• Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Stormking902

  1. Where is some text claiming the Freys are even top 20 in terms of wealth??? The Frey are not richer then the Manderlys or the Starks for that matter, the Freys do not have enough traffic useing the bridge they built to be extremly wealthy, also house Frey is HUGE could you imagine the cost of feeding all of your family anually?? Can you imagin the cost of Armour and weapons for all male kin?? Can you imagine the Dowrys spent on Walders numerous mariage arrangments? Up keep of the twins and paying taxs to Riverrunn.......... Trust me house Frey are not as rich as you believe they are.
  2. This is for fun I know it wouldnt actually happen because the current Tyrells are closely related and on very good terms or so it would appear anyways. The setting of this challenge takes place right after Mace Tyrell declares for Renly you decide this is a perfect moment to take Highgarden from the lowly stewards who are the Tyrells mostly because you need control of the Reach because of what you and your daughter are working on for the last decade locked in the Hightower, in order for your plan to succeed you need ALL of the Reachs army at your command and magical book the Gardeners have kept in HG for hundreds of years...... Why not ask the Tyrells for the book?? Because if the book was read the Tyrells would know about the dark magic Leyton intends to release upon Westeros and never come up off it.
  3. Wrong the Manderlys are far richer then the Freys since they control White Harbour which is a city, also they have trade ships they use to trade with the rest of Westeros and Essos so were talking big money. The Freys control a bridge that is only used when trading with the North or the North trading with the RL..... If the North was trading any where else in Westeros they would just use White Harbours fleet to do so and cut costs and time. The Freys are rich but still behind the Tullys and every other LP even house Greyjoy are probably richer then the Freys by a hair.
  4. Read to acheive.......
  5. IMO Aerys was aware that numerous Great lords were working together to have Rhegar replace Aerys as king of Westeros and I believe houses Stark, Arryn, and Royce were involved in this plot so Aerys rightfully orded there deaths but Ethan on the other hand was just a Glover which isnt even a noble house to boot so he and his family had no wrong doing. I think Aerys was mad for certain and extremly paranoid which is a very bad combo but I believe he was justifiably paranoid since numerous people did want him removed or murded and one of these people was his own son Rhegar, but I believe he still had an ounce of good left where he didnt wanna kill innocent people untill the end where his mind finally Snapped in half and he thought everyone was guilty.
  6. If Jon turned over Ned and Bob he would of insured house Arryns destruction for numerous reasons which I will list a few. 1) The Vale lords would not respect Jon Arryn at all if he turned over his two Wards who just so happen to be great lords and completly innocent of any wrong doing especially after Aerys just killed your nephew and heir for again absolutely NO reason, I cant see a lord who would allow this especially Yohn Royce who would probably start a civil war. 2) The North and Stormlands and a few Riverlords would never forgive house Arryn and would work diligently towards their destruction. 3) A new Dance of dragons would happen between Rhegar and Aerys and since the crown would be busy there would be no help for the Vale if the North and Stormlands attacked the Vale. I suspect Rhegar would win this war and as the new king of Westeros would demand Jon Arryns head and probably even the Eyrie which the Vale lords would allow him to do no contest.
  7. In Essos you would think the need of sell swords would be great with all of the free cities pretty much always fighting between themselves not to mention the constant threat of the Dothraki.
  8. The Tullys were considered one of the strongest houses of the Riverlands for centuries before Aegon and his sisters arrived in Westeros, they witnessed River kings come and go and new houses rise and old houses be completely wiped out. The Tullys are the strongest house in the Riverlands at the time of Aegons conquest and Edmyn Tully rallied the riverlords to Aegons side not Aegon rallied the Riverlords so credit is due. For Edmyn Tullys help gathering the Riverlords and because house Tully was already known amongst their peers to be one of if not the strongest of the Riverlords he was givin the title of LP, you make it seem like the Tullys were just some up jumped stewards like the Tyrells lol. The Riverlords gladly accepted the Tully rule and benefited from it for the most part for the next 300 years. Also a side not unrelated to this....... Edmure Tully defeated Tywin Lannister in the battle of the stone mill........ Not even Stannis can claim such a thing and Stannis is the Chuck Norris of Westeros IMO.
  9. I could be wrong but its never mentioned if Mel had ever had the oppurtunity to have king Roberts ear even for a short amount of time, I believe if she did he would have become smittin with her in a way due to her confidence and hell she could easily drink Robert under the table due to her abilities which make her immune to poison lol. If she did manage to out drink Robert im sure he would keep her around either for that or her beauty and over time if Robert sees the magical things shes capable of he might allow her to spread the word of Rhollar around Westeros.
  10. Hoster would never have betrayed the Targs if it wasnt for Aerys insane actions of killing nobles for no reason without trials and then ordering the heads of Robert and Ned which was the last straw for everyone of the rebels, Hostet was faced with a decision stay loyal to a mad man or join the Rebels and get STRONG mariages out of them for your daughters. Also people tend to forget the RL is in smack in the middle of the North, Vale, and Stormlands if Hoster didnt agree to join the rebels his lands would be attacked from ALL sides and with Tywin staying neutral who was Hoster counting on to save them???? The Iron born??? I think not lol.
  11. Robert was known to be a good drinking buddy of Thoros of Myr who was also a red priest who was sent to Westeros to convert king Aerys, who just happens to light his sword on fire before he starts a fight. If Robert could enjoy his company im sure he could enjoy a beautiful woman like Mels company lol.
  12. Lets say Rhegar left a will declaring Jon Snow who is still a bastard his son and heir can a bastard son inherit before a true born aunt or uncle (Danny) or would she come first? Also lets say Rhegar also legitimises Jon with the same stroke of pen can Rhegar do this since he was technically never king or no??
  13. House Stark of old, they were strong rulers both cold and calculating and easily inspired the loyalty of all of there bannerman even house Bolton respected the Starks to some degree or another. Ned Stark and his children are not like most Northmen since Eddard was raised in the Vale and gained their sense or honour and duty which is Eddards and Robbs biggest downfalls IMO.
  14. What most of you are forgetting is Rhegar was the king all of Westeros wanted not Viserys or Danny so if a son of the beloved prince Rhegar shows up he will be welcomed far more then any other claimant.
  15. Yes but a bastard of a lord can still inherit lands and some times even titles from there lord father which at least Dragonstone is technically Rhegars since Rhegar is Aerys heir. Rhegar is an unusual case since he is the kings true born heir so when Rhegar and Aerys both die Rhegars heir should be king no?? Think of history someone has to inherit the lands of their house its not like Rhegars heir has no rights to the kingdom becaue he obviously does.
  16. Man the Dothraki dont stand a chance and never would without help from dragons period, they have no armor and weapons that basically have no effect against plate armor unless your good enough to shoot an arrow through his eye which is almost impossible while on a battlefield fighting. Westeros has better everything including battle tactics. If I was a commander in Westeros I would lure the dothraki into the open which they believe is there advantage but I would lace the ground with tens of thousands of sharp spikes and hidden holes so the horses would immediatly throw the dothraki off there back making them very easy pickings for my vanguard I send in on foot, My plan is very time consuming but well worth the results.
  17. Summerhall and the laughing storm rebellion
  18. IMO its a great match for Leyton for numerous reasons but the two that really stand out to me are. 1) Leyton has numerous daughters one who is married to Lord Tyrell, and at least two that are older then Lynnese and they married knights which means Lynnese actually has a better match then even they do since Jorah is a lord and a famous knight who was knighted by the king himself. 2) Lynnese probably cost him to much money to keep in oldtown so thus BOOM send her north lol.
  19. If Renly was to make Roberts known bastards Baratheons and made Edric heir to Storms End not KL since the Tyrells still want Marg as queen and there sons/daughters heir to the throne, Renly would have 2 Baratheons to offer to either Robb or Sweet Robin, maybe even the Martells etc. Is this a smart move or dumb????
  20. You mad bruh??
  21. Man why do u comment on these what if threads?? Every time you say the same thing just dont click on the what if threads and go away........ Your a lil troll and noone cares about your opinions.
  22. Not true........ Edric being legitimized all hinges on Renlys claim as king, Edric claiming he has the better claim then his uncle only hurts his position since Renly couldnt technically legitimize him in the first place. Also why would Edric fight Renly to begin with if his uncle is offering him SE his fathers castle for nothing...... Edric would be happy as lord of SE if he seeked more he should have his head removed.
  23. Robb would have made a great lord of Riverrunn but Edmure would have been better IMO.
  24. IMO I do not believe GRRM created Edrics character for no reason especially since he has gone out of his way to make Edric look like a Bobby B clone with Florent ears, and a publically known bastard of Roberts then send him to Essos where Danny currently is. IMO I believe the Golden Company and Jon Con will capture Storms End and thus the Stormlands and Danny will use Edric Storm newly made Baratheon to reclaim the Stormlands and force the Storm lords to abandon Jon Con and Faegon.
  25. This sums it up rather nicely