beheads Arys Oakheart. 4

2. Arya kills the Tickler. 5

3. Asha Greyjoy laying claim to the Seastone chair at the Kingsmoot. 4

4. Barristan Selmy, dismissed from the KG, cuts his way out of KL, then disguises himself and comes back in. 5

5. Barristan, armed with a staff, defends Dany from Titan’s Bastard & kills him. 5

6. Barristan kills Hizdahr's pit fighter guard. 5

7. Bran wargs into Hodor and fights off the wights. 2 +

8. Brienne drops a boulder on a pursuing river galley, sinking it. 5

9. Brienne killing 3 mummers single handed (mostly). 5

10. Bronn, lightly armored, kills fully armored Vardis Egen in a duel. 4

11. Catelyn stops a Valyrian steel dagger with her bare hands. 8

12. Dany mounts Drago’s funnel pyre, survives it and gives birth to 3 dragons. 7 +

13. Danys’ dragons burn the slave masters of Astapor. 5

14. Drogon kills the undying. 5

15. Dany & Drogon at Daznak's pit. 6

16. Davos surviving Battle of the Blackwater. 6

17. Davos standing up to King Stannis and rescuing Edric Storm. 5

18. Donal Noye dies killing a giant. 8

19. Gregor Clegane smashes Oberyn Martell. 3 -

20. Jamie's rescue of Brienne from the bear pit at Harrenhal. 5

21. Jon Snow rescues LC Mormont from the wight using fire. 2

22. Jon Snow’s duel to the death with Qhorin Halfhand. 5

23. Pod shoves Mandon Moore into the Blackwater Rush drowning him. 5

24. Sam killing Puddles. 4 -

25. Strong Belwas on foot take down Meereen’s mounted hero. 5

26. Syrio wearing no armor takes down several armored Lannister guardsmen with a wooden sword. 5

27. Tyrion gets between a stoneman & Aegon; goes overboard with him. 5

28. Victarion in combat at the Shield Islands. 5

29. Weasel soup. 5

30. Wylla Manderly stating her loyalty to the Starks before a hostile court. 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...