Jump to content

Coolbeard the Exile

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited


About Coolbeard the Exile

  • Rank
  • Birthday 04/10/2000

Profile Information

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Coolbeard the Exile

    The Best commander in ASOIAF

    I suspect they did try to assault the castle since Donal Noye lost his arm in the siege but it is very impressive of him with no experience holding the caslte and keeping his men loyal for such a long time. Not only did he destroy the iron islands fleet he also subdued the largest island in what must have been an extensive campaign. At the battle of the blackwater kings landing had 7000+ troops that is a very large garrison against stannis 20,000 and they have walls and water surrounding them and they had hundreds of scorpions, catapults, trebuchets and wildfire and a large fleet. Sure Stannis knights are vastly superior to the normal wildling but still it is impressive that they managed to rout them all with such few troops without many casualties. Also Stannis was smart and did a suprise attack so he should get credit for that. Deepwood Motte was not impressive but still it means experience.
  2. Coolbeard the Exile

    The Best commander in ASOIAF

    You said his record was rubbish. His plan for the battle of the green fork was very impressive i think and i just think its stupid to say he sucks at military stuff because he is a very intelligent guy and we have all reason to think he is great at military stuff and everyone says he is great at military stuff but the books content is limited when it comes to warfare so i just think its stupid to judge him as rubbish.
  3. Coolbeard the Exile

    The Best commander in ASOIAF

    1. Stannis Baratheon Stannis Baratheon is the best commander in Westeros. He held Storms end against a huge host and held together despite starvation and unrest for a year. He later rebuilt the Royal Fleet and took Dragonstone and later defeated the Iron Born at the battle of Faire Isle and after that he took the largest island Great Wyk. He spent some time suppresing smugglers at the sisters. He almost took a very very well defended King's Landing despite the Wildfire and only lost because of a miracle on the defenders side. He then took less than 1500 men and completely routed the Wildling army of 30,000 warriors giants and mammoths easily. He then marched south through winter and starvation with his tiny army and took Deepwood motte and is about to defeat the supperior enemy forces coming to get him.
  4. Coolbeard the Exile

    The Best commander in ASOIAF

    How is Tywins record rubbish?
  5. Coolbeard the Exile

    Jon will get wightified, a theory by Lothar Frey

    how about no
  6. Coolbeard the Exile

    The Best commander in ASOIAF

  7. Coolbeard the Exile

    What House would be the most fit to rule the Seven Kingdoms?

    Best would be: 1. Lannister 2. Tyrell 3. Arryn Stark - Strange religion and customs, would not be very popular and they have their lands far away therefore not a good choice. Tully - Would be close to the Crownlands to support them but they strategically have a very weak position therefore not a good choice. Greyjoy - No explanation needed... Lannister - Very rich and the goldroad takes you to King's landing very swiftly. No cultural diffrences good choice i would say. Arryn - A little far off but they seem to be very pious so they would have the support of the faith and smallfolk good okay choice i would say. Baratheon - They are to headstrong and warlike and uninterested in rule i would say so they wouldnt make good kings. I think Robert kind of personifies a Baratheon lord. Tyrell - Strongest Kingdom by far, no cultural difficulties, a little far of from kings landing but i would say they would be a good choice. Martell - They are very disliked for their foriegn ways, are very far of and they have kind of radical ideas to the westerosi system. Not a good choice at all allthough they probably would have the most sensable people.
  8. Coolbeard the Exile

    Targaryen Morality

    Except Dany she is by far the most evil character in the story. Ramsay appears as a nice guy beside Dany. Infact i would rather leave a child in the care of Ramsay then that cruel Dany. "Satire intended"
  9. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    Were you in the presence of George RR Martin??? :D:D:D:D:D??? Was his aura mighty???:D:D:D??? How did you get to talk to him?
  10. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    Ohh i looked up George saying it. Thought it was a valyria exclusive thing.
  11. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    Explain i don't get what you mean?
  12. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    There is only one kind of people that have targaryen traits like very pale skin, silver hair and purple eyes and that is valyrians. If any one of these traits are on a person you know 100% that they are born from someone with valyrian blood. Bittersteel dosn't have the overall targaryen look but the purple eyes gives away that he has valyrian blood. Give me some examples of V+nV=nV I can't really tell Duncan's eyes. Dont you get it? Only one of those 3 distinguishing traits need to be on a person to give away that they have valyrian blood and there are less than 5 people of targaryen family that lack those 3 traits. It is a strike against r+l=j
  13. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    We don't know about aemma arryn as far as i know. Valarr has a streak of silver in her hair so she is clearly of valyrian blood dosnt count. Don't think we know about duncan the small. We don't know 100% what colour her eyes were. I will give you the velaryon boys and Baelor
  14. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    There have been like 70 known Targaryens and only three of them from what i can find are without Targaryen features. I don't know how to express in words why it would be bad for the story.
  15. Coolbeard the Exile

    Does fAegon annoy anyone else?

    Good eye but i still think it is a very weak theory.