Jump to content

February 2016 Reads


mashiara

Recommended Posts

I'm working through Kushiel's Dart and quite enjoying it so far. Better than you'd think based on how so many genre readers look down on it as erotica.

Genre readers (it's really noticeable in SFF in particular) have a massive aversion to sex in books. The bogus excuse "they're never written well" is overused to the extreme to defend prudish stances on literature (this sounds much harsher than I'm meaning it to, so apologies in advance), and I've really only encountered a few cases of a sex scene being written rather poorly, and it's from Joe Abercrombie. You have authors like GGK, Jacqueline Carey, GRRM, Kate Elliott, and Sapkowski (even in translation his are pretty good) who are really popular and write perfectly good sex scenes (some fade to black, some not), and there's generally always someone who brings up how they don't like the sex while hiding behind the "it's not written well" shield.

Do SFF readers have absurdly high standards for sex scenes, or what?

 

Anyway, endrant. I'm going to be grabbing the audiobook for Morning Star as soon as it's out in 5 days, and I'm probably reading Altered Carbon either at a good on-hold point in Kushiel or after if I can manage it, though it's a library ebook so I have to plan around the 14 day checkout.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Goldhand said:

I'm working through Kushiel's Dart and quite enjoying it so far. Better than you'd think based on how so many genre readers look down on it as erotica.

Genre readers (it's really noticeable in SFF in particular) have a massive aversion to sex in books. The bogus excuse "they're never written well" is overused to the extreme to defend prudish stances on literature (this sounds much harsher than I'm meaning it to, so apologies in advance), and I've really only encountered a few cases of a sex scene being written rather poorly, and it's from Joe Abercrombie. You have authors like GGK, Jacqueline Carey, GRRM, Kate Elliott, and Sapkowski (even in translation his are pretty good) who are really popular and write perfectly good sex scenes (some fade to black, some not), and there's generally always someone who brings up how they don't like the sex while hiding behind the "it's not written well" shield.

Do SFF readers have absurdly high standards for sex scenes, or what?

 

Anyway, endrant. I'm going to be grabbing the audiobook for Morning Star as soon as it's out in 5 days, and I'm probably reading Altered Carbon either at a good on-hold point in Kushiel or after if I can manage it, though it's a library ebook so I have to plan around the 14 day checkout.

Rothfuss is the best writer of sex scenes in the genre :)

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just finished The Beating of his Wings by Paul Hoffman. Ugggghhh. I wasn't crazy about The Left Hand of God, but I'm a completionist so I trudged on with the second and third books. 

If your thinking about reading the series, don't. It's a turgid pile of crap. You can actually see the pretentious stink cloud rolling off of each page.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, C Rutherford said:

 

He wrote a couple of short stories that tied into the series.  I could only find the one that Tor.com has:

 

What Doctor Gottlieb Saw

Thanks! Before I start clicking these links though, where does it fit in the chronology of the series?

2 hours ago, Goldhand said:

I'm working through Kushiel's Dart and quite enjoying it so far. Better than you'd think based on how so many genre readers look down on it as erotica.

Genre readers (it's really noticeable in SFF in particular) have a massive aversion to sex in books. The bogus excuse "they're never written well" is overused to the extreme to defend prudish stances on literature (this sounds much harsher than I'm meaning it to, so apologies in advance), and I've really only encountered a few cases of a sex scene being written rather poorly, and it's from Joe Abercrombie. You have authors like GGK, Jacqueline Carey, GRRM, Kate Elliott, and Sapkowski (even in translation his are pretty good) who are really popular and write perfectly good sex scenes (some fade to black, some not), and there's generally always someone who brings up how they don't like the sex while hiding behind the "it's not written well" shield.

Do SFF readers have absurdly high standards for sex scenes, or what?

 

Anyway, endrant. I'm going to be grabbing the audiobook for Morning Star as soon as it's out in 5 days, and I'm probably reading Altered Carbon either at a good on-hold point in Kushiel or after if I can manage it, though it's a library ebook so I have to plan around the 14 day checkout.

I obviously like GRRM, or I wouldn't be here, but really, sex scenes not his strong point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Astromech said:

Rothfuss is the best writer of sex scenes in the genre :)

The guy who gave us Felurian (aka porno Tom Bombadil) and the sex ninjas?

Contrary to popular belief, I don't think speculative fiction readers are particularly prudish. I think it's just (1) a matter of genre convention - the defining books in the genre don't tend to feature much sex (c.f. Tolkien), and (2) the major interest with speculative fiction often lies with exotic premises, not human relationships. Sex isn't exotic - it happens every day in the real world.

Anyway, my issue with Carey isn't the sex - it's the fact that her fantasy France is treated as being infinitely superior to everyone else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh yes, and as for Martin's sex scenes... "fat pink mast," "Myrish swamp", and "her cunt became the world"?

I recall Scott Lynch saying once that the issue authors have with sex scenes isn't that the authors themselves are prudish. It's that they're worried about revealing something intimate about themselves. Martin seems to have a nipple fetish...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Britton said:

Going through The Braided Path by Chris Wooding right now.  It's decent enough but pales in comparison the his Ketty Jay series and I find myself struggling through it a bit.  I have been thinking about dropping it it and moving on to something else.

I thought the series was reasonable but I agree his Ketty Jay books were much better. I think Wooding's standalone The Fade is his best out of the non-Ketty Jay books.

Ha, the top rated book on my shelf is Mark Lawrence unreleased book 3 in the series I forget the name of. Followed by a Shakespeare collection, Gene Wolfe Interviews collection, and finally, at number 4, A FUCKING FORGOTTEN REALMS NOVEL. I can hear peterbound screaming as I type this.

The top rated book for me is Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, which seems odd given that it's far from being the most loved book even in that series.

Looking at the other end I'm amused that the worst-rated story (by a long way) is last year's Hugo-winning novelette The Day The World Turned Upside Down, whose title presciently predicted how I'd have to change the way I was looking at the average ratings to find it. I'm not inclined to really argue with its position. The rest of the bottom 10 has another Hugo nominee by the same author, three Forgotten Realms novels, lesser works by David Eddings, Vernor Vinge and Tim Powers and Sophia MacDougall's Romanitas which was a book I liked quite a bit despite some flaws.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I finished the excellent Tigana. I've loved everything I've read from GGK so far. Looking forward to his Children of Earth and Sky this Spring.

Next up is Jaroslav Hasek's anti-war, The Good Soldier Svejk.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...