Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

The-Targaryen-Dog

What if?

36 posts in this topic

So, i'm one of those people that always wonders what could have been if a character took a different turn or choice. For example, what if Joanna didnt die? Or Rhaegar was the brother to survive with Dany? So I thought this could be a mass topic for people to ask and answer questions and thoughts.


I'll start us off- What if Robb was the one to be paralysed by Jaime and Cersei?


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

He would have told someone and the lannisters would have had their heads on spikes.



Here's a great one: What if Robb had not gone to the Red Wedding? think of how many leaders (Balon, Tywin, Joffrey, Oberyn) people died during this span, he might have been able to "win" northern independence.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok, I will bite.

So Jon still goes to the wall...

So Robb is immobilized when Ned is arrested...does he still call the banners knowing he can't fight himself? If Bran goes in his place, he obvisouly doesn't lose the Frey partnership by hooking up with another girl.

Theon goes South in war and Robb never sends him to see Daddy and then never attacks Winterfell.

Robb stays at Winterfell and the Starks don't lose the North

Catelyn likely goes back to Winterfell since Robb is there and it hasn't been lost, or she stayed with Bran and he listens and doesn't send Theon to Iron islands

Since Winterfell isn't lost, Catelyn has no reason to release Jaime, and Karstark can have his revenge, and stays loyal to Starks.

goes on and on....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I still believe that if Joanna survived childbirth, complete ASOIAF would have been different...


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I still believe that if Joanna survived childbirth, complete ASOIAF would have been different...

Tyrion would be a completely different person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, i'm one of those people that always wonders what could have been if a character took a different turn or choice. For example, what if Joanna didnt die? Or Rhaegar was the brother to survive with Dany? So I thought this could be a mass topic for people to ask and answer questions and thoughts.

I'll start us off- What if Robb was the one to be paralysed by Jaime and Cersei?

When we consider questions such as these, we have to take into account the butterfly effect. One seemingly minor change can lead to a very different story.

If Robb the heir was paralyzed there's a good chance Ned doesn't leave Winterfell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Tyrion would be a completely different person.

Oh not just that... That is only tip of the iceberg.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh not just that... That is only tip of the iceberg.

Well, yes. Tywin would be a completely different person as well. There would be no incest, Oberyn would be married to Cersei and probably, Jaime to Lysa.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, yes. Tywin would be a completely different person as well. There would be no incest, Oberyn would be married to Cersei and probably, Jaime to Lysa.

And that would also affect RR, which would affect Wo5K etc, etc... Completely different universe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's a "what if" I recently thought of:



What if the Westerlings' maester switched the moon tea Lady Sibyl was giving Jeyne with an actual fertility drink? Jeyne's mom thinks she's preventing all chance of a pregnancy, but is being outfoxed by a guy who wears chains. Don't think it's likely, but it's a lovely thought in some ways.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here's a "what if" I recently thought of:

What if the Westerlings' maester switched the moon tea Lady Sibyl was giving Jeyne with an actual fertility drink? Jeyne's mom thinks she's preventing all chance of a pregnancy, but is being outfoxed by a guy who wears chains. Don't think it's likely, but it's a lovely thought in some ways.

Jeyne would probably get killed in the RW, like in the show, or we would get to a similar point in which we are now, but Manderly and the rest would be scheming to smuggle and hide a pregnant Jeyne. It's a cool idea, by the way

Here's another one:

What if Baelor Hightower hadn't farted that one time?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What if Jon had turned his cloak and joined the wildlings

Stannis would have killed him .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jeyne would probably get killed in the RW, like in the show, or we would get to a similar point in which we are now, but Manderly and the rest would be scheming to smuggle and hide a pregnant Jeyne. It's a cool idea, by the way

Here's another one:

What if Baelor Hightower hadn't farted that one time?

Elia would have married him and not the ass clown. Cersei would have married Rhaegar and Rhaegar would have been murdered as soon as he mentioned polygamy. She may have gave birth to a true born Aegon and Rhaenys and the Targs would have a lion married to their dragon. If Tywin remains in KL baby Aegon goes under his wing and instead of being Cersei's clone he would be Jaime's, fo that is what being under Tywin's wing looks like. He would marry Marg because would have saw the marriage fruitful, why'll Rhaenys marries Baelor's heir, the second in line to hightower and nephew to prince doran. Under Tywin the Targaryens power reaches new heights and no one, even the STAB alliance, would be able to challenge them for a hundred years. Yes all this and more I see in my crystal ball.

My question: What if Elia and kids ran to Dorne?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Stannis would have killed him .

You don't think things would have gone down somewhat differently? You're probably right, but I could see him giving more information and they would have pulled off the surprise attack on castle black

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My question: What if Elia and kids ran to Dorne?

Doran would have crowned Aegon. He could have offered to marry him to Margaery (and if it was me, I'd also offer to marry Rhaenys or Arianne to one of the Greyjoys). Mace and Paxter wouldn't have surrendered, so Storm's End eventually falls. Stannis and Renly become hostages or get killed. The rebels would have to march through the hostile Reach to get to an even more hostile Dorne, maybe even fighting Tywin (what he does in this scenario is anyone's guess) and the Ironborn (if Doran plays his cards well). So all in all, I think Robert and the rest eventually bend the knee

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My question: What if Elia and kids ran to Dorne?

They might have been able to hide them there, but it would have been safer to ship them to Essos. They could have maybe gone to Norvos with Mellario. It still would have been a life of constant fear of being found out, but they might have been able to live in relative peace and happiness for a while. And Aegon could come back one day to claim the throne. Viserys, had he known of their survival, might have married Rhaenys and not been so awful to Dany.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What if Rhaegar had a twin brother who was shipped up north as an infant/very young child and abandoned near the Wall to limit the likelihood of the two brothers starting a civil war over which of them would inherit?


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

...Bran goes in his place, he obvisouly doesn't lose the Frey partnership by hooking up with another girl.

Or he falls in love with a frog-eater.

Robb being disabled would result in Bolton or Umber leading the fight, then they return north as soon as the Iron Islanders attack, as Bolton/Umber don't appear to have southron ambitions.

What if Patchface had succeded in removing the stick from Stannis' ass?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What if Rhaegar, instead of messing around with prophecy's had took the Iron Throne from his insane father?


Actually think he was in the middle of this process, would explain why three Kingsguard, three of the best where in Dorne instead of at the Kings side.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites