Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Katydid

[Book Spoilers] Jaime killing Cleos/Alton

130 posts in this topic

I'm trying, really I am. I'm trying hard to reconcile the liberties they're taking in this series, and go with the flow with the changes/additions/subtractions. For the most part, I've done alright (save for anytime we see Ros on screen.)

But Jaime is now a kinslayer. Pointlessly, needlessly, it added nothing to the story that I can see. Cleos was a goner anyway. So what was wrong with the way GRRM wrote his death?

Fail.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

taking far to many liberties this season, and they are not capturing the grey areas of most of the characters

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think they are doing this to enhance his redemption in the later seasons. They need to enphisize the peoples trates like changing joffery from being an cruel idiot to being a monster and then also making more unlikable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think they are doing this to enhance his redemption in the later seasons. They need to enphisize the peoples trates like changing joffery from being an cruel idiot to being a monster and then also making more unlikable.

Exactly. We have thousands of pages to build up these characters personalities over. The show creators have 10 hours for like 15-25 characters. They have to overdo some traits to get the point across to people who don't read the book.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1) It gave Jaime something dramatic to do and reintroduces him to the the viewers in a fantastic way. The audience hasn't seen him in many episodes.

2) The scene was well written and acted. Both actors were great and I didn't see it coming until Alton kept creeping closer to Jaime.

3) It only serves to enhance Jaime's upcoming redemption arc in Seasons 3 and 4.

4) It adds more sense of immediacy to the Karstark subplot. Now the audience understands who Rickard Karstark is and why he is so adamant on having Jaime dead.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I for one really enjoyed the discontent that was portrayed amongst the northmen. You really get the feeling that something could go down at any minute. The pressure on Cat to do something drastic to protect Jaime and thus her daughters is palpable making her decision to Free Jaimie believable. Once again another example of how visual media can flesh out some of the less believable parts of the book. Her decision enraged me in the books but is more acceptable this way.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

taking far to many liberties this season, and they are not capturing the grey areas of most of the characters

Honestly this, far too many grey areas are being written out, Cat letting go of the kingslayer with direct word from Tyrion (although that's a subtle one), Ygritte escaping instead of Jon just being an idiot, and now this. I don't even see the point of this, what did Jaime achieve I mean, it seemed to be done purely to make him more evil.

And honestly, I'm not sure I buy a redemption arc. They should be making the Lannisters more likeable, to make sure they don't take a massive hit after...certain events, instead Cersei is neutered and Jaime kills someone for the heck of it. You can only push the audience so far, once they hate these people too much to want to watch them trying to switch it about will seem like a bait and switch. Especially since of all the evil shit the Lannisters have done, this was just silly and purely to make the character seem evil/dangerous. I go with evil because a better way of showing him being dangerous would be to show him kicking ass while still chained.

That said, the scene was wonderfully acted. I love the mention of different branches of the Lannister family, and how The family was held in such esteem, Alton was painfully earnest, and so was Jaime, I loved it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Seconds before killing his cousin, my wife (book reader too) told me: they are making him look nice too early, he should still be an asshole until his hand gets cut. The murder cleared that doubt quickly. Good,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Honestly this, far too many grey areas are being written out, Cat letting go of the kingslayer with direct word from Tyrion (although that's a subtle one), Ygritte escaping instead of Jon just being an idiot, and now this. I don't even see the point of this, what did Jaime achieve I mean, it seemed to be done purely to make him more evil.

It was the most effective, no strings attached escape strategy - Leaving him alive has other complications/decisions to be made that he obviously didn't want to risk.

I didn't understood why he paused after saying he would kill him though, was waiting for him to say he was just kidding.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't like this scene at all because Alton (who I believe is supposed to be Cleos Frey) is such a likeable young man. I always envisioned Cleos Frey as an old stuffy thing because that is the way Roy Dotrice reads him in the audiobooks. So after than when I read the books that is still how I saw him. Alton is young and honest. I had a hard time watching this scene when I watched the espisode a second time and switched channels until I knew it was over.

But I get that they have to establish Jamie early on as an a**hole and then show his transformation. The question is who will take his hand?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Upcoming third-season scene with Vargo Hoat:

“Y U kill Jon-Boy Alton, Kingthlayer??? U 2 manly 4 me, tho I fink I kyure U 4 good: time 4 U get thpethal mannikyure!”

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It was pretty awesome. It'll also make viewers doubt his redemption since it is clear he can turn on the charm any time he likes, and we can't see into his head like in the books.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm on the fence. I just don't see how they can make viewers enjoy his story like the readers have learned to. Jaime will never say outloud the things we got to read in his head. This act was just so cruel too it just makes him seem like a physociopath. I guess I didn't like it. I loved that the people in the room with him always got "piece of shit" Jaime, but the readers got the more complex story. I guess that's tough to do on screen in the shorter timeline.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved it, personally, I don't care that much for his redemption being part of the TV Series. Why pick Jamie out of all the different characters to show ooogles of self contemplation and backstory for when there is so much going on and so little time?

I prefer him as a cold-blooded, ruthless guy who people fear. There's plenty enough EMO going on on the TV Series with the way they are portraying Cersei and Jon Snow so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Killing Cleo (sic) is a Tony Soprano like moment of sociopathic tendancies, Irredeemable, though HBO will try. We will have to foget that JL is a kinslayer without conscience. We will be asked to believe it and many will.

such is life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So he is Alton Lannister, a distant cousin - but Jaime kept talking about Alton's mother as a Lannister so he wouldn't be Lannister unless Alton's father was one too... so that would make him a double Lannister cousin?

I don't think there has been any mention of kinslaying being any more egregious than a normal "killing," as of yet but they could still bring it up. I know the conversation between Renly and Stannis was there but there was no specific mention about kinslaying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Killing Cleo (sic) is a Tony Soprano like moment of sociopathic tendancies, Irredeemable, though HBO will try. We will have to foget that JL is a kinslayer without conscience. We will be asked to believe it and many will.

Jaime was already irredeemable after what he did to Bran. That's why his redemption is interesting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jaime was already irredeemable after what he did to Bran. That's why his redemption is interesting.

it seems to be common opinion that killing children is understandable if its done to protect one's sex life

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I loved it, personally, I don't care that much for his redemption being part of the TV Series. Why pick Jamie out of all the different characters to show ooogles of self contemplation and backstory for when there is so much going on and so little time?

I prefer him as a cold-blooded, ruthless guy who people fear. There's plenty enough EMO going on on the TV Series with the way they are portraying Cersei and Jon Snow so far.

Awesome point.

it seems to be common opinion that killing children is understandable if its done to protect one's sex life

hahahahahaha!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.