Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Arthur Dayne's Honor

Your Reactions If

57 posts in this topic

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Arthur Dayne is dead Valar Morghulis. It is known

If all those things happen I'll feel disappointed

they are all individually true. So they aren't all happening at once. Just think about them individually

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im not sure, and I dont think Id want to know...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

they are all individually true. So they aren't all happening at once. Just think about them individually

What do you mean they are all individually true? The entire list is speculation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

1- I would have no problem with that except for the part about Arthur being alive. That seems a bit far-fetched.

2- I wouldn't like that. I don't want Jon as king of the 7 kingdoms.

3- That might actually happen...

4- I wouldn't be too upset...

5- :crying:

6- Well, if I have to choose between the two, I guess he's better than her (but only a little...)

7- Not happy. At all.

8- :ack:

9- :cheers: :thumbsup: :D :)

10- Cool!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

7. Disappointed. Why portray the Northern families as having honor if they sink to the same lows as the Freys and break guest rites? Can't happen that way.

10. Seems odd, isn't he seriously needed at the wall where his nephew was just stabbed?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

7. Disappointed. Why portray the Northern families as having honor if they sink to the same lows as the Freys and break guest rites? Can't happen that way

10. Seems odd, isn't he seriously needed at the wall where his nephew was just stabbed?

.the northern families wouldn't have anything to do with it. It'll be all UnCat and TBWB

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them. - I wouldnt mind

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne. I would mind, I only want Jon to be KotN not all of westeros

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)- I would be disappointed, however if she becomes maegor the cruel and is not mad I wouldnt mind

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her :ack:

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon- Ill cry

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0- I would be very disappointed

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun- I wouldn't mind

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin Cant happen but I would be happy if it does more secret targs :P

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds -I have trouble understanding that theory havent taken my time to read it

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC. I wouldn't mind

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

I'm sorry, but is four like a personal fantasy or something?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

1.Unless it has some incredibly profound implications on the story,I wouldn't care really.

2.I wouldn't like that,I prefer the 4 Kingdom split.

3.Wouldn't mind it,though I'm rooting for her to not live long enough.

4.I want him to go out on a high,But I wouldn't really care.

5.Very likely this will actually happen.

6.Very Surprised that both the 2nd and 6th Aegon's won.

7.Wouldn't be surprised,But will be a fun read.

8.

9.Meh,unless Rickon is old enough to rule it doesn't matter.

10.I'd be disappointed,I want Benjen in the Lands of Always Winter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. :dunce:

2. :bs:

3. :bang:

4. :frown5:

5. :bawl:

6. :bowdown:

7. :owned:

8. :eek:

9. :thumbsup:

10. :stunned:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm sorry, but is four like a personal fantasy or something?

:blushing: yeah.

I think of it as

He is campin on the Tridant the night before the battle with Dany. He knows he can't win against her dragons conventionally but then he remembers another potential battle where the odds were stack against him and he won, He'llremember Renly and how he defeated him. He ask Mel but she says no cuz it will kill him, this is after Shireen's death and the GNC happens an Stannis will be a little unhinged at this point so he will keep asking and begging and eventually he gets to the point where he won't take no for an answer and forces himself on her. Later out of pure spite Mel does create the shadow babe at the cost if Stannis's life. And doesn't even send it after Dany, maybe she uses it on herself.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

1. Wouldn't mind if A+H = M+J but unless it's important to the plot somehow I don't see why he'd put it in. I would be annoyed if Arthur Dayne 'the KG does not flee'.

2. Jon's a typical Northman and we've seen that northmen don't do well when it comes to Southron politics, wouldn't mind him being KiTN (though I think it should be Bran or Rickon) but only if the NW is dissolved.

3. I both think and want this to happen, agree with you about Cersei as well.

4. No way would Stannis rape someone but if he doesn't die in a blaze of glory I will be majorly pissed.

5. All the tears.

6. I don't really care for fAegon or Dany, but I would really want to see get Dany get annihilated in battle.

7. So happy.

8. Isn't fAegon older than Jon? Don't really see how this will change anything too.

9. Northerners conspiring to remove the Boltons and Freys and put a Stark back in Winterfell, very happy. Northerners conspiring to do all of that and then turning on Stannis, majorly pissed. Northerners are supposed to be loyal, turning on the man who saved them would go completely against character.

10. No way would Benjen, First Ranger and a Stark desert from the NW.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. I wouldn't mind H+A=J+M, but Arthur Dayne is dead, let's keep him that way.

2. Disappointed, I think Jon will end up king but I'm still hoping for a better ending.

3. I'd be ok with this.

4. Very upset, Stannis is one of my favorites. I don't want to him to die raping someone.

5. Oh shit. :crying:

6. Fine by me.

7. :thumbsup:

8. I'd be like, wut?

9. Good, but I 'd feel bad for Stannis.

10. Meh. It's better if no one finds out what happened to Benjen ever, he got lost in the snow and no one found him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

I would be quite happy.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

I would be OK with it.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

Disappointed; I don't want Dany to be queen.

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

I wouldn't mind.

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

Sad.

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

Happy (at least if he kills Dany).

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

Sad, I kind like Genna and Daven and don't want them to die.

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

Very surprised.

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

I'd be OK with it, but not amazingly happy.

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

No opinion

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just can't believe that you think Stannis would do such a thing. Are you sure we are talking about the same Stannis?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

1. I'd be a little disappointed. It would be almost too neat.

2. I don't want that to happen, since it would mean the same structure exists still.

3. I don't want Daenerys to be queen, but at least it would remove the hero halo surrounding her, in the TV series at least.

4. :frown5: Stannis is one of my favourites so I'd be let down but considering his stance on rape, I see literally no chance of that happening.

5. Tears.

6. Happy, I much prefer Aegon to Dany.

7. Happy that the Freys get their comeuppance but many others would die too so overall, I'm not sure.

8. Very much going wtf?I would be very surprised.

9. I'd be kind of disappointed, for Stannis and in the Northmen who seem to emphasise honour so much and then they would betray him.

10. Shocked.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Howland+Ashara= Jojen and Meera theory proves true as well as Arthur Dayne being in the Neck with them.

"Now that's... contrived. But okay."

2. Jon is King of the Seven Kingdoms but there is no Iron Throne.

"Well, at least he didn't get that storybook "lost son of the dynasty"-ending"

3. Dany becomes the Mad Queen 2.0( Cersei is the OG Mad Queen)

"That was unnecessary"

4. Stannis dies from raping Melisandre to make a Shadow Baby with her

"What an idiot"

5. Arya dies right before she reunites with Jon

"Well, it was clear that SOMEONE like that would die before the series ends"

6. fAegon beats Dany in the DWD2.0

"Okay with me"

7. The RW2.0 goes down in Riverrun

"Good"

8. fAegon turns out to be Jon's non identical twin

"Fuck you, George Lucas"

9. The GNC proves true and it succeeds

"Good"

10. Benjen is the hooded man and is at the head of the GNC.

"That makes no sense"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.