Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

LordFirkraag

How many men to take down Gregor Clegane?

62 posts in this topic

Not Robert Strong, but the original Gregor Clegane?



Arguably just one if you pick Oberyn Martell, but bear in mind that Oberyn was no ordinary man...and in any case he had the advantage of poison and the knowledge of the chinks in Gregor's plate mail.



This armour is so thick and heavy that Clegane is almost like a human tank, as I see it. Stopping him is not going to be easy. How many soldiers would do the job?


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's more about the weapons than about the number of people.



Remember it's said that Gregor's armour is ridiculously thick and so heavy that only he can wear it and move around in it. That would explain why Clegane survives battle after battle, not just due to his physical gifts.



I think you have a better time with 5 men with war-hammers than 10 with swords.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good point. Realistically, though, there have to be gaps in his gear or he would never be able to see. So anyone with a knife could just jump up on his shoulders and take out his eyes.



He would also get tired. With ten men harassing him, it's only a matter of time before he buckles.



Probably why he's being turned into Robert Strong. More interesting TACTICS if he's undead as well as tireless...


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Id fancy Jaime or Barristan in their prime one on one with the Mountain


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

However many it would take to distract him, while rebellion era Robert lands a rage-filled swing of his hammer to gregor's head.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One person to shove him in the river-- an unarmed person, so that he wouldn't feel threatened. With that heavy armor, he would probably be sink to the bottom quickly!


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If he didn't die at Stone Mill, I would have thought some of the Riverlands soldiers would have tried to drown him and use the weight of his ridiculously heavy armor against him.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not to mention he wields a 2-handed greatsword with one hand, so he can still use a shield.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If he didn't die at Stone Mill, I would have thought some of the Riverlands soldiers would have tried to drown him and use the weight of his ridiculously heavy armor against him.

I can imagine Victarion bull-rushing him off a ship into the water. That's one method. Would be pretty tubular.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any of the contesting best knights could do it...



but if not them



5 normal soliders, with two of them being ranged (crossbow), this is becasue he is so large and his armor strong


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One man fighting intelligently with speed and a bit of luck. Or one man using brute force. Robert would have caved Gregors massive chest in with his warhammer, Bronn on a good day would simply outfight him. People like Jaime, Barristan, Arthur Dayne etc would go the same way as Bronn. Outmanoeuvre and outfight him. I think a big part of Gregors shtick was the fact that he was essentially someone who fought his way through commonfolk who probably had far less training and experience, obviously inferior armour, and just general fear of this beast of a man coming at them.



How many nobles do we know of that actually fought Gregor? Sandor, Oberyn, and Beric, to my recollection. One literally stuck a stick through Gregor and wiped the floor with him, another basically parried everything Gregor threw at him with relative ease, and the last one Gregor actually killed. Excusing cockiness causing death, that's a 2-1 trade off. Gregors big and strong, and he's skilled with a sword, but as I said an intelligent, fast fighter should win.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends on the man/men.



Gregor doesn't seem all that technically skilled as a fighter. Oberyn, young Barristan, two-handed Jaime, Arthur Dayne, and other highly skilled fighters could take him down one-on-one.



Gregor's best use is on a battlefield, in the chaos of things, where technical skill can be forgotten and hampered by terrain and fatigue. He is massive, extremely strong, rides a freakishly large horse, and has extremely thick armor. It gives him a huge advantage over average and mediocre fighters. He can ride right over opposing forces.



My guess is a half dozen average men with spears and a good plan should be able to take him on foot.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One formidable man.

Many many ordinary men, I'd say 8-10 with swords, 6-8 if at least 2 have spears.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends his chief advantage is the terror he inspires. He could likely cut through a dozen common footsoldiers as they'd be hesitant to engage and he could pick them off one by one.

But two determined knights fighting in tandem could beat him nearly every time. Say Garlan and Loras Tyrell, or Yohn and Robar Royce.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends his chief advantage is the terror he inspires. He could likely cut through a dozen common footsoldiers as they'd be hesitant to engage and he could pick them off one by one.

But two determined knights fighting in tandem could beat him nearly every time. Say Garlan and Loras Tyrell, or Yohn and Robar Royce.

I would prefer Rolland Storm and Richard Horpe, but yeah, too guys who know what they are doing will take this oversized brute nearly every time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites