ipsuel

Members
  • Content count

    712
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About ipsuel

  • Rank
    Council Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Female

Recent Profile Visitors

1,581 profile views
  1. Who will win the battle of Winterfell?

    If Stannis is dead on the show, it leads me to believe this: When he takes Theon to the tree as is suggested in the Gift Chapter -- Asha (or anyone really) ambushes him and he dies at the tree... Giving the tree blood-sacrifice of a king. I think that's why the show had him leaned up against a tree when Brienne finds him. So *if* he's dead (lord I hope not but w/e)... I think he will be killed at the tree instead of Theon. Edit: Spelling
  2. It was a 1 for me. Most people I know didn't watch this year, so I wasn't going to, either. Then I heard about Hardhome and I had to see it. It was as amazing as everyone said. So, I went back and watched the season. But out of 10 hours, I feel like maybe 1-hour was excellent TV (Hardhome and many of the Stannis scenes). The rest was honestly just eh to me... nothing outstanding. Lots of plot holes, lots of head-scratchers and lots of silly, illogical, make-no-sense moments. I could complain all day, but put simply, I just don't enjoy the show like I used to. It just doesn't bring anything to my life like reading the books has. Imo, this was easily the worst season (even if it included the best 30-min bit, Hardhome) -- and I really do feel like this: When D&D need to troll fans (as in Benjen) and actors need to bold-face lie (as in Kit) it speaks volumes about the work itself.
  3. [Book Spoilers] EP510 Discussion

    Ugh. I really thought they were trying to be all cliffhanger-y til S6. Done.
  4. [Book Spoilers] EP510 Discussion

    Stannis isn't dead. No way... You can let me know how I right I am when we get behind-the-scenes pix of season 6 filming. You're welcome :)
  5. Did they say that Stannis would burn her? Or just that she would burn? They're two vastly different things (And Stannis is nowhere near her early in WoW).
  6. Did they say that Stannis would burnher? Or just that she would burn? They're two vastly different things (And Stannis is nowhere near her early in WoW).
  7. I think the difference is proper storytelling -- GRRM will lead into it in some cool way... D&D won't.
  8. How would you rate episode 410?

    Lol... well I wouldn't curse at him -- but I would critique it! Free speech and all ;-)
  9. How would you rate episode 410?

    But I'm guessing that adaptation would NOT turn out so well if he threw in random giraffes, or had Adam sitting on a puppy's head, or floating baby hedgehogs -- or any other random things, that have nothing to do with anything AND that actually change the story. And guess what? If those changes were made? I'd critique them as crap, too.
  10. How would you rate episode 410?

    Lol, Stannis is one of the ones I'm wondering about as well. I love him/Davos -- and I'm starting to get the feeling that he just doesn't play into the bigger picture the way I thought he would (from reading). I'm not sure I want to sully my reading, no matter how long the books take, for the TV show -- it's a strange place to be in. Omg, I hope you'll love it. I just started it, and it's great so far!
  11. How would you rate episode 410?

    Amen. And may I add that, included in the self-destructive changes -- are random additional scenes/dialouges that simply don't work with the characters/storylines. What bothers me most is the audacity that they clearly really believe they're improving on his story. It's just a complete head-shaker to me. And it's kinda heartbreaking because I want to love every episode... ASoIaF is my go-to series; I've done more re-reads than I care to admit, so I WANT to love GoT. :-(
  12. How would you rate episode 410?

    :agree: I don't critique just to be a b*tch. I critique because GoT is supposed to be an adaptation of a book series I happen to love. When they do something well, I shout it from the rooftops -- but when they screw up, I'm supposed to keep making excuses/allowances over and over and over again? I love some of the added things over the 4 seasons... but they are now going into fanfic of some sort. Back when we saw a convo of Robert/Cersei that wasn't in the books -- well, it made sense because neither was a POV and that convo COULD HAVE happened. Now we have CoF throwing wtf-grenades, silly skeletons attacking and Jojen dead. Not even remotely adapted from the books. Which is just silly and ARROGANT on their part. The show runners have to take the good with the bad, like the rest of us do in our jobs -- and hopefully learn/grow from it. It's part of life! Though tbh, I don't see it improving. It's had 4 years and I don't see a magical "respect GRRMs work" attitude starting now.