Jump to content

Lady Dyanna

Members
  • Content count

    564
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Lady Dyanna

  • Rank
    Noble
  • Birthday January 10

Contact Methods

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Female
  • Location
    Playing in the Snow with Nymeria's PAC
  • Interests
    ASOIAF of course!

Recent Profile Visitors

2,444 profile views
  1. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    I don’t know. If I were GRRM I think I might be frustrated too. None of us has any idea WHY he is having problems getting the book out. He might have a perfectly reasonable explanation. It might even be something out of his control. But he is under no obligation to anyone to share his personal reasons with anyone.
  2. Lady Dyanna

    The Heretic's Guide to Heresy

    Good. Cuz though I can see where it might come from. The possibility is there. There are very few indicators there. But just not a lot. It does strike me as odd, however, that after the Varamyr prologue very few ppl seem willing to discuss the possibility that Robb is now present in either Grey Wind or Lady Stoneheart I did read a really good theory on it years ago. I’ll need to look to see if I can find it again.
  3. Lady Dyanna

    The Heretic's Guide to Heresy

    @Platypus Rex Personally I’d like to explore the idea that Jojen paste is absolute and total bs in any real way other than symbolically. Where in the world do ppl get that idea? Not to mention that NOWHERE in the series does it say that Grey Wind is actually dead. We just assume that he is. It’s only the show that proves it to be so conclusively. It seems that immediately following the Red Wedding is when the show world and book world completely go off the tracks in relation to one another.
  4. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    If you don’t do that you risk turning Heroin into the HEROINE
  5. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    I will say it again. To look at the results of Harrenhal you need to look at the characters that are present AT HARRENHAL ETA. And maybe that’s our keystone. First names starting with those letters???
  6. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    I think that the problem with this train of thought is that you are trying to cram all versions of the outcome into the same shoebox when inevitably it changes with each telling. We need to investigate that occurrence independently of the rest. We’re getting closer comparing Arya to the Piper relative with orange hair, but to include Ser Shadrich is to pull in conflicting information from alternative versions.
  7. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    John is a win for Ice. Dany is a win for fire. Bran is the compromise.
  8. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    I’m pretty sure that those are definitely all possibilities. It just depends on what it is about the story that catches our eye. There are always going to be nine options, but in the end only three are potentially correct. Ice wins. Fire wins. Or they become balanced.
  9. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    Yeah. I think you can look at that as well. But when looking at the toj there are only two possibilities I see. Both are BBJ. But this time I think it’s Barbery Dustin and Brandon that are Jon’s parents. It was Dany that is the Child of Rhaegar and Ashara. Mellaria is Melisandra. And Lyanna is Septa Lemore. I still need to work through the others. It is kinda a big leap. But the evidence is there to support it all.
  10. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    See what I said in the post above. I think that GRRM might be trying to give us a type of Rosetta Stone. To Clarify... A key that we can apply to come to the end result each time something is prophesied. Problem is that he only gives enough information to come up with and rule out 7 out of 9 options. I’m the end it’s always a choice between two final options. You just need to hope that you’ve chosen correctly.
  11. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    Hmmmm. I think we might be looking for a total of 16 houses as events have happened twice. That’s where we get the opposing 9 and 7 from, I think. Maybe we need to look at who was in attendance at each of the events that was prophesied and compare it to whomever was present at each of the actual event. It starts out with 9 possible options and then seven are taken away. It leaves two possible outcomes each time. I think that this key might be in effect in some manner for each of the prophecies that are on page.
  12. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    I think that maybe we need to start out looking at the Wardens of each of the separate kingdoms in order to narrow down our options. So... 1. Stark is the North 2 Tully is the Riverlands 3. Martell for Dorne 4. Lannister for the West 5. Arryn for the East 6. Baratheon for the Stormlands 7. Targaryen for the crown 8. 9. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
  13. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    Oh wait.... We also need to add in 1. Flower Type 2. Flower color 3. ??? Material of some sort? 4. Eye Color (This might be why it was important that Renley’s eyes are known to be green and NOT blue. Why else would GRRM care enough to make a later correction to that be known unless there was some significance.
  14. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    Doesn’t hurt to try. We all tend to look at different things. I’m just still not positive that we have enough to narrow it down or not. So we want to look for parallels between ... 1. House Color 2. Sigil Representation. 3. House Name 4. Character Name 5. Physical location 6. Significant Symbolism. Am I forgetting anything?
  15. Lady Dyanna

    Heresy 228 and one over the eight

    To be clear. I’m our original loop I think we might be looking at choices between WHent or Hightower, Arryn and Stark.
×