T and A
Members-
Posts
557 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Recent Profile Visitors
T and A's Achievements
Noble (7/8)
-
StarksTogetherOutrageously reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
WolfOfWinter reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
Sheiraseastar23 reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
alienarea reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
CrypticWeirwood reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Believe whatever makes you happy. -
CrypticWeirwood reacted to a post in a topic: Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
-
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
The best answer on this whole topic. But you won't change the minds of people here. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Come on, that is just plain stupid. Now people are just forcing it... It was stupid to even think that it was D&D's idea to put Bran on the throne. They hated that character. But now some people just sound desperate, which looks pretty sad. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Isaac has stated that D&D told him two things coming straight from GRRM: Hodor, and him being King. So there you go... -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Of course you cant see it. 2/7 of the story is not done yet. Do you know how much plot hapened in the first two books? FEAST and DANCE are bad examples, because literally nothing happend plotwise. But the earlier books had a lot to tell. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Nicolaj and Gwendoline talking about, who will be King at the end, back then when promoting Season 7. Gwendoline bets it is Bran. Nicolajs reaction to that is just hillarious Nicolaj: The three eyed raven???? That doesn't make any sense! -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
The logic you are using regarding who will be King at the end, even though thought out pretty well, is completely flawed. You all start to think about lineage and legacy. And you continue to play the game as it was played before. After the war against the Others, the continent will be unrecognizable. Probably half of (If not more) the population in Westeros will be dead. Westeros will be devastated by the wars it had to suffer: Five Kings, ,(upcoming) Dance, (upcoming fight for Dawn), (upcoming) fight against Daenerys Army. It will change the whole game. After all of this is set and done, GRRM won't just write a story about who has the most valyrian blood to sit him on that throne (which also will not exist). Bran might be the crucial figure in the fights to come. He might be the first King to be elected, because he will be the most important figure to secure humanities survive. Think for a moment, you really think, GRRM is writing this whole epic fantasy, just to sit at the end and start "well, lets see, he is a quarter Targaryen, he is one eittth Targaryen. Well he is an Andal. No, wait, he is one of the first men". That is not what is going to happen. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
I don't believe that for a second. Even before the show spoiled it. We will see if Winds come out -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
He neither did in the show. Meera literally states it "Brandon Stark died in that cave". The artist formerly known as Bran is the 3ER, a being with the conciousness of all the 3ER existing before him. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Funny, I put that Quote of George here, to state that the Author won't give anything away from the books, nor how much the show differs from the books, he is planing to write. Yet, it leads to a discussion to exactly that -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Just for the lols: If you had to guess how many manuscript pages GRRM has written, what would you guys guess? -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
He made it vague, on purpose. He obviously won't spoil his books. But he can not act as if nothing from the show is from the books. And he can not act as if everything from the show is from the books. Hence, Yes, No, Yes, No.... -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
Yes,.yes and yes. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
It tells us to enjoy what we got, don't mix two different mediums that are uncomparable and complain. And that he is not done with the books. His first punchline though, is the official confirmation from HIM, that R+L=J. If that was still debatable. -
Master thread on what the Show means for the book plot
T and A replied to Free Northman Reborn's topic in General (GoT)
"How will it all end? I hear people asking. The same ending as the show? Different? Well… yes. And no. And yes. And no. And yes. And no. And yes." - George RR Martin