CaptainTheo

Members
  • Content count

    347
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About CaptainTheo

  • Rank
    Hedge Knight
  • Birthday 04/20/1980

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Brisbane, Australia

Recent Profile Visitors

980 profile views
  1. While I thought Jon could have used his death as a loophole to leave the Watch at that point, that's not what he did. When he came back to life, he resumed his duties as Lord Commander by executing the mutineers then resigned. Doing it this way seems more like desertion because his watch ended not at the point of his death but while he was alive (or at least undead). Also just about everybody who wasn't there would see it as deserting as they would hardly expect to believe that Jon pulled a 'Jesus'. The only person who does though seems to be Ramsay. Also it's a very big turnaround from Jon who pre-death refuses to leave the Watch for anything, even Lord of Winterfell, yet shortly after he comes back to life can't wait to get out of there and go somewhere else and happily becomes King in the North. Maybe he really did turn into a different character after his death and rebirth.
  2. Nice post. One reason for the drop-off after S4 is likely that aside from less book material, I don't believe GRRM has been helping out at all, having not written an episode since early season #4. I have similar complaints about the show. LF giving Sansa to the Boltons and not even bothering to do a background check on Ramsay was very strange indeed, and also it really didn't benefit anyone other than give LF an additional reason to ask Cersei for permission to send the Vale armies up north to liberate it. I have watched lots of clips by a YouTube poster called "The Dragon Demands" (he also posts links to his clips on forums here) and he said that basically the showrunners, for reasons best known to themselves, really wanted Sansa to be in the Ramsay/Wintefell horror story instead of cooling her heels in Vale. They even arranged for LF to head to King's Landing leaving Sansa without protection. This whole plot seemed dreadfully contrived as did lots of the other storytelling elements: Arya's plot in Braavos in season #6 was very weird. Having been threatened with death after failing to kill Lady Crane and hiding out with Needle, in the next episode Arya is walking around in broad daylight without Needle. This looks like an abandoned subplot, the initial plan being that "Arya" here was Jaqen in disguise. Not that this explains how Arya recovered so quickly with wounds that really ought to have been fatal, or how she defeated the Waif. Another plot hole is that in season #7 Arya suddenly becomes this great swordfighter despite her Braavos training mostly involving getting bashed up by the Waif. Re Arya's behaviour towards Sandra, the prevailing theory is that the writers did it to inject tension and make the audience wonder so that they could pull a switcheroo in the last episode. I don't buy the theory that it was all a big act because Arya started behaving like that before she ever found the note in Petyr's room and had not been given any particular reason to be suspicious of Petyr. Granted, this makes Arya look really bad and doesn't explain how at the end of the finale the sisters are suddenly BFFs. Note that Arya got her trial cancelled thus getting away with murdering most of House Frey (and several other people) yet LF got executed for betraying and killing a few people years ago, despite being helpful since then especially liberating Winterfell. Must be because Arya = "good" and LF = "bad". The trial didn't make a lot of sense I thought; I thought that the Knights thought it was Arya's trial initially but disliked LF enough to go along with what Sandra said. Personally I hated Littlefinger being killed off especially by one of the few people he'd actively helped. Ironically if Littlefinger hadn't ridden to the rescue and liberated Winterfell (either because Sandra didn't need him or because he'd ignored her belated request) he'd still be alive in the Vale. I didn't think that LF did send the assassin to kill Bran even on the show (in the books yes it was Joffrey), just that the dagger belonged to him. Presumably as in the books he lost it to Robert during that tournament, and Joffrey pilfered it, but the TV series never revealed this. Not really relevant to the question, but I assumed that Dany/Hizdahr never even married on the show, as it wasn't shown, and also that Hizdahr was shown being stabbed but not actually being dead. I thought it would have been a great twist for Hizdahr to have faked his death and really been the one behind the attack, but I severely doubt the writers are capable of coming up with twists like that (though GRRM is). Tyrion's intelligence seemed to take a major drop this season. Not that he was shown as being brilliant for some time before then either. He was a much more effective Hand in season #2. That was basically a suicide mission that relied on dragons and ravens travelling at light speed allowing a miraculous rescue, and in Jon's case he needed Benjen to conveniently show up. I guess the named characters did it because they realised they'd be protected by their plot armour, which they were right about other than Thoros. This should never have been annulled because as you say it had been consummated - even Rheagar taking a second wife would have made slightly more sense as Aegon the Conqueror did. Just so that Jon could unambiguously not be a bastard and instead be the Chosen One ahead of Dany in the line of succession. Just like Jon is so honourable that he will refuse to lie and then later in the episode dishonourable enough to fornicate with Dany and risk fathering a bastard, which he said he'd never do in season #1. (So much for his complaints about the girls liking Robb more than they did Jon.) There was amazing crazy amounts of teleportation going on this season. Whole armies getting from point A to point B basically instantly.
  3. So much this. Also saving her from Lysa, and liberating Winterfell. I felt really sorry for him and that Sandra and Arya had become evil. And he was a much more interesting character than either of them. I felt like it was Arya, not LF, who was causing all the trouble in Winterfell this season. (1) Commits genocide against the Freys, (2) Irrationally keeps verbally attacking Sandra (this starts before she reads the note she wrote), (3) Espionage, (4) Steals the letter from Petyr's room, and (5) kills LF before Sandra pronounces sentence. The only possible accusation against LF this season is that he planted a note for Arya to find, which he can claim (and basically does claim) that he obtained from Wolkan in order to protect Sandra's reputation and was stolen by Arya - it was well-hidden, after all. Yet Arya gets away with all this, in fact Sandra suddenly becomes nice to her in the finale, in spite of it. Not that I thought Arya should have been executed (except perhaps for her crimes against House Frey, which were not common knowledge, though Bran could have told people about that, too). But I definitely didn't think LF should have been executed. He killed nowhere near as many people as Arya did. Just compare him with Jorah, whose punishment was banishment, and Tyrion, who was given the option of taking the black and a trial by combat. Ned also was supposed to have been allowed to take the black. Even Cersei was allowed a walk of penance. LF was killed on the spot with no options.
  4. I am being extremely generous and giving it a 5; my initial reaction was to give it a 1. I actually really enjoyed the first two-thirds of the episode, with the gathering at the Dragonpit allowing the reunion between a lot of characters and some interesting stuff happened. Then it all went to pieces. + Euron pretending to flee when really he had an alternative plan was cool. + Cersei pretending to acquiesce then really not doing so was in-character. Good to see Jaime leave her at last. Although, it was a bit odd that she didn't have Gregor kill Tyrion, given how willing she was to murder people at the end of last season, including family members who weren't even her enemy. + Jon being overly loyal and honest and honourable thus causing trouble is also in character. + Glad the supposed spoiler about Cersei losing her baby wasn't true. ----- By far the worst bit was my favourite character Littlefinger out of nowhere being put on trial and in a Kangaroo Court being murdered by Sandra who he had saved at least twice and done his best to help her and give good advice. All his crimes, revealed by Bran ex machina, were years in the past. (I thought even making him take the black would be too harsh.) This whole scene was sickening. Please someone kill Sandra off early next season! Preferably Arya too. I was prepared to reduce the mark for this episode by 5 just because of this. - Sandra and Arya having been at odds all their lives, especially in the previous few episodes, magically turn into BFFs. - Theon implausibly wins a fight against a tough Ironborn fighter and this act makes the rest of the Ironborn instantly and simultaneously change their minds and go and rescue Yara who is conveniently apparently still alive. I guess violence really is the answer to everything. - Jon's real name is Aegon? Doesn't Rheagar already have a son of that name? And remember these are writers who renamed other characters in earlier seasons simply to avoid duplicating names. - Just a minor nitpick, but Rheagar, who's supposed to be ridiculously handsome (even Cersei considers him outshining Jaime by a mile), looked suspiciously like Viserys. - Jon/Dany, ugh! And I'm not referring at all to them being unknowingly aunt and nephew. Having gone on and on about honour early in the episode, Jon then immediately dishonours himself and risks fathering a bastard (the very thing he said he would never do in season #1) by sleeping with a highborn outside of marriage. This scene came out of nowhere, there was no build-up, just wham, bam, Terrible. Dany has already shown a propensity to sleep around; does she know she's sleeping with a corpse? - Apparently Viserion can now breathe ice. How ice can destroy the Wall instead of making it even more frozen is beyond me.
  5. I gave it a 3 - easily the worst episode yet this season, and worst episode to date. The only other episodes I gave a 3 were Battle of the Bastards, and Sons of the Harpy; the latter initially a 5 until it turned out that Barristan was magically dead next episode. There were only two bits I thought were kind-of cool: (1) Arya being suitably creepy with her faces, and (2) The Night King resurrecting the dead dragon as his steed. Otherwise: - Everything else Arya made no sense, I thought she acted like a complete moron in this episode, which she started doing in the previous episode. I thought Sandra explained herself perfectly well about being forced to write the letter yet Arya could not let it go and refused to listen. I don't buy the theory that Arya was only pretending this, to fool Littlefinger, because (1) Arya does not know much about LF at this stage, and (2) It's not like anyone's overhearing what Arya is saying. Also (3) Arya started behaving like this towards her sister before she ever saw the letter. I'm quite prepared to believe that it's (4) Arya was killed by the Waif offscreen in the episode 'No One' and this is really the Waif wearing Arya's face. - The Winterfell scenes felt like filler. Littlefinger (and Bran) continues to hardly be shown at all, in favour of those boring Stark sisters. Why did Sandra send Brienne away? I thought LF was advising her to keep her close as protection from Arya. Apparently it was so Brienne couldn't protect Arya from Sandra. - Unlike most episodes, I didn't find the dialogue in the Wight Hunt very interesting at all. The whole thing came across as pretty bland. - It is again blatantly obvious how all the important characters have thick plot armour, especially Jon. Of the ten who went on the expedition, the three extras are killed off plus Thoros, probably the least important named character there. - Dany travelling thousand miles in a few minutes with her dragons is a tad implausible. - For the second time, Benjen ex machina. The writers decide that they won't need him again so they have him killed off this time, even though he could easily have escaped too. There's no suspense when you know that Jon is going to be miraculously rescued again because he's the hero.
  6. Unfortunately at least my four favourite characters are now all dead: Tywin, Eddard, Littlefinger and Joffrey. Joffrey used to be my least favourite character but I miss him now, he was entertaining and a good (if weak) villain. I really miss Tywin too. Olenna and Margaery would be my favourite female characters. There's not many characters I actively like now. My three favourite would have to be: Jaime, the Hound, Beric. Least favourite: I'll leave Ellaria out because she's not going to be turning up again. This leaves it as Sandra (by a country mile), Cersei and Arya. Ironically Sansa was one of my favourite characters in the first four seasons with Arya and Cersei not far behind. Arya was still among my favourite before this season aired but she started out by committing genocide against House Frey, spent the second half of the season behaving irrationally towards her sister and capped it off by killing Littlefinger.
  7. The whole thing can be considered an example of a Kangaroo Court - it is cited as one on the TV Tropes website. LF was not officially arrested, he thought it was someone else's trial and was not given any time to prepare a defence or summon witnesses or take the black - unlike Tyrion, who was also in a Kangaroo Court but had all three options (in theory; in practice there were no witnesses available to him really). From my perspective it made Sandra look like the villain and LF the victim.
  8. Technically Sandra didn't pass sentence on LF at all. Arya murdered him with his own dagger (that he'd generously given to Bran) without a word from Sandra.
  9. I actually enjoyed more than the first half of episode... right until we got to "Arya's Trial" at Winterhell. Then everything went to pieces. By far the worst was the brutal murder of my favourite character LF by the very people who he saved, who he got Winterhell back from, especially that ungrateful b*tch Sandra, violating guest right in a sham trial. An extreme case of biting the hand that fed you. Sandra and her sister are due some very bad karma. Ned Stark would be spinning in his grave right about now at his daughters having become such monsters, anti-Starks. Not sure the showrunners realise it though. Also the whole thing came out of nowhere, apparently due to Bran ex machina. Dany/Jon. Not because it's incest (they don't know that). It came out of nowhere. We already know Dany is overly promiscuous (see: Daario) but Jon who so much has been made about being his father's son has just dishonoured himself engaging in pre-marital *** with the highest of highborns. This is the same guy who stated in season #1 that we would never father a bastard. Now Dany has had the almost unique experience of f***ing a corpse. And geez talk about everything falling into Jon's lap!! Theon. Do we seriously expect this guy can outfight that thug? And suddenly the rest of the Ironborn do a 180 and support him?? This reinforces the show's message that violence solves everything. Jon's real name is AEGON? isn't that the name of Rheagar's first son? I was under the impression that the showrunners were going out of their way to avoid name duplication (e.g. Asha/Yara, Robert/Robin) and suddenly they give two (half-)brothers the same name?? That's just dumb. 'Jaeherys' would have made way more sense. Rheagar looks uncommonly like Viserys. How can an icy wall disintegrate from a dragon breathing ice? Wouldn't that, like, solidify it even more?
  10. I absolute agree with the OP of this topic. LF gave Sansa the opportunity to opt out of the marriage, he didn't know about Ramsay and he told Ramsay to be kind to Sansa. I don't know if there is a more appropriate topic to post this in, but I was absolutely disgusted with Sandra (from my perspective, the character Sansa has been replaced by an evil doppelganger who resembles her only physically) in the finale, and screaming at the TV. I call it murder because the whole trial was a sham. This was sprung on LF out of nowhere, he wasn't given a chance to prepare for it (or demand a trial by combat), and most of the accusations against him originated from someone (Bran) who could not possibly have been there. Aside from the whole deal about the man who passes sentence should swing the sword, Arya went ahead and murdered LF without a word from Sandra (who nonetheless completely endorsed this). This, if I'm not mistaken, also violates Guest Right. The evidence was also hideously biased against LF. No mention was made of the fact that he saved Sandra and Jon and liberated Winterfell by marching in with the Vale Army, even though Sandra herself notes it at the start of the season. He was the reason they were all sitting in Winterfell. He got their home back. Apparently no good deed goes unpunished. As for his other charges: Murdering Lysa. Sandra omits the fact that he saved her life, and her statement here totally contradicts what she said late in season 4 when she said it was suicide. As LF pointed out in his final scene, Lysa would have killed Sansa if he hadn't intervened. Betraying Ned. Yes, this screwed over Ned and the Starks severely, although (1) he did warn him earlier not to trust him, and (2) LF only did this after Ned refused his suggestion to install Joffrey on the throne. A Stannis regime would have been very bad for LF. Jon Arryn's death. Lysa did this, not LF. Arya started the conflict with Sandra, not LF. (She started going off at her before she ever even saw the latter, which she decided off her own bat to steal into LF's room and steal if.) Yet Arya gets off scot-free. True, he was somewhat involved in playing Cat and Lysa against each other, though Lysa seemed pretty crazy anyway and it was her decision to do all this, and Cat's decision to arrest Tyrion. It's debatable whether playing people against each other qualifies as a crime, legally, and certainly does not warrant death. Given the life-saving assistance provided by LF to the Starks in recent seasons, I would have thought banishing him would be an appropriate punishment (similar to what Dany did to Jorah). Even making him take the black (as both Tyrion and Ned were given the chance to do) would seem to be a bit harsh. But murdering him? LF seemed like the victim in this storyline; Jon and Sandra both treated him like rubbish, despite his attempts to give Sandra more good advice and him giving his dagger to Bran. Jon told LF to leave his sister alone; a pity he didn't tell his sister to leave LF alone. I'm so upset about the finale. LF was my favourite character being the only decent villain remaining and he got betrayed and murdered by the girl he supported, mentored, saved, trained and admired, who also used to be one of my favourite characters but having turned into the opposite of what she was, is now my least favourite by a country mile.
  11. 6. While there was more interesting stuff, there were far too many plot holes for my liking. + Jorah is finally welcomed back into Dany's service. + Loved the reveal that Littlefinger knew what Arya was up to, though I'm not sure what he plans to achieve by increasing the enmity between the Stark girls. + Tyrion and Varys rightly question Dany's pyromania. + Gendry returns, at last. + Cersei being pregnant again offers interesting possibilities, one being another Joffrey. Maggy the Frog's prophecy is now even less accurate. - Jaime's plot armour is nearly as thick as Arya's was last season. Having been miraculously saved twice last episode by Dickon and Bronn, Bronn not only manages to pull him out of the water (which has somehow gotten much deeper) - pretty amazing given his plate armour - but also manages to carry him about a kilometre downstream underwater without being detected by Dany and Drogon and their army. Also Tyrion magically knows Jaime survived. - Dany having been advised to be different from Aerys and Cersei, and saying she will be, ends up behaving exactly like both of them by burning people alive. Also sorry to see Dickon and Randyl go. This looks very contrived as a means to make Sam first in line for Horn Hill. - Why on earth would Dany, or anyone for that matter (other than fellow villain Euron) want to align with Cersei? - Implausible stuff about Bronn getting in touch with Tyrion, Tyrion getting in and out of King's Landing without being captured, and Cersei somehow finding out all this and not doing anything. - Jaime and Tyrion's reunion fell flat. - Why didn't Jon stop off at Winterfell? - Arya wanting to commit mass beheadings and getting angry at Sandra for... I'm not exactly sure what. Having a nice bed? Not wanting to murder people? - The bit about Rheagar annulling his marriage was very much out of focus and implausible, as marriages can normally only be annulled if not consummated. - The Maesters at the Citadel weren't being very smart. I don't blame Sam for leaving.
  12. 8. Either this or "The Door" is my favourite episode of seasons 5-7. No other one comes close (though I haven't seen the last two episodes of this season yet). + This battle scene I actually liked, unlike the ones in "Hardhome" and "The Batte of the Bastards". Bronn and Dickon acquitted themselves well. This battle is the main reason I gave it such a high mark. - Confused as to what's going on in Winterfell. I'm guessing that Littlefinger gave the dagger to Bran in an attempt to curry favour with him. I'm not sure why Arya needs it, as she already has Needle; shouldn't Bran return it to LF if he doesn't want it? - Sandra continues to be sickeningly sceptical - again, the exact opposite of the character she replaced (Sansa) in seasons 1-3. - Arya almost besting Brienne in a swordfight is extremely implausible. The only person she had training with was Syrio way back in season #1, and was easily disarmed in seasons #3 and #4 by Thoros and the Hound respectively. - Time-wasting with those guards being reluctant to let Arya in. - Pretty implausible how the Dothraki magically appeared at Highgarden having previously been at Dragonstone.
  13. Another 7. Compared to seasons 1-4, this season, while enjoyable so far, is lacking truly enthralling moments. Dany/Jon met, but I didn't find their meeting especially interesting. Jaime/Olenna was a good scene but I'm really sad to see Olenna go. + Euron's triumphant parade. + Cersei's torture of Faullaria and Tyene. If the victims were anyone else I'd be horrified, but this pair deserved it. What's most annoying is that the person who avenges the murder of Doran is Cersei, who is now unchallenged as the worst person in Westeros. + Bran is appropriately weird having become the three-eyed raven. + Melisandre admitting to her grievous mistakes. - The Lannisters taking Highgarden is completely implausible. The Tyrell armies should have been much stronger than the Lannisters as they hadn't been depleted, and people from the Reach are good fighters. Also it's a castle and it would realistically need to be beseiged instead of magically capitulating. - Euron's fleet magically teleporting from one side of Westeros (King's Landing) to the other (Casterly Rock) is implausible. - Dany is being really arrogant and entitled, as usual. - My favourite character, Littlefinger, is hardly getting to do anything at all this season. At least this time Sandra appeared to be listening to his useful advice. Hopefully he'll get to do more later in the season. He's never been rewarded for taking back Winterfell from the Boltons. Mind you, Bran might know that he betrayed Ned and if Sandra finds out she is liable to banish him (as Dany did Jorah). Hell, Sandra might even opt for a larger punishment, ie imprisoning him or making him join the Night's Watch (as Cersei planned to do with Ned), both of which IMO are a tad harsh. - Sam's curing of Jorah's greyscale seems too much of a miracle cure, a convenient plot device.
  14. poll

    I give this one a mark of 7, an improvement on the premiere. The scenes were a bit more interesting and there were only two scenes that I really didn't like. + RIP Obara and Nymeria, getting exactly what they deserved. Go Euron! He unintentionally avenged Prince Trystane. + The war council at Dragonstone at the start of the episode, with the Queen of Thorns present. + Hot Pie turns up again! Arya was weirdly detached in this scene. + Randyl Tarly was portrayed in a more favourable light than last season. But did he really believe Cersei's BS about the Sept blowing up by accident? - Jon's inexplicable rudeness towards Littlefinger, the guy who saved them. Even if he doesn't like him, he should have at least been diplomatic to a powerful lord like LF. Not that it was very smart of LF to declare his love for Sandra. - The Grey Worm/Missandei scene. There was no build-up to this and it went on for too long. - Dany dragging Viserys' name through the dirt, the same brother who looked after her for 16 years. - Sandra somehow thinks she knows Cersei better than LF does, even though LF had been at King's Landing for years, and Sansa/Cersei didn't even interact in seasons 3 and 4. - Again, the Citadel was pretty yuck. - Davos should already told Jon that Dragonstone was full of dragonglass, because he's with Davos who spent lots of time there. - A disappointing lack of support for Jon's decision to visit Dragonstone.
  15. A bit late to the party here - only started watching this season last weekend. But I'll review each episode. I gave this one a 6. It seemed a bit scattered and had a similar problem to premieres of other seasons, in trying to cram every character into the episode, rather than actual story development. At least it didn't have a completely terrible scene like the previous premiere (Faullaria and the Sand Fakes "avenging" Oberyn and Elia by murdering the rest of their family). The production and music was really good in all episodes I've seen so far. + Jon Snow acquitted himself well as King in the North, making what I thought were good decisions and appropriately shooting down Sandra. + Arya's scene with the Lannister soldiers was nice, showing that not all Lannisters are bad (a bit like at the end of season #2, showing that not all Starks are good) and showing traces of humanity from Arya. + Euron is ok as a new villain, I guess. At least he's funny. + The Hound and the Brotherhood scene was ok with Sandor trying to right one of his wrongs. + As bad as the scene was, it was nice to see a cameo by David Bradley (Walder Frey). Which brings me to... - Arya commits genocide against House Frey. This is implausible for one (how could she arrange to have all that wine poisoned, and get as tall as and speak like Walder) and it is impossible that all the Frey men could have been involved in the Red Wedding. This is extremely hypocritical of her (two wrongs don't make a right) and establishes as a villain rather than an anti-hero(ine). Also, it's overkill; she already avenged the Red Wedding at the end of last season. This was overkill and none of the victims were on her hit list. - Everything done by Sandra. She insisted that the sons be held responsible for the sins of the fathers, even though they're kids, and argued with Jon both in private and in front of everyone. Worst of all, she expressed admiration for the worst person in Westeros (Cersei) who was also her tormentor. And she was rude to Littlefinger when it sounded like he was trying to help her. Whatever happened to Sansa who was one of my favourite characters in seasons 2-4? Sandra is pretty-much the opposite of the character she "replaced". - Add Harold Karstark to the list of characters who magically died offscreen. - Cersei's BS about Tommen betraying her when it was the other way around. - Jaime inexplicably forgiving Cersei for all her atrocities with the Sept explosion and the deaths of Kevan/Lancel not even mentioned. - The scene at the end arriving on Dragonstone, while dramatic, dragged a bit and pales in comparison to a similar one in season #1 episode #1 when King Robert's entourage arrives at Winterfell. - Sam's scenes at the Citadel. I had no idea until I read the recap that the guy who came out of the wall was Jorah.