Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Katjushka

  • Rank

Profile Information

  • Gender
  1. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP510 Discussion

    I kinda thought about this as well when I remembered Carice talking about her big scene with Kit.. I just really can not and will not accept the idea that Jon Snow is staying dead on the show, he is needed. But maybe he stays dead for half a season and even after that he only has a little screentime.
  2. Well hey, I'm just a lady from Finland and I can get a fire going in the winter.. Not that hard really when you know what you need for it an how to use them. The whole point of Ramsay and his 20 men succeeding is that they're from the north, Stannis and his men are not.
  3. Yeah, this. Obviesly it is a money issue as well as the show already is really expensive to make but also time, they shoot with two crews simultaneously as it is and have told in previous seasons that not a lot of material ends up on the cutting room floor as they use pretty much almost everything they shoot. There's no way they could do 15 episodes of this quality and I'll rather take quality over quantity here.
  4. Wow, that's spot on. Also, she is not the first child to be burned in this show so I'm really not getting the rage. Same goes for Trants brothelscene, sure it's horrible but it's fiction, it's not really happening and no little girls were really harmed.. There are many shows and movies that illustrate horrific crimes and that's fine, that's what fiction is there for really - to tell stories that could or could not happen in real life.
  5. Interesting, I see this in the exact opposite way. I see this as a strong indication that Stannis will fall relatively soon, sure there's some magic in Mel and she can do certain things but I don't think Stannis is AA so Shireen was burned only so that Stannis can sometime farely soon realize that Mel was wrong and he was superstupid to believe in her and to make the sacrifices he made.
  6. Well I don't really think it was inconsistent for Stannis to go from telling Shireen he loves her to sacrificing her in a few episodes.. I think it goes to show how strong of a hold Mel has on him and how he in his own mind can justify everything with "Because Mel said I'd be king", he believes he is destined to be king and to fight the army of the dead and he also believes he has to do whatever it takes to get there. Losing is not an option, turning back is not an option, starving to death is not an option. Stannis surely loved his daughter even as he decided to burn her so nothing changed there, what changed were the circumstances they were in and the amount of his desperation. He trusts Melisandre and believes her to be right about everything.
  7. Wise words. No need for anyone to be personally offended if other people have different views or beliefs about some series, it's all just opinions and no one's is better or more "right" than someone else's.
  8. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    Yes he could and he is. They did show his face at one point and it's just a guy. And not even the only hooded guy on the boat so.. Some of the wildlings just decided to wear hooded cloaks that day.
  9. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    I wish you told me that sooner or something similar?
  10. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    I think they were left behind, yeah. But then I also thought Sam just gave him the one blade last week and he ended up having a bag full of them so maybe there's more in CB and there's definately more on dragonstone, Stannis said so. I'm thinking part of why Jon sends Sam away is going to be about getting weapons to fight the WW, meaning Valyrian steel and dragonglass.
  11. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    Yes it's just a guy in a hooded cloak. He's sitting in the back and the cloak is very likely hiding a small motor to move the boat or something and he is not the only one on that boat who has a hood on when they're leaving.
  12. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    I agree that Selmy maybe should've mentioned him but you are really putting the wrong words in Tyrion's mouth here, he did not at any point say that Dany is the last of her name just talked about there not being anyone in her name lef to support her and that is very true. Is it not?
  13. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    No, what Tyrion said was that there is no one with Dany's name left to support her. He did not say that Dany was the last living Targaryen. Even with Aemon alive there is no Targaryens left to support Dany, the NW do not support anyone and certainly not individual members of it. So not a show mistake.
  14. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    Well there were actually a few guys on the boat that had hoods on (some were rowing) so I don't see the mystery there and we also did get to see the face of the hooded guy in the back, briefly yes but it was shown. So just a wardrobe choice for a few people, no mystery, nothing significant and certainly not Benjen.
  15. Katjushka

    [Book Spoilers] EP508 Discussion

    Lots of posts regarding this but what Tyrion actually said was that there is no one with Dany's name left to support her and that is very true wheather Aemon is alive or not. Aemon is in the night's watch and they don't envolve themselves with politics so Aemon would not be in a situation to support Dany, So clearly this was not a mistake in the show, what they wrote Tyrion to say was the truth as Tyrion knows it. I don't mind critisism on the show when there's a reason for it but wanted to point this out 'cos I thought that a lot of people might have missed what Tyrion actually said.