53 replies to this topic

[Stubby]

If we catch the board during one of the times it is not on performance mode I'll see what I can do via PM.

[SecretSquirrel]

Do not make up internet rumors about the title of the mysterious eighth book, such as calling it A Tide of Banners, or The Solstice of Ice and Fire. A Tide of Ice and Fire or The Solstice of Banners is right out.

Edited by SecretSquirrel, 01 September 2011 - 03:14 PM.

[Whatever]

mods, there are two lemore threads. Can you merge them? Thanks
Ps: the new board is great!

[Nordic Pyromancer]

Does one get a notification if a your tread gets rejected?

[Galen M]

Even Mikkelsen, on 11 September 2011 - 05:44 AM, said:

Does one get a notification if a your tread gets rejected?

no

[garion77]

I have tried to post numerous threads.  None have came through...  What is going on?  I never been on a forum that you can't even post on...

[Stubby]

garion77, on 12 September 2011 - 08:53 PM, said:

I have tried to post numerous threads.  None have came through...  What is going on?  I never been on a forum that you can't even post on...

I have been through and checked the threads you posted.

None were approved as they were all duplicate threads.

If you are having trouble with the search function while the board is in performance mode, try doing a google search such as "site:asoiaf.westeros.org + (topic)" to find existing threads.

[Qyburn's Monster]

Hi,

New to this so this is only my first post but was wondering if you start (or try to) a Thread how long does it take till its approved and do you ever find out if its not?

Thanks

Edited by Qyburn's Monster, 15 September 2011 - 10:38 AM.

[Galen M]

Since it is past 10/12, actually a week past, can we start posting in the main forum without spoiler tags?

[Stubby]

Galen M, on 19 October 2011 - 12:32 AM, said:

Since it is past 10/12, actually a week past, can we start posting in the main forum without spoiler tags?

An announcement about further ADwD posting rules will be made soon.  For the moment, the rules are to continue as before.

[protar]

I accidentally posted a thread without marking ADWD spoilers in the title. Will this still get approved? Also as it is an AA theory is it in the right place?

[Imp Slap]

Can I have some feedback on why my topic was rejected? I've checked over 25 pages of threads and while there are some topics about Theon (is he Azor Ahai, a fan thread, etc.) I couldn't find one discussing the believability of Reek. I'm not asking to be antagonistic, I'm genuinely interested in understanding the process as the whole shrouded in mystery feel makes the moderating seem whimsical and arbitrary at present.

[Angalin]

Imp Slap: there are already a lot of topics about Theon, both in the General ASOIAF forum and the ADwD forum.  On the whole, as mods we prefer that someone contribute to an already-existing thread rather than to scatter the debate further across threads for mile wide, inch deep discussions.

[Jayce]

May I ask, if a post is not approved (for what ever reason) do you message the person to tell them that it hasn't been approved with (or without) an explanation of why?

Edit: I saw a similar question above to wqhich the answer was: No.

Edited by Jayce, 02 March 2012 - 09:11 AM.