TalalOfDorne

Not exactly groundbreaking, but I like the Myrcella Might be Dead Theory. A theory about how Myrcella might have died after the confrontation with Hotah and his men. If there is a Parallels section, or at least parallels supporting a certain Valonqar theory, then Ill shamelessly promote my thread about the parallels between Cersei and Lysa, and how they point out to Jaime being the Valonqar :leaving: .

Something tells me that if Daemon Sand was sent to seduce JonCon, then the following will happen: Daemon succeeds but to his dismay JonCons greyscale became active again, and he then has sex with Arainne which gives her greyscale as well :bawl: . I think this might begin spreading greyscale in the South while Shireen does it in the North.

The Asha scene bothered me because she never defies her father. And she certainly isnt stupid enough to go against the entire North with just 50 men. Sansa and Tyrion having a good time is just awful. I wished they showed Stoneheart. I understand that it would make her death less dramatic, so Im hoping that she first appears in season 4 killing Freys. Stannis, laughing. I just cant get over that. Kits acting in his scene with Ygritte disappointed me. And I actually liked the Dany scene. Not as an episode ender though.

:agree:

Ros, you wont be missed.

Oh Cat. They already ruined her character, and if they mess the Red Wedding I might really be done with the show. Yeah the Northern storyline hasnt been looking good for a while now. I have to say though that I enjoyed Karstarks rampage. I can see why they introduced the Lannister kids in an earlier episode.

Something I really want to say is how happy I was when they showed the Ned and Robert scene. Ant it also sad seeing how everything went downhill after their deaths :frown5: :frown5: :frown5:

Jaimes been busy in Dragonstone??

As each episode goes by, Catelyn and Stannis are being presented less accurately :thumbsdown:, Though I did like him with Shireen, but Im not sure if its just because I think they did a great job with her. And of course too much Talisa :bang: :bang: :bang: Beric and Sandor was good. And they nailed Shireen. Jaime and Brienne was good as well. Tywin, Cersei, and Tyrion was probably the best scene. Why does it seem like they forgot about the Ironborn?

Though not in the book, Cersei and Tywin was one of my favorite scenes in the season. Though Im not sure about "him not undermining her for being a woman"

The episode was good. Arya, Jaime/Brienne, Daenerys were good. The chair changing scene with the small council was funny to me. Though I didn't like them wasting time on Pod. My only real issues were Edmure and Stannis. They made Edmure look like an idiot, even though it was Robbs mistake in the books, and dont get me started on the Blackfishs treatment of him. They are basically making Robb look like the clever, flawless character at the expense of characters like Catelyn and now Edmure. Dont have much to say about Stannis, just that the scene was very uncomfortable to watch as it really shifts away from his real character.

Qot was nice, Arya was amazing. Catelyn and Talisa was one of the worst scenes in every way. HBO is changing so much of her because they think she doesnt appeal to most of the audience.

This is great! I have a feeling Ser Barristans chapters will be among the best in the next book. And finally! Victarion and the Ironborn are here!