WhatIsDeadMayNeverLive

Yeah I expected she would burn the city to win the war. What I didn't expect is her burning the city after she had already won. It makes no sense and goes against everything her character stands for.

In isolation this was a 10/10 episode. The problem is that the characters' actions in this episode don't match their established personalities. Dany's red mist came out of nowhere, Tyrion and Varys are suddenly retarded, and Jaime is right back where he started in season 1. The only character that made sense was the Hound.

Yeah I'm a fan of the time loop theory. I'm not sure it makes any sense, but the concept sounds great.

7/10 The dialogue continues to suck. The battle was cool I guess but I've seen better.

2/10 Edmure ordered Blackfish's execution? Okay, but I'm no longer taking the show seriously.

9/10, better than anything in season 5.

I don't understand why everyone is raging about Stannis allowing Shireen to burn. Most book readers knew it was going to happen in book 6. The question is, will his men desert him now that he showed them he's a monster?

5/10 The dialogue is getting worse and worse, and Hardhome wasn't directed particulary well.

5/10 Instantly forgettable.

That whole scene was taken straight from Skyrim.

No Tysha. No Lady Stoneheart. Jojen's death (and ridiculous scene that preceded it). 6 and only because I'm generous.

What's wrong with you guys? It was the second best episode of the season.

6/10 This episode was not based on the books.

7/10. Decent, but nothing spectacular. The dialogue was not as sharp as in S3E10 which I watched just before S4E01 to refresh my memory.

Loved Bran's and Arya's scene, liked Jaime's return (you can clearly see that he's not the same man). The rest was OK, but I really missed Lady Stoneheart. The Mhysa scene was nothing special and certainly not the "final scene of ep10" material. I also didn't care for the bonding between Tyrion and Sansa. Tywin and Joff were amazing as always, I still cannot believe HBO submitted Kit for the Emmys instead of Dance. I'm sorry but the guy can't act. "Ygritte... Ygritte..." Even I can act like that. I gave the episode an 8, decent episode but could be better.