mormont, on 25 April 2012 - 02:33 PM, said:
He'd surely like to think so: but one thing that he'll never have over Guardiola is that he'll never be recognised as an influential thinker about the game. Guardiola has a distinctive and (IMO) influential philosophy on how to play the game: Mourinho is only a win-at-all-costs mercenary. The most distinctive thing about his approach is that he's been quite happy to make even the biggest teams in the world play ugly football if he thinks there might possibly be an advantage in it. Not really what I'd call a legacy.
Interesting first half: the tie's completely even now. I think Real are looking more likely, though, as Bayern look vulnerable in defence, Boateng especially.
Eh, I don't know. Guardiola will go down favorably in history because his teams play a more attractive style, and that will win him points in people's hearts- but he's now lost the league to Mourinho, and his CL problems have frequently come at the hands of Mourinho-influenced sides (Chelsea, Inter). If we're going to give him credit for the Tiki-Taka game (rather than, say, Cruyff and his Total Football vision, which I think you could argue is the real idea for which Pep is just the executor), then you've gotta give him the blame for not being able to handle this counter, even though Mourinho-style sides parking the bus against Barca isn't exactly a groundbreakingly new idea.
And frankly, I'd say Mourinho's philosophy is as distinctive and influential as Guardiola's- the issue for him legacy wise is that everyone hates his philosophy and loves Pep's. Which is fair, Barca are certainly more attractive (speaking objectively)... but I agree with John, when it's your team, and you watch them more than other sides, you learn to enjoy the sort of disciplined, 1-0 deconstructions of the opposition that '07/'08 Chelsea were capable of.
ETA: Oh, right, a point I intended to make about Bayern-Real: Both are fielding very nice starting XIs, but holy shit, look at the benches. See anyone you recognize among the Bayern subs? Thomas Muller, I guess, and maybe Pranjic. Whereas sitting on the Real bench- Kaka, Higuain, Albiol, Coentrao. I think Real wins the game in extra time because they can do shit like take off Di Maria for Kaka.
Edited by DVD ROTS, 25 April 2012 - 03:32 PM.