WI: Both Greyjoys and the Vale knights decided to ally with Robb?

[UFT]

how would that change the war

[The South Forgets]

GRRM would be forced to rewrite the story from ACOK, and the slim hope of ADOS seeing the light of the day will be lost

[Stormking902]

Stannis wins the battle of the Blackwater and takes KL and the Redkeep due to the Tyrells very cautious nature, throwing in all your chips with the Lannisters isnt smart when Robb has 4 kingdoms at his command.

Stannis sentences Joffrey and Tommon to death and Myrcella joins the silent sisters or is killed as well, Tywin retreats West and plays a defensive war bending the knee to either Robb or Stannis depending on the victor. Robb finds out about Wildling invasion through Jon returns North to witness for himself, then calls a truce with Stannis to properly fight the Wildlings and WW when he finds out WW are infact real. Even Stannis would call for a truce if it ment fighting the undead and he would have Mel telling him the WW are REAL as well. 

[Corvo the Crow]

Robb decides to strike southwest takes Highgarden, Margaery gives him comfort over the death of his horse. After all, they are related, Starks and horses.

[White Ravens]

8 hours ago, UFT said:

how would that change the war

If the Greyjoys and the Vale had supported Robb in his war effort, Space Aliens would have materialized and changed things back to how GRRM wrote them.  This solution applies to most what-if scenarios.

 

 

[Corvo the Crow]

39 minutes ago, White Ravens said:

If the Greyjoys and the Vale had supported Robb in his war effort, Space Aliens would have materialized and changed things back to how GRRM wrote them.  This solution applies to most what-if scenarios.

 

 

Why space aliens and not some other aliens? Is it because the wall stops the other kind?

[The Commentator]

It will force the Tyrells to reconsider their support for Renly.  All they want in this is to keep the kingdom whole.  The Ironborn will only agree to support Robb if it meant their independence.

[Chris Mormont]

These what if questions always have a lot of unknowns.  We know that the Iron Born wanted their independence, what would the Vale want?  The Riverlands seemed willing to accept Robb as their king since the alternative, was a Lannister.  Had Lysa gone back to the Eyrie claiming the Lannisters killed Jon Arryn, then they would have fought for revenge, but would that be enough to follow Robb?

[Stormking902]

4 minutes ago, Chris Mormont said:

These what if questions always have a lot of unknowns.  We know that the Iron Born wanted their independence, what would the Vale want?  The Riverlands seemed willing to accept Robb as their king since the alternative, was a Lannister.  Had Lysa gone back to the Eyrie claiming the Lannisters killed Jon Arryn, then they would have fought for revenge, but would that be enough to follow Robb?

Absolutly revenge would be enough Jon Arryn was well loved in the Vale and Ned Stark was also loved in the Vale revenege for both Great Lords is a givin. 

[Dorian Martell's son]

11 hours ago, UFT said:

how would that change the war

Balon would have his son double cross Bobb and the vale would return to neutrality so the story would continue as written 

[Dorian Martell's son]

8 hours ago, The South Forgets said:

GRRM would be forced to rewrite the story from ACOK, and the slim hope of ADOS seeing the light of the day will be lost

excellent response 

[Dorian Martell's son]

3 hours ago, White Ravens said:

If the Greyjoys and the Vale had supported Robb in his war effort, Space Aliens would have materialized and changed things back to how GRRM wrote them.  This solution applies to most what-if scenarios.

the best response so far 

[Dorian Martell's son]

2 hours ago, Corvo the Crow said:

Why space aliens and not some other aliens? Is it because the wall stops the other kind?

Yes obvs....

[Dorian Martell's son]

I also forgot to add that and alliance between the vale and the IB would cause megatron and optimus prime to wake from their slumber and start harvesting energon from the westerosi 

[Dorian Martell's son]

And it would cause china to invade italy, starting the renaissance early 

[Dorian Martell's son]

And possible cause columbus to be killed by the arawaks 

[Dorian Martell's son]

The inuit would build an empire out of ice 

[Dorian Martell's son]

and the pawnee would lead a combined force north to stop them 

[Dorian Martell's son]

Then the non-inuit would build a huge wall from coast to coast to prevent further inuit incursions south

[Dorian Martell's son]

and they would create a semi autonomous order to man said wall