Well it's more that her play doesn't make sense as innocent to me, and some of her pre flip stuff looked vaguely trollish. I guess I think she might be more...idk, upset at getting mislynched - I didn't really get that vibe from her. Symps are stupid ._.
In fact her not claiming basically secured her lynch + there was a completel lack of fight at deadline, so if she was a symp I don't think her vote on EP is as crazy as you made out earlier. There are definitely situations where a symp voting their master is okay play, and the fact Gert never really tried to fight off her wagon is kind of weird to me.
Early, Snowstorm and Tammy are all town. Well early maybe less town but still fairly town. Uh, other than that, kind of confused by the flip. Don't think anyone looks scummy for the way they pushed either wagon, really?
EP's reluctance to vote Gert doesn't make that much sense as scum? I mean, i guess he could want to stay off what is a mislynch but some of his logic, while pretty weird doesn't seem that scummy to me. Also some of his later stuff hit fairly okay emotional notes.
I guess someone like Jupiter or Walrus could be scum but I don't really have any conviction. Kingmaker's logic on uh, EP is actually super weird but I kind of think it might be townish? It feels like a ~real~ read.
Malc looked kind of lazy and not particularly concerned about stuff which I associate with town him, I think.
Ep could still be scum via POE, I guess, Monday, you I'm pretty sure on since I think you've some genuine stuff but I feel your scumhunting has been kind of off, then after that I don't really have strong town reads on Jupiter or Emmit? I think Walrus is the most likely town of the 3 "newbies" though, uh, I have a weakness for adorable clueless new players so I'm strongly biased there.