Gurkhal

Members
  • Content count

    3,399
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Gurkhal

  • Rank
    Bannerman of Casterly Rock

Profile Information

  • Gender Male
  1. Dreadfort claimers?

    I hope that Roose and Walda's child will become lord or lady of the Dreadfort but you never know. Still if Roose losses he has kind of lost his rights by going against his liege so it will be up to the Starks or Stannis to decide what will happen with it.
  2. Will the Westerland vassals eventually fight the Lannisters?

    Most likely there will not be a civil war against the Lannisters for a few reasons. 1. All of the people that the Lannisters have pissed off are outside the West, thus no or few of their bannermen would have a real grudge to settle with House Lannister. 2. Catelyn thinks about bannermen wanting to replace their liege at one point and it is; Stark-Bolton, Tully-Frey, Tyrell-Florent, Martell-Yronwood and that the Lannisters HAD Tarbeck and Reyne. There don't seem to be any House of importance with ambitions to replace the Lannisters and we have to my knowledge never got any foreshadowing that this might happen 3. Like the Starks and Arryns the Lannisters have the tradition of thousands of years behind their rule. That kind of thing isn't forgotten in Westeros overnight. Some bannermen might get the idea to put a puppet Lannister in the Rock but to actually replace the Lannisters is an entirely different thing But as a matter of fact I do think that there will be a forthcoming civil war within the West. Although I do believe that it will be between Cersei and Tyrion rather than between House Lannister and some other House.
  3. how would've tywin ''dealt with robert's brothers? ''

    Up until Eddard Stark got killed the conflict between the Lannisters and the Tullys and Starks were not unsolvable. Strange as it is to a 21st century humanist no or few people of importance had until that point been killed, like Lannisters, Starks or Tullys, and thus it would've been perfectly possible to make a peace between these three Houses. If a shadow baby is born the Tyrells will never fight the Lannisters. They wanted their puppet on the throne and they will not bled to put a king who despise and hate them on that throne. So even if the Tyrells won't fight the Lannisters it will come down to the West against the Stormlands+some Reachmen. The Tyrells will just go home and make their peace with the King's Landing, I can't possible see them making common cause with Stannis.
  4. how would've tywin ''dealt with robert's brothers? ''

    No, he would've faced them on the field of battle at a chosen battlefield and there contested who the crown should belong to with arms. And I might recall that Stannis and Renly still won't stand each other and that Stannis will still likely have Renly assassinated and thus split the Stormlands+some Reachmen from the Tyrells. Which will mean that Stannis will still be defeated, either by Renly if he does not kill his brother, or by Lannister-Tyrell army. The only thing that could possible defeat Tywin is if Renly is allowed to kill Stannis and thus send his army to attack King's Landing. But by that time Tywin's army is likely to have made it there and it will be a savage struggle for Renly to win the throne, although he probably would be able to do it.
  5. how would've tywin ''dealt with robert's brothers? ''

    He would probably have raised the Crownlands to add to his men as well as taking as many mercenaries with him as possible, and those sellswords who fought with Robb and Edmure might want to join a team that has a reason to give them jobs. To this he would no doubt find a good position, possibly wait at King's Landing, and there fight a battle on his own terms as he knows the Baratheon brothers will come for the capital. He would, contrary to some person notion about warfare, not charge off in a head-to-head battle and hope for the best. When he recieves news that Stannis has assassinated Renly and the Tyrells have split off he will attempt to make an alliance with them. And basically Stannis will come into an even worse battle then he did in real life and very well be smashed by Tywin before he can get to King's Landing.
  6. It don't really have to be a conscious decisions to sacrifice himself. Could just as well be Brynden who somehow called to him or the maester hoped that he would find some sanctuary in a place that's considered sacred by the Northmen.
  7. Sam and Bran I can't stand them. Arya is pretty bad but not as bad as the two mentioned before.
  8. Can The Starks Make A Comeback?

    Given all the secret Stark supporters across the North I would be very suprised if the Starks were not returned to Winterfell. In particular since its mentioned that the foundations of the castle are still standing.
  9. Depends on what you mean with "crashing down". They may well lose the Iron Throne but to be extinguished it would require something else entirely. Only in the show. In the books Tommen was safe in Rosby by that time.
  10. Would Robb make a good king?

    I totally agree with everything here.
  11. The "Bittersweet" Ending

    English is not my native language so I don't have a clue what "massive tool" means but I take it that you were trying to say something cool but I'm afraid I can't understand it.
  12. The "Bittersweet" Ending

    I would handle it fairly well. I would make a toast for the end of the Starks and I would weep for the Lannisters. But life would go on.
  13. Did Cersei murder Melara?

    I think its entirely possible that Cersei killed Melara but I wouldn't say that its certain. For one thing she does not think to herself about pushing down Melara into the well, as has already been mentioned by other posters.
  14. What region suffered the most in the war?

    To me the Riverlands easily takes the price since it has been the area of constant war right from the start, and have almost only had bad stuff happened to it. - Lannister foraging - Brave Companions - Lannister and Stark "normal" atrocities - Nymeria and her wolves - Outlaws and broken men - And now winter on top of it before they have recovered To me it seems that the Riverlands have probably suffered as much if not more than the rest of Westeros althogether in this war.
  15. Relative army strengths of the Great Houses

    This is very old, but this came as a suprise to me. I thought that 50 000 would be the absolute total the West could hope to put in the field.