Jump to content

Rant & Rave Without Repercussion s 5 continued [book spoilers]


kissdbyfire

Recommended Posts

Still laughing, good one. :lol:

Hopefully they run into Nymeria along the way. GRRM said (TWOW spoiler):

[spoiler]
http://www.latintimes.com/winds-winter-plot-spoilers-aryas-journey-involve-direwolf-nymeria-according-george-rr-278134[/spoiler]

Interesting so all those nymeria mentions aren't for nothing. Damn I need twow before season 6 hate watching with alcohol is all well and good (that bingo game is actually fun) but I want to enjoy my entertainment.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still laughing, good one. :lol:


Awww. Poor Ghost! :lol:

Hopefully they run into Nymeria along the way. GRRM said (TWOW spoiler):

[spoiler]
http://www.latintimes.com/winds-winter-plot-spoilers-aryas-journey-involve-direwolf-nymeria-according-george-rr-278134[/spoiler]

 

WTB Nymeria's pack killing the Freys escorting the Northern Lord prisoners from the Twins to King's Landing, thus setting them free.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting so all those nymeria mentions aren't for nothing. Damn I need twow of winter before season 6 hate watching with alcohol is all well and good (that bingo game is actually fun) but I want to enjoy my entertainment.


Want to be entertained by my entertainment! Lol
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've been following but mostly lurking...the threads either move too fast or something I wanted to comment on was in an already locked thread. Great stuff, keep it coming y'all.

 

Most likely won't watch S6, and this season felt like the first time where watching was actually more of a chore than something to look forward to. There have been some wtf moments and things I found offensive from S1 on, but there was still enough of GRRM's story to keep my interest.

 

Love Cheb's series on sexism and have to comment on the latest where women who have been disfigured in the books are still remarkably attractive. I found Sansa after her marriage with barely a bruise on her to be pretty disturbing, and said a lot about what the showrunners really consider to be "gritty realism." I also remember the interview with Natalie Tena where she mentioned being somewhat puzzled by playing Osha with a fresh Brazilian (that was from a Thronecast interview). As if people north of the Wall don't have more important things to worry about. Just small things here and there at first, but things start to add up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think they will make Jon or Arya wargs. It is too late. Jon died without warging.

I'm surprised they've not killed Ghost off yet. He is clearly not as cool as a dragon (pretty much just a big dog), takes up the cgi budget and has little relevance to Jon.

Ghost will be a goner, especially if Jon gets a dragon. This is probably for the best because at least Drogon knew when to save his human.

Yea, I think the moment to show Jon warging was at the end of Season 5. I saw pictures of his eyes being just white but they were faked, which was unfortunate as that could've been quite good. Imagine it, the camera zooms into him, lying dead on the floor, then suddenly he goes into warg-mode and it cuts to Ghost looking rather pissed off and cuts to the credits. Then next season we could've looked forward to Olly becoming dinner. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yea, I think the moment to show Jon warging was at the end of Season 5. I saw pictures of his eyes being just white but they were faked, which was unfortunate as that could've been quite good. Imagine it, the camera zooms into him, lying dead on the floor, then suddenly he goes into warg-mode and it cuts to Ghost looking rather pissed off and cuts to the credits. Then next season we could've looked forward to Olly becoming dinner.


But then they wouldn't be able to get away with this stupid 'Jon is deader than dead' bullshit they're so keen on.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Does anyone seriously believe it though? Even non-book readers?


Honestly? No idea. But my point isn't how many people believe it or not, but rather how keen they were to go ahead with it. It's all about the hype, but ultimately, everything n GoT boils down to false advertising:
- it's an adaptation
- it's all about gritty realism!
- 'we' (D&D) love Sansa!
- Jon is deader than dead
- yadda yadda yadda

:)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly? No idea. But my point isn't how many people believe it or not, but rather how keen they were to go ahead with it. It's all about the hype, but ultimately, everything n GoT boils down to false advertising:
- it's an adaptation
- it's all about gritty realism!
- 'we' (D&D) love Sansa!
- Jon is deader than dead
- yadda yadda yadda

:)

I see your point there. Still, I think it would've been an improvement than what we got. Then again, what wouldn't be?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still laughing, good one. :lol:


Awww. Poor Ghost! :lol:

Hopefully they run into Nymeria along the way. GRRM said (TWOW spoiler):

[spoiler]
http://www.latintimes.com/winds-winter-plot-spoilers-aryas-journey-involve-direwolf-nymeria-according-george-rr-278134[/spoiler]


George doesn't really involve himself in the making of the show anymore so I wouldn't give this (dated) article much weight. He isn't involved in the process now.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yea, I think the moment to show Jon warging was at the end of Season 5. I saw pictures of his eyes being just white but they were faked, which was unfortunate as that could've been quite good. Imagine it, the camera zooms into him, lying dead on the floor, then suddenly he goes into warg-mode and it cuts to Ghost looking rather pissed off and cuts to the credits. Then next season we could've looked forward to Olly becoming dinner. 

 

I was expecting something like this. However, the "Jon Snow is gone" angle shocks and horrifies the fans more than the "Jon Snow may be gone" angle, so figures.

They could have at least made it clear why Ghost was not there for Jon (showed him in a cage, had Jon lock him in his chambers, had Jon mention that he was locked up or away hunting etc.) Just something! :bang:

 

Also, people should not build up their hopes for Jon or anyone killing Olly. Jon forgave him once and apparently Jon let him down so there will probably be a redemption arc coming.  :ack:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I see your point there. Still, I think it would've been an improvement than what we got. Then again, what wouldn't be?


Of course it would have been a million times better! It's just yet another mistake they made, the list is truly endless.
'Stick 'em with the pointy end. Ghost.'


It would give people a hint, where's the fun in that? It would develop character and plot, but it wouldn't be fun at all, Much better to state categorically that Jon is 'deader than dead', and when they bring him back, OMG WTF SUCH A SHOCKING TWIST!!!
Only it won't, it will backfire and look and feel stupid and cheap. But hey, they'll get months of hype out of it, and that's all that matters.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure. I mean, they may do it just so they can show more boobs but I can't see how they'll have her without making it obvious that's she's a woman. When I first read AFFC I had no clue who it was and only after found out when I read theories on it, although I guess they could make it obvious like they have everything else. I think it's more that I really hope they don't, because I don't trust them to treat her character with any care or sensitivity at all. 

 

And please remember to try and ignore the trolls :P.

I know, the name spelled backward was right in my face and never caught on until my best friend pointed it out then it was clicking. Very clever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if they finally go there with Jon and Arya warging, how they will explain it. Nothing leading up to it.

They made Arya blind, why bother if not to "warg" the cat. Or maybe a dog, since Cat and things cat are off limits.

After forgetting about Nymeria all this time, will she suddenly have a dream first? Or will they just bypass her.

 

God knows. At this rate, there'll have to be an extra season just so they can tie up loose ends.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to really believe there was a logic to their choices, even the stupid ones I hated. I have since stopped believing that. They really do seem led by what seems "coolest" or "most shocking" and it's so sad. And the things that are recognizable as "logical" plot decisions or foreshadowing are so heavy-handed it's not even funny. (Hey, remember GREYSCALE? Wait, let's talk about RHAEGAR. There are no horses but Mel just got to the Wall- WONDER WHY?)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think they'll spring Jon and maybe Arya warging on us next season. Arya was blinded - even though that sends her arc backwards so perhaps that is because they're going to have her warging. And with Jon they just wanted to make the ending as bleak as possible. They didn't want to hint at any possibility of Jon's survival beforehand because then it wouldn't be shocking enough!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They seem to be going there with the Riverlands, so Nymeria and her pack taking out Freys would be good, but she was headed north, I wonder if a reunion with Ghost might happen. Arya would be mad as hell when she found out what happened to Jon, maybe she finds out this way.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to really believe there was a logic to their choices, even the stupid ones I hated. I have since stopped believing that. They really do seem led by what seems "coolest" or "most shocking" and it's so sad. And the things that are recognizable as "logical" plot decisions or foreshadowing are so heavy-handed it's not even funny. (Hey, remember GREYSCALE? Wait, let's talk about RHAEGAR. There are no horses but Mel just got to the Wall- WONDER WHY?)

If logic and D & D ever meet, it would probably be pure coincidence. Like themes, logic is probably meant for 8th graders.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...