Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

ab aeterno

Non-ASOIAF Elimination Game I Best Starships

1,060 posts in this topic

Welcome to 1st edition of the Non-ASOIAF Elimination Game

This game is intended to complement rather than replace the ASOIAF EGs.

Our inaugural topic will be best fictional Starships.

A brief review of the mechanics and rules

In each round, you are allowed to "heal" one option and "hurt" another. For example:

Death Star 5

Enterprise 5

Heal Death Star

Hurt Enterprise

Death Star (+)

Enterprise (-)

The rules:

1. Every battle starts with 5 HP (healing points).

2. You can only vote once every 10 attack posts (9 between your first and last) OR once every two hours.

3. A cap of 25 HP will be imposed upon the last 5 deaths standing. Once this cap is in effect, you can choose to hurt one option without healing another, as long as at least one of the remaining choices is at the 25 point maximum.

4. If you spot any errors during the game, please correct them and include where you saw the error happen.

5. The game starts with 150 HP total and should stay that way until the last 5 deaths standing.

6. Please note who you're healing/hurting with +/- signs.

7. Declare what you are hurting and what you are healing

Pictures are included for illustrative purposes to refresh people's memories.

Picture Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3)

Picture Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI)

Picture Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)

Picture Prometheus (Prometheus)

PictureEnterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations)

Picture Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV)

Picture Serenity (Firefly)

Picture Executor Star Wars V, VI)

Picture Tantive IV (Star Wars IV)

Picture Auriga (Alien Resurrection)

Picture USSC Discovery I (2001)

Picture Nostromo (Alien)

Picture Event Horizon (Event Horizon)

Picture Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3)

Picture Axiom (WALL:E)

Picture Planet Express Ship (Futurama)

Picture Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis)

Picture Voyager (Star Trek Voyager)

Picture Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda)

Picture Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous)

Picture Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V)

Picture Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3)

Picture NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest)

Picture Moya (Farscape)

Picture Odyssey (Stargate SG1)

Picture TARDIS (Dr Who)

Picture Narada (Star Trek)

Picture Rodger Young (Starship Troopers)

Picture Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)

Picture White Star 1 (Babylon 5)

Voting List:

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 5

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 5

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 5

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 5

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Event Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 5

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3)

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 5

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Tantive IV

Hurt TARDIS

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 5

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 5

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6 +

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 5

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 5

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3)

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 4 -

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal TARDIS

Hurt Slave I

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Serenity

Hurt Tardis

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 5

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 7++

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4-

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 4-

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3)

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 4+-

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

*edit* Fixed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Serenity :bowdown:

Hurt TARDIS

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 5

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 6 (+)

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 8 (+)

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 4

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 2 (--)

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

ETA: Alestrius' votes included.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6 (+)

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 4

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 2 (-)

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Alex got Ninjad. TARDIS should be on 1

Correct Score

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 5

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 4

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 1

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Woo! Voting Normandy all the way on this one:

Heal Normandy SR-2

Hurt Slave I

Thank you!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Adding Gednry's vote

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6+

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 3 -

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 1

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Tardis

Hurt something

I did say the Tardis is the only ship that I would care about. But, you know what.... -sigh-

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Tardis

Hurt something

I did say the Tardis is the only ship that I would care about. But, you know what.... -sigh-

JW we can't add your vote unless you specify a hurt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal the citadel

hurt the deathstar

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 6+

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 4-

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 3

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 1

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hurt the Death star, just because it sounds ridiculous.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

]Hurt the citadel

heal the Death Star

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5-

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5+

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 3

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 1

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For Wench

Hurt Death Star

Heal TARDIS

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 4 -

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 4

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 3

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 2 +

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal Slave I

Hurt Auriga

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5-

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 4

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 3

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 4

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 2

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Heal TARDIS

Hurt Slave I

for me please. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For Crannog

Heal TARDIS

Hurt Slave I

For me

Heal the Death Star

Hurt the TARDIS

Will add vote

Citadel (Mass Effect, 1,2,3) 5-

Millenium Falcon (Star Wars IV, V, VI) 6

Battlestar Galactica (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series) 5

Prometheus (Prometheus) 5

Enterprise NCC-1701D (Star Trek TNG, Generations) 5

Death Star I (Star Wars III; IV) 5 +

Serenity (Firefly) 8

Executor Star Wars V, VI) 5

Tantive IV (Star Wars IV) 6

Auriga (Alien Resurrection) 3

USSC Discovery I (2001) 5

Nostromo (Alien) 5

Event Horizon (Even Horizon) 5

Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect 2,3) 6

Axiom (WALL:E) 5

Planet Express Ship (Futurama) 5

Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis) 5

Voyager (Star Trek Voyager) 5

Andromeda Ascendant (Andromeda) 5

Phoenix (Star Trek, numerous) 5

Slave I (Star Wars Ep. II, V) 3 -

Harbinger (Mass Effect 2, 3) 5

NSEA Protector (Galaxy Quest) 5

Moya (Farscape) 5

Odyssey (Stargate SG1) 5

TARDIS (Dr Who) 2 + -

Narada (Star Trek) 5

Rodger Young (Starship Troopers) 5

Rebel Basestar (Battlestar Galactica 2004 series)5

White Star 1 (Babylon 5) 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.