Jump to content

ASOIF Guessing game XVII: Who has the worst attitude in Planetos? - guessing #15


Castellan

Recommended Posts

I think Cersei's walk of shame is supposed to be some kind of parallel to Jaime's being dragged around by the Bloody Companions and the removal of her hair equivalent to his hand - some kind of creepy idea of punishment for pride/vanity going on. So it sort of fits in the set of mutilations other characters undergo, but no, its not Cersei!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

#11 Theon

45 pts 4 lists 19 - 3

Probably qualifies as most mutilated person still walking around.

 

I tried to make a list of mutilated people (alive at some point in asoif but can be dead). Additions welcome.)

 

Loras (burning oil counts, I think)

Jaime

Jaclyn Bywater

Three finger Hobb

The one armed smith at the Wall (I get wall characters mixed up)

Pia

Myrcella

Marillion

Tyrion

Brienne

 

 

#10 One of the inadequate personalities who end up at the Wall and run amock as things deteriorate. Unattractive all round.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

#11 Theon
45 pts 4 lists 19 - 3
Probably qualifies as most mutilated person still walking around.
 
I tried to make a list of mutilated people (alive at some point in asoif but can be dead). Additions welcome.)
 
Loras (burning oil counts, I think)
Jaime
Jaclyn Bywater
Three finger Hobb
The one armed smith at the Wall (I get wall characters mixed up)
Pia
Myrcella
Marillion
Tyrion
Brienne

The one-eyed smith is Donal Noye.

You forgot:
Varys (that's a pretty important mutilation!)
Grey Worm, Stalwart Shield and all the Unsullied (ditto)
Davos
Ilyn Payne
Rorge (missing the nose)
Biter (missing the tongue)
Jack One-Eye (member of the BwB)
Mors Crowfood Umber (also eye, courtesy of the crow)
Greatjon Umber
Ollo Lophand (I almost wrote Olly Lophand, LOL)
There was Weasel's mother, who lost an arm, but she also died later of the bleeding or infection IIRC?

ETA: And Beric, of course. Though one could argue the mutilations were the least of his problems.
ETA2: And Gared.

Possibly in TWOW:
[spoiler]Poor Jeyne Poole may lose the tip of her nose due to frostbite. :( Really, wasn't everything she had been through enough?![/spoiler]
For the next clue, I'm going to gamble on Chett.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...
  • 4 weeks later...

Results that had been revealed by Castellan before we lost posts:

#8 Gregor Clegane
#9 Alliser Thorne 49 6 8-17
#10 Janos Slynt
#11 Chett
#12 Theon Greyjoy
#13 Rorge
#14 Balon Greyjoy
#15 Randyll Tarly
#16 Catelyn Tully
#17 Tywin Lannister
#18 Lysa Tully
#19 Bowen Marsh
#20 Petyr Baelish

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...