Criston of House Shapper

League of Thrones: Round 13, now with 48 characters

158 posts in this topic

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

 

I'm more concerned about including popular characters than excluding unpopular ones, so I'm not too disappointed that no one is likely to be replaced given that there will be an expansion later. One thing I'd point out is that a theoretical replacement character might have it easier than the character they replace, since they would be matched against only low-ranked characters once the list has been "sorted" to a greater degree, whereas the replaced character had to go up against a random, possibly very strong opponent in the first round. That could be an argument for making it hard for a character to get replaced; you want to be fairly sure that the replacement will do better before you replace the character, since you don't want to replace a character with one who will only do about as well but survive due to an easier schedule.

Also, have you decided how many points new characters will start with? I initially thought zero would be fairest, but I'm starting to question that* and it's clearly the worst option excitement-wise.

*Consider a version of the game where instead of winning points based on their percentage of the vote, characters either won or lost points based on their margin of victory or loss. That would correspond to simply doubling and subtracting 100 from each character's score in each round, not changing the order at all, but making zero the average score. Yet zero is still to me the most intuitive starting point for a new character in that version, with lower starting points seeming to punish characters for nothing, even though zero points in that version would correspond to 50 points per round in this game.

Edited by Zizoz
added to first paragraph

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
15 hours ago, Raisin(g) Bran 2 Greenseer said:

I think that creating a threshold at 100 is a mistake. Because of the way matchups are created, pitting low scorers against eachother creates a situation where low scorers will (on average) receive 50% of the votes against other low scorers. This means that after only 3 rounds, even unpopular characters have passed the 100-point benchmark. And it is nearly guaranteed that all will pass the benchmark after 5 rounds. I think a more appropriate benchmark would be 150-175 (30-35%) meaning they lose by something closer to a 2/3 majority.

On the other hand, 30-35% is a little harsh, there's bound to be characters who are lower than that. If a low scorer is able to receive 50% against another low scorer, than arguably, he's still competitive against that particular person, so he shouldn't be cut. I thought about raising it to a 25%-threshold with 6 rounds being the cutoff-point, but ultimately decided against it because 100 is a nicer number.

10 hours ago, Zizoz said:

Also, have you decided how many points new characters will start with? I initially thought zero would be fairest, but I'm starting to question that* and it's clearly the worst option excitement-wise.

*Consider a version of the game where instead of winning points based on their percentage of the vote, characters either won or lost points based on their margin of victory or loss. That would correspond to simply doubling and subtracting 100 from each character's score in each round, not changing the order at all, but making zero the average score. Yet zero is still to me the most intuitive starting point for a new character in that version, with lower starting points seeming to punish characters for nothing, even though zero points in that version would correspond to 50 points per round in this game.

Or I could just start them with a bias of 600 and then lower it by 50 each round, or maybe a bias that is a little below that. But I don't know yet. Aside from the excitement-factor, an additional problem with starting them at zero is of course, that they will only play each other for the first couple of rounds, potentially giving the most popular one of them a big boost at the start that will last for a year, giving that person the opportunity to rise to the top of the ranking despite being a lot weaker than some of the other people up there.

But I'm also unsure if it's fair to start them in the middle of the ranking despite probably being less popular than the majority of the original 32. It might be more interesting to start them at zero and have matchups of similarly-popular characters. The more I think about it, a bias of about 300 (12*25) seems like the way to go, to avoid both problems.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I wasn't actually suggesting starting them with 600 points – as you say, new characters are likely to be less popular since we already chose all the really popular ones. My point was just that zero is a somewhat arbitrary number.

One solution I was thinking about is to set the bias equal to the lowest total for the relevant rounds among the older characters. So for instance, if a character were added now they would start at 83.84 points; then in round 13, the bias would drop to 45.45 (equal to Renly's total for rounds 2-3, which is the lowest), and then in round 14 to 27.27. That would essentially mean new characters start tied for last place, so they can immediately compete with at least some of the older characters, but at no point would their "free points" give them an advantage over any other character.

Just assigning a set number is simpler, though.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs. [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm sorry, this is a little later than usual. Round 4 will end at some point tomorrow, until then you can still vote or edit your posts if you've changed your mind about something. Thanks to all those who have voted so far.

Edit: The poll is closed now, results will follow shortly.

Edited by Criston of House Shapper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The results of the round 4 matches are:

 

[1] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [2] Arya Stark   4-4

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [4] Stannis Baratheon   6-2

[5] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [6] Brienne Tarth   5-3

[7] Davos Seaworth   vs.   [9] Jaime Lannister   4-4

[8] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Sansa Stark   4-4

[11] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [12] Eddard Stark   1-7

[13] Mance Rayder   vs.   [14] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   2-6

[15] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [15] Brandon Stark (Bran)   3-5

[17] Doran Martell   vs.   [18] Petyr Baelish   2-6

[19] Catelyn Tully   vs.   [20] Varys   4-4

[21] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [22] Eddison Tollett   6-2

[22] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [24] Theon Greyjoy   6-2

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Robb Stark   4-4

[26] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [28] Barristan Selmy   2-6

[28] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [30] Cersei Lannister   6-2

[31] Renly Baratheon   vs.   [32] Yoren   3-5

 

Ned beats Sam 7-1 and gets the "Lord Commander of the Kingsguard"-award for the second time in a row.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The rankings after round 4 now are as follows:

 

1. Jon Snow 300.25
2. Tyrion Lannister 282.32
3. Arya Stark 275.25
4. Sandor Clegane 261.49
5. Eddard Stark 255.18
6. Davos Seaworth 234.85
7. Daenerys Targaryen 230.56
8. Oberyn Martell 228.79
9. Jaime Lannister 227.78
10. Brienne Tarth 227.40
11. Stannis Baratheon 226.01
12. Sansa Stark 220.71
13. Petyr Baelish 212.37
14. Brandon Stark 210.98
15. Tormund Giantsbane 203.28
16. Aemon Targaryen 201.26
17. Mance Rayder 186.62
18. Asha Greyjoy 185.98
19. Samwell Tarly 181.19
20. Catelyn Tully 180.30
21. Varys 179.29
22. Wyman Manderly 179.04
22. Barristan Selmy 179.04
24. Doran Martell 171.46
25. Brynden Tully 170.20
26. Robb Stark 156.06
27. Eddison Tollett 151.26
28. Theon Greyjoy 149.24
29. Yoren 146.34
30. Jorah Mormont 136.11
31. Renly Baratheon 127.40
32. Cersei Lannister 121.97

 

Jon takes the number 1 spot and wins the "Lord of the Seven Kingdoms"-award for the second time overall. Tyrion is now in second place and gets the "Hand of the King"-award.

Cersei is back in last place and gets the "Black Cells"-award.

Dany (from 14 to 7) and Ned (from 12 to 5) climb 7 spots and claim the "Chaos is a ladder"-award. On the other hand Sam falls from 11 to 19 and receives the "Chaos is a pit"-award.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The matches for round 5 were determined by character's [rank], with neighbouring characters going up against each other, with exceptions where they were already matched up in an earlier round. The tie between Wyman and Barristan was broken by a random draw:

 

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

 

Round 5 will run for roughly a month, which means until 31st July. As usual it may last a bit longer than that, depending on when I have time to do the calculations. Thanks in advance to those of you who vote and have fun. :)

Edited by Criston of House Shapper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Edited by Raisin(g) Bran 2 Greenseer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Edited by lil' ghost

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon[/b

Edited by Zizoz

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Coming in..

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister (meh)

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark (:unsure:)

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks to everyone who voted so far. :)

The current round will remain open until some point next Tuesday, so if you want to vote, you can do so until then or edit your posts if you've already voted and aren't happy with your choices anymore.

Edit: The poll is closed now, results will follow shortly.

Edited by Criston of House Shapper

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

These are the results of round 5:

 

[1] Jon Snow   vs.   [2] Tyrion Lannister   5-4

[3] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Sandor Clegane   9-0

[5] Eddard Stark   vs.   [6] Davos Seaworth   4-5

[7] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)   vs.   [8] Oberyn Martell   5-4

[9] Jaime Lannister   vs.   [10] Brienne Tarth   4-5

[11] Stannis Baratheon   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark   5-4

[13] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [14] Brandon Stark (Bran)   5-4

[15] Tormund Giantsbane   vs.   [16] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   4-5

[17] Mance Rayder   vs.   [19] Samwell Tarly   4-5

[18] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [20] Catelyn Tully   6-3

[21] Varys   vs.   [22] Barristan Selmy   2-7

[22] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [24] Doran Martell   4-5

[25] Brynden Tully   vs.   [27] Eddison Tollett   2-7

[26] Robb Stark   vs.   [28] Theon Greyjoy   3-6

[29] Yoren   vs.   [32] Cersei Lannister   4-5

[30] Jorah Mormont   vs.   [31] Renly Baratheon   6-3

 

Arya defeats the Hound 9-0 and gets the "Lord Commander of the Kingsguard"-award for the second time overall.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The rankings after round 5 now are as follows:

 

1. Arya Stark 375.25
2. Jon Snow 355.81
3. Tyrion Lannister 326.77
4. Eddard Stark 299.62
5. Davos Seaworth 290.40
6. Daenerys Targaryen 286.11
7. Brienne Tarth 282.95
8. Stannis Baratheon 281.57
9. Oberyn Martell 273.23
10. Jaime Lannister 272.22
11. Petyr Baelish 267.93
12. Sansa Stark 265.15
13. Sandor Clegane 261.49
14. Aemon Targaryen 256.82
14. Barristan Selmy 256.82
16. Brandon Stark 255.43
17. Asha Greyjoy 252.65
18. Tormund Giantsbane 247.73
19. Samwell Tarly 236.74
20. Mance Rayder 231.06
21. Eddison Tollett 229.04
22. Doran Martell 227.02
23. Wyman Manderly 223.48
24. Theon Greyjoy 215.91
25. Catelyn Tully 213.64
26. Jorah Mormont 202.78
27. Varys 201.52
28. Brynden Tully 192.42
29. Yoren 190.78
30. Robb Stark 189.39
31. Cersei Lannister 177.53
32. Renly Baratheon 160.73

 

Arya rises to the number 1 spot and wins the "Lord of the Seven Kingdoms"-award for the third time overall. Jon falls back to second place and gets the "Hand of the King"-award also for the third time.

Renly is now in last place and gets his first "Black Cells"-award.

Barristan climbs from 22 to 14 and receives the "Chaos is a ladder"-award. On the other hand, the Hound falls from number 4 to 13 and wins the "Chaos is a pit"-award.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The matches for round 6 were determined by character's [rank], with neighbouring characters going up against each other, with exceptions where they were already matched up in an earlier round. The tie between Aemon and Barristan was broken by a random draw:

 

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Eddard Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [5] Davos Seaworth

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [6] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[7] Brienne Tarth   vs.   [8] Stannis Baratheon

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Jaime Lannister

[11] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [14] Barristan Selmy

[14] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Tormund Giantsbane

[19] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [21] Eddison Tollett

[20] Mance Rayder   vs.   [22] Doran Martell

[23] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [25] Catelyn Tully

[24] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [26] Jorah Mormont

[27] Varys   vs.   [31] Cersei Lannister

[28] Brynden Tully   vs.   [29] Yoren

[30] Robb Stark   vs.   [32] Renly Baratheon

 

Round 6 will run for roughly a month, which means until 31st August. As usual it may last a bit longer than that, depending on when I have time to do the calculations. Thanks in advance to those of you who vote and have fun.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[1] Arya Stark   vs.   [4] Eddard Stark

[2] Jon Snow   vs.   [5] Davos Seaworth

[3] Tyrion Lannister   vs.   [6] Daenerys Targaryen (Dany)

[7] Brienne Tarth   vs.   [8] Stannis Baratheon

[9] Oberyn Martell   vs.   [10] Jaime Lannister

[11] Petyr Baelish   vs.   [12] Sansa Stark

[13] Sandor Clegane   vs.   [14] Barristan Selmy

[14] Aemon Targaryen (Maester Aemon)   vs.   [16] Brandon Stark (Bran)

[17] Asha Greyjoy   vs.   [18] Tormund Giantsbane

[19] Samwell Tarly   vs.   [21] Eddison Tollett

[20] Mance Rayder   vs.   [22] Doran Martell

[23] Wyman Manderly   vs.   [25] Catelyn Tully

[24] Theon Greyjoy   vs.   [26] Jorah Mormont

[27] Varys   vs.   [31] Cersei Lannister

[28] Brynden Tully   vs.   [29] Yoren

[30] Robb Stark   vs.   [32] Renly Baratheon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.