32 replies to this topic

[Bright Blue Eyes]

I have to agree with Darth Rivers, his command structure is far more servicable, maybe with the exception of the outriders.

Overall commander/reserve - me
Outriders - Blackfish
Vanguard/right - Robert.
Rear guard/left - Ned
Center - Bittersteel
Commander of cavalry in my bataille - Daemon Blackfyre. A walking (riding) morale boost where it is most needed.
Commander of the footmen in my bataille - Blackheart. Competent professional soldier.
Commander of archers in my bataille - the guy from the Golden Company
Lord Admiral - Stannis
Warden of the west - Jaime Lannister post Harrenhal. The guy started growing a brain there, and he isn't a walking morale disaster like his brother.
Warden of the east - Bronze Yohn
Warden of the south - Tarly. Gigantic asshole, but competent soldier
Warden of the north - Robb Stark

[vleeter]

Rand Al'Thor

[Mikken's Mark]

Leader of scouts- Dacey Mormont

Commander of vanguard-  Brynden Tully

Commander of rearguard- Kevan Lannister

Captain of archers- Edmure Tully

Cavalry general- Robb Stark

Commander of the left- Lord Beric Dondarrion

Commander of the right- Eddard Stark

Commander of the centre- Robert Baratheon

Commander of the reserves- Jon Connington

Admiral of the fleet- Davos Seaworth

Second in command- Edmure Tully

Commander in chief- I'd prefer more of a council style. Blackfish, Ned Stark, Jon Arryn, Robert Baratheon, Oberyn Martell, and Kevan Lannister.

Generals seven bodygaurds- Ser Jorah Mormont, Ser Barristan Selmy, Greatjon Umber, Oberyn Martell, Ser Jaime Lannister, Ser Garlan Tyrell, and Ser Arthur Dayne

[Artos Stark]

Grimwolfe, on 08 July 2012 - 06:31 PM, said:

army of the dead :trollface:

surprised no one has put Anguy for captain of archers

He crossed my mind as he is possibly the best archer in the realm but he isn't a commander.  He would be better suited serving as a captain

[Prince Doran Martell]

Leader of scouts - Brynden Tully
Commander of van guard - Gregor Clegane (I hate him but he can lead reckless charges and I wouldn't mind sacrificing him)
Commander of rear guard - Jon Arryn (he's smart enough to be able to maintain order in the ranks if there's a rout)
Captain of archers - Jon Snow (he did well when he held The Wall against the wildlings)
Cavalry general - Loras Tyrell
Commander of the left - Eddard Stark
Commander of the right - Robb Stark
Commander of the centre - Robert Baratheon
Commander of the reserves - Tywin Lannister
Admiral of the fleet - Davos Seaworth
Second in command - Stannis Baratheon
Commander in chief - Aegon the Conqueror
Generals seven bodygaurds - Arthur Dayne, Barristan Selmy, Oberyn Martell, Jaime Lannister, Addam Marbrand, Balon Swann, Jon Umber

[Moreland]

Eggo Targaryen, on 08 July 2012 - 05:53 PM, said:

Westerosi only (or permanent resident of Westeros in the case of Areo Hotah). No "historical figures" (so no Dunk, Bloodraven or Baelor Breakspear). Assuming everyone is in their prime:

Leader of scouts- Oberyn Martell
Commander of van guard- Robert Baratheon
Commander of rear guard- Tywin Lannister
Captain of archers- Beric Dondarrion
Cavalry general- Robb Stark
Commander of the left- Garlan Tyrell
Commander of the right- Jaime Lannister
Commander of the centre- Randyll Tarly
Commander of the reserves- Jon Snow
Admiral of the fleet- Stannis Baratheon
Second in command- the Blackfish, commander in the field
Commander in chief- council of Eddard Stark, Doran Martell, Tyrion Lannister, Jon Arryn, Asha Greyjoy, Willas Tyrell, and Howland Reed.
Generals seven bodygaurds- Loras Tyrell, Brienne of Tarth, Arthur Dayne, Barristan the Bold, Areo Hotah, Sandor Clegane, Greatjon Umber

[Moreland]

Only problem with a council of leaders is no decision maker. Would just end up with huge amounts if arguing and no plan

[Jedi Master Hot Pie]

Leader of scouts- Brynden Tully

Commander of van guard- Greatjon Umber

Commander of rear guard- Bastard of Nightsong (Based on the fact he held a rearguard at the Battle of Blackwater which allowed Stannis and the rest of his men to retreat).

Captain of archers- Anguy, the Dornish dude who won the Archery Tourney in KL.

Cavalry general- Loras/Garlen Tyrell

Commander of the left- Addam Marbrand.

Commander of the right- Kevan Lannister

Commander of the centre- Randyll Tarly

Commander of the reserves- Edmure Tully

Admiral of the fleet- Stannis Baratheon

Second in command- Tywin Lannister

Commander in chief- Robb Stark

Generals seven bodygaurds- Barristan Selmy, Balon Swann, Arys Oakheart, Areo Hotah, Jory Cassel, Sandor Clegane and Brienne of Tarth.

[MagnarMerlinhaus]

Ok with people just from the recent times not like rheagar or Aegon the first, also with using to OP's way mine would be:

Leader of scouts - Brynden Tully
Commander of van guard - Robb Stark
Commander of rear guard - GreatJon
Captain of archers - Jon Snow (With Anguy in his ranks hehe)
Cavalry general - Garlan Tyrell
Commander of the left - Robett Glover
Commander of the right - Roose
Commander of the centre - Robert Baratheon
Commander of the reserves - Tywin Lannister
Admiral of the fleet -  Stannis
Second in command - Eddard Stark
Commander in chief - Randall Tarly
Generals seven bodygaurds - Brienne of Tarth, Barristan the Bold, Areo Hotah, Sandor Clegane, Oberyn Martell, Jaime Lannister, Andrik the unsmiling

[Ser Areo Mace]

Leader of Scouts - Ser Addam Marbrand
Commander of Vanguard - Lord Randyll Tarly
Commander of Rearguard - Daemon Blackfyre
Captain of Archers - Brynden "Bloodraven" Rivers
Cavalry General - Ser Brynden "the Blackfish" Tully
Commander of the Left Flank - Lord Robert Baratheon
Commander of the Center - Ser Arthur "the Sword of the Morning" Dayne
Commander of the Right Flank - the GreatJon Umber
Commander of the Reserves - Ser Barristan "the Bold" Selmy
Admiral of the Fleet - Lord Stannis Baratheon (with Victarion Greyjoy and Ser Davos Seaworth as Seconds-in-Command)
Seconds-in-Command - Lord Eddard Stark and Prince Baelor "Breakspear" Targaryen
Commanding General - ME
General's Guards - Areo Hotah, Sandor Clegane, Ser Jorah Mormont, SmallJon Umber, Ser Archibald Yronwood, Lord Garlan "the Gallant" Tyrell, Ser Oswell Whent, Anguy the Archer (had to do eight)

Edited by Sir Areo Mace, 10 July 2012 - 01:04 PM.

[Petyr Baelish the First]

Leader of scouts- Ser Addam Marbrand
Commander of van guard- Ser Barristan Selmy
Commander of rear guard- Lord Randyll Tarly
Captain of archers- Ser Balon Swann
Cavalry general- Ser Jaime Lannister
Commander of the left- Lord Tywin Lannister
Commander of the right- Victarion Greyjoy
Commander of the centre- Lord Stannis Baratheon
Commander of the reserves- Lord Mace Tyrell
Admiral of the fleet- Paxter Redwyne
Second in command- Prince Oberyn Martell
Commander in chief-Me
Generals seven bodygaurds- Lucas Blackwood, Ser Loras Tyrell, Ser Arys Oakheart, Ser Mandon Moore, Greatjon Umber, Areo Hotah, Syrio Forel

[KhaleesiDany]

(I'm sure we all feel this way but) I definitely picked the best team!

Leader of scouts- I want a pair: Jojen and Meera Reed
Commander of van guard- Gregor Clegane. Scare 'em good!
Commander of rear guard- Brienne of Tarth. She's loyal, but I wouldn't put her anywhere in front.
Captain of archers- Jon Snow. He's not as good as Anguy but he seems to be a good teacher to others.
Cavalry general- Khal Drogo can ride better than anyone yet mentioned.
Commander of the left- Blackfish. Probably one of the smartest commanders in the series.
Commander of the right- Mance Rayder. He hits with full power.
Commander of the centre- Ser Loras Tyrell. Stay close to Renly <3<3
Commander of the reserves- Lord Renly Baratheon. He's charismatic, so the reserves will be psychologically ready.
Admiral of the fleet- Victarion Greyjoy, duh.
Second in command- Prince Oberyn Martell.
Commander in chief- Danaerys Stormborn.
Generals seven bodygaurds- Sandor Clegane, Barristan Selmy, Strong Belwas, Visyrion, Rhaegon, Drogon, and Arya Stark. No one gets through.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's an unstoppable army.

[Ser Areo Mace]

Using Darth Rivers's command structure due to it being the correct way (I like the OP's breakdown but I'm trying this one too)



Overall Commander- Lord Eddard "the Ned" Stark
Overall Commander's Honor Guard- (the Honor guard has no limit as opposed to the KG
(LC) Ser Gerold "the White Bull" Hightower
Ser Barristan "the Bold" Selmy
Ser Aegor "Bittersteel" Rivers
Ser Archibald Yronwood
Areo Hotah
SmallJon Umber
Sandor "the Hound" Clegane
Anguy the Archer
Ser Oswell Whent
Ser Arys Oakheart
Ser Balon Swann
Vanguard/Right- Lord Robert "the Demon of the Trident" Baratheon
Rear guard/Left- Prince Baelor "Breakspear" Targaryen
Reserve- Ser Arthur "the Sword of the Morning" Dayne
Commander of the Footmen in my Bataille- Ser Daemon Blackfyre
Commander of the Archers in my Bataille- Brynden "Bloodraven" Rivers
Command of the Cavalry in my Bataille- Ser Brynden "the Blackfish" Tully
Captains of the Outriders- Ser Addam Marbrand
Lord Admiral- Lord Stannis "the Mannis" Baratheon (with Ser Davos Seaworth and Victarion Greyjoy as Second-in-Command)
Warden of the West- Lord Tywin Lannister (if Tywin has a reason to be loyal to you then he's the best choice)
Warden of the East- Lord Jon Arryn
Wardens of the South- Lord Randyll Tarly and Lord Garlan "the Gallant" Tyrell
Wardens of the North- Benjen Stark and Robb Stark