61 replies to this topic

[Malgarroth]

Thought this would be a little bit of fun.
Make two lists, one of theories you believe and one of theories you flat out disagree with.

Here's mine.

Theories I Subscribe To

R+L=J (ofc)
Coldhands is Benjen.
Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
Jon is Azor Ahai
Jaime will kill Cersei

Theories I Disagree With

The Faceless Man conspiracy.
Aegon isn't Aegon.

Will add more if I've missed any when I remember them.


Added list from me:

Crackpot Theories I'd Really Like To Be True

Hodor is Rhaegar
Ned's Bones will be reanimated and he will guard the Winterfell Crypts for eternity.
Jojen Reed doesn't exist, he's Howland Reed.

Edited by Malgarroth, 06 June 2012 - 10:24 AM.

[Lady Hodor]

Agreed Theories:
- Jaime will kill Cersei
- Jeyne Westerling is pregnant
- Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
- Aegon isn't Aegon

Disagreed Theories:
- Rhaegar + Lyanna = Jon
- Jon/Dany/Aegon is Azor Ahai
- Coldhands is Benjen

What exactly is the Faceless Man Conspiracy? I've heard so many different ones.

Edited by Lady Hodor, 06 June 2012 - 10:52 AM.

[Lord Damian]

R+L = J
Cersei and Jaime are Aerys II kids with Joanna Lannister, not Tyrion
Aegon decends from the Blackfyre line through his mother and Ilyrio or through Illyrio's mother.
Littlefinger is in league of sorts with Varys, his role was to commit financial chaos for the realm
Benjen is not Coldhands but is alive in the Land of Always Winter surviving and scouting the others.

[Malgarroth]

Lady Hodor, on 06 June 2012 - 10:51 AM, said:

What exactly is the Faceless Man Conspiracy? I've heard so many different ones.

The one I'm referring to is the one that essentially boils down to: The Faceless Men are in league with the Others and their "All men must die" line literally means they're out to destroy all life.

[COYStars]

Agreed Theories:
- Jaime will kill Cersei
- Rhaegar + Lyanna = Jon
- Aegon is a Blackfyre

Disagreed Theories:
- Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
-The Faceless Man conspiracy.
- Jon/Dany/Aegon is Azor Ahai
- Coldhands is Benjen

I'm sure there are many that I'm missing...

[Walder Waters]

- R+L=J
- Lightbringer=NW
- Jaime kills Cersei
- Aegon=Blackfyre
- Varys=Blackfyre
- Illyrio Mopatis=Aegon's father

[Cheese Pudding]

Agreed:

Jaime will kill Cersei
R + L = J
Aegon isn't Aegon
Jon is AAR

Disagreed:

Tyrion is Aery's son
Coldhands is Benjen
Ashara is Lemore

[Babeldygob]

Theories I Subscribe To

R+L=J
Jon is Azor Ahai
Jaime will kill Cersei
Stannis is the Night's King come again
Varys is a Faceless Man
Robert Strong is the Headless Mountain
Aegon Blackfyre
Bran can talk through weirwoods with faces
Jeyne Westerling is pregnant
Benjen is alive
Hooded Man is Theon and he did at least a few of the murders
The Hound = The Gravedigger
Dany going crazy
Aegon marries Sansa
Wyman crowns Rickon King in the North
Religions and Gods mean less than what they represent
Lemore = Ashara
Euron killed Balon indirectly(FM)
Mirri Maz Duhr prophecy is coming true
Bloodraven wargs Balerion
Alleras is Sarella
Maesters conspire to something dark
Pate = Jaqen

Theories I Disagree With

Coldhands is Benjen
Jojen Paste
Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
Aerys + Joanna = Cersei & Jaime
NW is Lightbringer
Syrio = Jaqen
Ashara + Ned = ?
Varys isn't a eunuch

Edited by Babeldygob, 23 June 2012 - 08:26 PM.

[COYStars]

What's the basis for the Jeyne Westerling being pregnant theory? Hadn't seen that before.

P.S. I hasn't included Robert Strong as Un-Gregor because I don't think anyone could argue against it, given what we know from the books. I'm not even seeing it as a twist. Does anyone really believe otherwise?

[The Wight Walker]

I can't say i feel 100% about any unknown theory, however

Quite sure of:
Aegon is not what he seems to be
Jaime killing cersei (or at least screwing her over big time)
The great mystery of Robert Strong (saracsm)

Disagree with:
Tyrion being a targ
Coldhands being benjen
Faceless men being in line with others
Various characters which have been linked to "the great other"

What i sure hope is true:
Jaime & Cersei are targs
Dany is insane, or getting there
Also, hadn't thought of jojen being howland, however i do quite like that
Either patchface or Hodor better have some unknown significance
The hound was not the grave digger, hasdn't had some spiritual awakening, and is still angry as ever waiting to kick some (preferably robert strong) ass.

Edited by The Wight Walker, 06 June 2012 - 11:22 AM.

[PlainJane]

Theories I Subscribe To:
R+L=J
Aegon isn't Aegon
Jon is Azor Ahai
Jaime will kill Cersei
Robert Strong is the Mountain
Benjen is alive

Theories I Disagree With:
Coldhands = Benjen
Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
Jeyne Westerling being pregnant

[Trinket2]

Theories I Subscribe To

R+L=J (unfortunately)
Jeyne Westerling is pregnant (unfortunately)
Aerys + Joanna = Tyrion
Jon is Azor Ahai (again, unfortunately)
Jaime will kill Cersei
Aegon isn't Aegon
Benjen is not Coldhands but is alive in the Land of Always Winter surviving and scouting the others.
Robert Strong is the Mountain
Jojen paste
the hound=the gravedigger

I'm also hoping on the Dany is insane theory.


Haven't heard about the Stannis= night's king come again. Sounds interesting, will have to read up on that one.

Edited by Trinket2, 06 June 2012 - 11:30 AM.

[Completely Headless Ned]

Agree
R+l=J
Jon =AA/TPTWP
Tyrion/Jon/Dan being the dragon riders.
Robert strong is the mountain with or without a head
Benjen is still alive

Disagree
any of the lannisters being targs.
Dany being crazy. At least not yet.

On the fence about
Jaime killing Cersei
Aegon not being aegon

[Winter's Knight]

Agree:
R+L=J
Aegon is a Blackfyre
Stannis shall be the Night King
Dany is TPtWP, Jon is AA and Bran is the Last Hero and they are the three heads of the dragon.

Disagree:
Secret Lannister Targs
Jaime will kill Cersei

Crackpots I want to come true:
Briennsa
Varys is PtWP

[Babeldygob]

COYStars, on 06 June 2012 - 11:14 AM, said:

What's the basis for the Jeyne Westerling being pregnant theory? Hadn't seen that before.

P.S. I hasn't included Robert Strong as Un-Gregor because I don't think anyone could argue against it, given what we know from the books. I'm not even seeing it as a twist. Does anyone really believe otherwise?

The main point of argue is whether he still has a head or not.

[Dacie]

Agree:
-R+L=J
-Aegon is a Blackfyre
-Jaime will kill Cersei
-Sansa is the younger, more beautiful queen
-Nightswatch=Lightbringer
-Dany will not be the savior of Westeros
-The Pink Letter was untrue, Stannis is not dead (yet)
-Robert Strong is unGregor
-Rickon will be Lord of Winterfell when all is said and done
-Jon will survive the attack
-Oberyn poisoned Tywin (a recent thread that was awesome!)

Disagree:
-Any of the Lannisters being secret Targs
-Dany is AA or TPtwP
-Coldhands is Benjen
-Septa Lemore is Ashara Dayne
-Dragons are Lightbringer
-The Others are the ultimate Bad Guys

Crackpot that I wish were true:
-Mance Rayder is Rhaegar Targaryen
-Jojen is actually Howland Reed

[Only Fire and Blood?]

I must be the only person who thinks Aegon is real. He supposedly has the Targaryen silver hair while the Blackfyres had black hair apparently and Tyrion comments that he is a Targaryen. Dany will cross the Narrow sea and I think Jon Snow is Azor Ahai and Rhaegar and Lyannas son.

[ermireallydontcare]

Theories I subscribe to:
R+L=J
Coldhands = Benjen Stark
Jaime will kill Cersei.
Jeyne Westerling is pregnant.
Bran can talk through weirwoods.
Robert Strong = Headless mountain.

Theories I don't believe
Faceless men conspiracy - would be in the category below except I made my mind up instantly.

Theories I only just learnt about via the forums and have yet to make my mind up about:
Aerys + Joanna = Any of the Lannisters. (Hmmm, intriguing. I might be able to understand it for Tyrion - if Tywin hated him not just because of his dwarfism and even more than we think for killing his mother given the circumstances, not so much Cersei and Jamie - incest isn't genetic.)
Aegon is a Blackfyre (I'm yet to make my mind up whether he's fake or not.)
Stannis = Night's King. (I can't even remember what that is. There's a reason I'm currently re-reading.)

As for everything else (such as who AA is) I will admit to being completely on the fence.

[Know Face Man]

Theories I subscribe to:

- Dawn is Lightbringer
- Jon Snow is Azor Ahai
- Dany is the PTWP
- Bran is the Last Hero
- Arya will end up with Dark Sister
- Septa Lemore is Ashara Dayne
- Jaime will kill Cersei
- The Hound = The Gravedigger
- Many More...

Theories I don't believe:

- Lightbringer is the Nights Watch (sorry its just not)
- AA, The PTWP and Last Hero are the same person (Jon, Dany and Bran)
- Many More...

[Arch-MaesterPhilip]

gangstamillion, on 06 June 2012 - 05:14 PM, said:

I must be the only person who thinks Aegon is real. He supposedly has the Targaryen silver hair while the Blackfyres had black hair apparently and Tyrion comments that he is a Targaryen. Dany will cross the Narrow sea and I think Jon Snow is Azor Ahai and Rhaegar and Lyannas son.

You're one of two who thinks Aegon is real.

Edited by Arch-MaesterPhilip, 06 June 2012 - 09:18 PM.