Jump to content

LotR vs. ASoIaF, which novel series do you prefer?


First of My Name

Recommended Posts

Can't really say as i've only read the third book from the Lord of the Rings trilogy. Other than that i only read the Silmarillion.



Therefore, as much as i love the LOTR movies, book wise, i prefer aSoIaF due to it's proximity to reality and how with it GRRMs achieves, to a greater level, the whole idea that the world isn't a garden of roses.



Now if you were to ask me about the movies/tv show, i'd have to go with the movies, simply because with them there was more room to make the battles actually large scale ones, unlike the GoT tv show where you can't really obtain a sense of grand scale from it (im looking at you Battle of Blackwater!!)


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...