scolbert08

Noah Taylor was in Edge of Tomorrow

Interesting to compare these numbers against IMDb's ratings. In general, IMDb has a much lower variance than the forum does. Furthermore, on IMDb, Season 4 has by far the highest average rating, followed by S1, S3, and S2. Here the order is S1, S3, S2, S4. The top five episodes liked more by this forum relative to IMDb: 1. S1E8: The Pointy End (+0.03 Forum) 2. S3E5: Kissed by Fire (+0.09 IMDb) 3. S2E9: Blackwater (+0.20 IMDb) 4. S3E4: And Now His Watch Is Ended (+0.27 IMDb) 5. S1E6: A Golden Crown (+0.29 IMDb) The top five episodes liked more by IMDb relative to the forum: 1. S4E3: Breaker of Chains (+1.92 IMDb) 2. S2E10: Valar Morghulis (+1.77) 3. S3E10: Mhysa (+1.72) 4. S2E8: The Prince of Winterfell (+1.48) 5. S3E7: The Bear and the Maiden Fair (+1.46)

Better than episodes 1 and 3, not quite as good as episodes 2 or 4. I'd give it a solid 8 or 9. I don't understand how people thought that this was a dull episode. The entire beyond the wall sequence had me on the edge of my seat. All of the Vale/Lysa scenes were great and set up "Only Cat" well. I liked the reference to the Sand Snakes and to what's happening in Yunkai and Astapor, plus the ironic line about little girls not getting hurt in Dorne. Looking forward to seeing what they do with Yara vs. Ramsay next episode.