Anythingatall

Members
  • Content count

    783
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Anythingatall

  • Rank
    Council Member

Recent Profile Visitors

728 profile views
  1. Well in that case conquering doesn't make you the rightful heir either and therefore the 7 kingdoms doesn't exist and Jon Snow still isn't the right heir to anything** **I suppose one could argue that Bran/Sam was saying he was Danys heir which actually makes sense if they had decided to bend the knee.
  2. You thought right but they were overthrown so none of them were the "rightful heir".
  3. No because they were usurped. Otherwise Dany would have been the Queen prior to the Aegon reveal.
  4. I think your partially right but I also think some of it is a result of problems with the book series. They needed to do something at Winterfell, they needed a "big" character death and they needed to get rid of LF 'cos he plays no role in the end game. The way they went about it was terrible. I imagine the reasons were irony, his plans coming undone as a direct result of a "cunning plot". The Sansa/Arya/Bran relationship should have been the focus and they should have fit LF's down fall in this. Instead they did it the other way round, Sansa et al had to act in that way for LFs story. It's shitty writing pure and simple. How about something like this instead - 1- Stark kids reunion 2- Mistrust between all three but not outright hostility. After everything they have been through and the fact they weren't exactly bessie buds prior some mistrust would be expected. 3- LF starts his plan, Bran immediately grasses him up to Arya. She stabs the shit out of him. 4-The rest of the season can then be dedicated to the fallout of this. Will Sansa think that Arya cunningly disposed of her smartest ally? Will Bran mistrust Arya seeing how violently she reacted to the information? Will Sansa think Arya/Bran are coluding against her? What of the Vale Lords? etc etc. So much potential. Plus how shocking would that be? LF brutally murdered early on in the series? Aww well. I wont mention the acting (although obvs I have) but I do think it plays a role. I don't understand what they are doing with her at all. That whole Dickon/Randyl thing baffled me. What was the problem? Tyrion made zero sense. Loads of the soldiers didn't kneel, where they to jail them all? Quite honestly that seems like a good deal in a war. Be on the losing side, refuse to kneel, sit out the rest of the war in a nice cell with food and water. Tarly had betrayed Olenna who died as a result. Plus Tyrions reasoning was "Wont somebody think of the Old Houses!?"... but if you are so hawt for the old ways then surely they should die for betraying their liege lady. Anyway the point is the show wants us to think this was bad. Then... totally forgot about it. I mean the "Game of Thrones" doesn't have that much life left in it. Can Dany go totes Mad Queen in 6 episodes? Whose she gonna go Mad Queen on? The army of the dead? Part of me thinks they just did it to fuck with book readers who are convinced shes batshit. I agree with you here, the showrunners wanted the main characters to get together and have all those reunions and I don't think they will get another chance. I actually give this one a pass. I think they are patching up book stuff that simply can't be explained in the context of the show. My guess is that he is called Aegon in the books and he was legitimate somehow and both those things make total sense but have complex reasoning behind them that requires background (or page time) we don't have in the show. Here is an interesting question though. How come he is the legitimate heir to the Iron Throne? I can't remember if it was Sam or Bran who said this but either way it doesn't matter. So let's accept whichever one said it was privvy to Jons letter saying he had bent the knee and accepted this. It doesn't matter, Dany is attempting to be a ruler by conquest, the legitimate heir is probably some Baratheon 3rd cousin. Even if they accept Dans rule then as I said she rules because she conquered. Her reasoning may be cos her Dad was king but the actual reasons are Dragons, Dothraki and Unsullied.
  5. I'm not ashamed to say I enjoyed all the fan service. The nods to earlier seasons, the reunions etc. It made not a lick of fucking sense but I am cool with that, at this point I am convinced it doesn't make sense because it can't as the source material setting up something it simply cannot pay off. Lena Headley was great and I thought Emilia Clarke did better this week. Maisie Williams is amazing as always, it's lovely to know that her poor "acting" in the last couple of episodes was because she was, indeed, because Arya was acting.
  6. Urgh Talisa. I wouldn't have minded if she was marginally interesting. The writers sat down and came up with 'Things Writers Think Characterise Strong Women'. Jeyne on the other hand is a really intriguing character. I find the conspiracy theories about the Westerlings to be quite convincing but even that aside (for fanwank does not an interesting character make) we have this 'girl' who is just pretty, and nice and kind (dull as dishwater) and then when she is widowed we see something completely unexpected. Do I want to know more? Nah, but's it's cool that GRRM plays with our exceptions. Jeyne was supposed to be 'just some girl' (indeed thats why I like the arc) but he adds something, a little spice. It's pretty cool. The show butchered Shae in a similar way. She couldn't be a lazy but clever prostitute that Tyrion viewed with rose tinted glasses. In fact now I think about Shae is basically Talisa-in-hard-times.
  7. Couldn't agree more. The whole Dorne thing is an utter mess . Preston Jacobs really hammered this home for me in his insane video, he (obviously) didn't convince me that his theory was correct but he did inadvertently demonstrate just how full of holes that whole story line is. It's a shame for a number of reasons. For me, as a reader, it really sullies the story as a whole. I was a bit of a zealot before I started coming to these boards and analysing the story a bit more. Then again part of this is because the books aren't finished. If GRRM can write well enough to distract from the fact this stuff is actually nonsensical then I'm cool with it
  8. Getting Tyrion (and even Asha and Theon) to Mereen and with Dany. The Tywin stuff. Almost everything they left out I agree with, it's too much to list so I will list stuff I wish they had kept instead- Satin, original flavour Jayne Westerling, Edmure not being a nob. /list.
  9. I'm vegan and I wouldn't mind either way.
  10. I'm impressed that you understood it. I have read it three times and am still confused.
  11. So much better. The whole season has been horribly paced. It truly is baffling.
  12. I saw it as the smaller dragons following Drogons lead.
  13. My exact words when I watched it. Also this.
  14. I liked Sansa more in the show this season than I ever have in the books. Not sure how I felt about the dog scene as I hate that trope.