808 replies to this topic

[Trebla]

Another strong episode. Can't wait for the full BRIENNE SHOULD BE UGLIER rage! To me it's no different than the Tyrion is too handsome stuff. In this show Tyrion's problems are that he is a dwarf. Him being ugly as well isn't necessary. Brienne is tall (huge!) and a woman. That's more than enough "negatives".

Alas for Yoren. Loved his backstory.

Was interesting to see how the writers simplified some storylines. Shae working for Sansa and Arya immeditately being caught by the Lannisters. Makes sense for a 10 episode season.

I'm gonna miss Renly. Just when he was becoming more interesting.

[ckal]

And yes they really did condense A LOT into this episode which made sense. It is setting up things quicker and will allow the show to spend more time in other areas.

[The Nerdly Knight]

Jack, on 15 April 2012 - 08:58 PM, said:

...The Craster scene was kind of strange.  I was surprised that Mormont was so accepting of the fact that Craster gives his sons to the others.

Keep in mind he has the same attitude in the book. Where they are the laws are different, in fact Craster has no law to bend to beyond the Wall that would match what those men were use to. By "doing something" about his actions they would have lost an ally who had always provided food and shelter to the Night's Watch as well as potentially caused a host of other ethical and legal issues as well.

Edited by The Nerdly Knight, 15 April 2012 - 09:03 PM.

[Megara]

WuTangWesteros, on 15 April 2012 - 08:54 PM, said:

great episode, only thing i didn't like was Shae/Sansa.

I hated that scene, I really think Sansa was way too out of character =7 ...

[Mya Stone]

Josephxoxo, on 15 April 2012 - 08:57 PM, said:

Way to much homoism. it's unattractive and not a very important part of the show.

Seriously? You realize you don't HAVE to type everything the little homophobic voice in your head tells you to, right?


I loved this episode. Thought it greatly improved on the first 2 of the season. Not one wasted scene. Liked how they condensed Shae's arc from bouncing from brothel to Lollys to Sansa.

Loved how Sansa's hair was exactly like Cersei's. Thought it was a nice touch. Also loved Lena's rage at Myrcella being sent away. Finally seeing shades of book Cersei.

I'll have more to add after I watch it again.

[Boar Hunter]

I keep seeing people say the scene between Sansa and Shae was no good. But if you think about it, they are really just staying true to the book and the crap that was that chapter.

PWND hahaha

[Trebla]

ckal, on 15 April 2012 - 08:57 PM, said:

Only things I didn't like where the Renly/Loras/Margeary and Sansa/Shae scenes. Everything else was really great. Probably the best episode so far this season.

The ménage à trois worked for me. Shae didn't. I don't know, I just find  tv Shae completely uninteresting.

[Jack's Smirking Revenge]

Josephxoxo, on 15 April 2012 - 08:57 PM, said:

Way to much homoism. it's unattractive and not a very important part of the show.

I liked that scene.  I liked Loras for the first time in this episode.  I think it's important to establish Margarey and Loras for the benefit of future seasons.

Also all they did was kiss...I mean you didn't see Renly give him a BJ...also "unattractive"?  Also it explains the actions of Loras in future seasons.

[CrypticWeirwood]

Josephxoxo, on 15 April 2012 - 08:57 PM, said:

Way to much homoism. it's unattractive and not a very important part of the show.

Whoa!!  Did you really just say that? Really?

It’s plenty attractive.  Indeed  tt’s quite a bit more attractive than a lot of the senseless banging and gratuitous tit scenes going on in this series.

I doubt that it’s there just to make you uncomfortable, although if it were, well, that would be ok, too.

Edited by CrypticWeirwood, 15 April 2012 - 09:09 PM.

[Ser Joe of House Targaryen]

I agree about TV Shae. Not sure if its the writing or the actress, but she is far less interesting on the show than she is in the book. I wish they'd fix that.

[Mya Stone]

Trebla, on 15 April 2012 - 09:01 PM, said:

Another strong episode. Can't wait for the full BRIENNE SHOULD BE UGLIER rage! To me it's no different than the Tyrion is too handsome stuff. In this show Tyrion's problems are that he is a dwarf. Him being ugly as well isn't necessary. Brienne is tall (huge!) and a woman. That's more than enough "negatives".

Alas for Yoren. Loved his backstory.

Was interesting to see how the writers simplified some storylines. Shae working for Sansa and Arya immeditately being caught by the Lannisters. Makes sense for a 10 episode season.

I'm gonna miss Renly. Just when he was becoming more interesting.

This times 100. But I love Brienne's look. I think she looks amazing. And she's f-ing HUGE, Trebs. HUGE.

I appreciate Yoren's story as a segue into Arya's own prayer. I'm really liking the choices the writers are making in condensing the book.

[Nymphetamine]

Thought it was a great episode. Would have liked to have seen some Davos, Stannis and Mel though.

[Boar Hunter]

dtones520, on 15 April 2012 - 09:00 PM, said:

It's important to build Renly as a character. To show a rather arrogant man in all other aspects of being a king, but his duty to provide an heir, he cannot do because of his sexuality.

Interestingly to readers, Margery acknowledges Renly and Loras' relationship, and is more than okay with Renly getting his nut in whatever way he has to.

She is so much older in the show that it really changes the sexual dynamic that is so important to her story.

[redraike]

I liked the part where Will Smith punches the alien in the face and says 'Welcome to Earth!'

Oh wait.  Wrong forum.

[Ramsay Gimp]

legba11, on 15 April 2012 - 09:00 PM, said:

  I wonder how many purist heads exploded when they read Theon's letter?

I liked that part. Theon's arrogance/cockiness seems to be toned down a bit for the show

Though some of Asha's cruel remarks toward him seem forced.

[Lord Godric]

Trebla, on 15 April 2012 - 09:01 PM, said:

I'm gonna miss Renly. Just when he was becoming more interesting.

Same here.  The show has fleshed out his character more than the books did and just as he becomes a character worth getting behind, he's gonna die.  I think his death will be more heartbreaking on the show than it was in the books.

[Josephxoxo]

Quote

It's in the books and it's hypocritical to not bitch about "heteroism."

They could have displayed the same thing without all the making out. It was so unneccessary. I don't bitch about heteroism because every scene in the show so far displayed a purpose. (Jaime and Cersei in the tower for example.)

[Ser Lany Cassandra]

Great Episode!  Loved every minute of it.  I like how they have streamlined Shae's story line.  We really don't need Lorrys--Bronn can marry someone who has not been scene on-screen---her name/title is what matters.

[Jack's Smirking Revenge]

Josephxoxo, on 15 April 2012 - 09:09 PM, said:

They could have displayed the same thing without all the making out. It was so unneccessary. I don't bitch about heteroism because every scene in the show so far displayed a purpose. (Jaime and Cersei in the tower for example.)

Nothing was wrong with it though. It wasn't gratuitous like the scene where the chick is fingering the other chick while Littlefinger was talking.  I have a feeling it bothered you seeing two men making out.

Edited by Jack's Smirking Revenge, 15 April 2012 - 09:14 PM.

[Bran the Bummer]

Josephxoxo, on 15 April 2012 - 08:57 PM, said:

Way to much homoism. it's unattractive and not a very important part of the show.

Wow, not even sure where to begin. I admit I am curious why the use of "homoism." Either you mean deference to gay people, which is certainly ridiculous because we've seen more breeding and inbreeding than is really "important" without seeing so much as a bare backside from Loras or Renly. Or you mean homosexuality generally, though you feel some need to demean gay people in the process. As others have already pointed out, it's important to show how different Renly's relationship with Loras and Margaery were and how it affected his decisions. If anything is unattractive here, it's your base opinion.