Jump to content

Dorian Martell's son

  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited


About Dorian Martell's son

  • Rank
    Council Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
  • Location
    Hiding from the Mormonts
  • Interests

Recent Profile Visitors

3,810 profile views
  1. Dorian Martell's son

    Jaime, Joanna, and Cersei

  2. Dorian Martell's son

    What if Daenerys was Ugly?

  3. Dorian Martell's son

    Jaime, Joanna, and Cersei

    there were plenty of women in his life. siblings experiment sexually. it is well documented.
  4. Cersei becomes a silent sister after getting caught screwing Jamie
  5. Dorian Martell's son

    Yohn Royce was a fool

    yes he was, but there was no lands or keeps for him
  6. Dorian Martell's son

    2017: Sons of dragon, 2018: Fire and Blood, 2019 ..

    Probably not much more than what was done when he took 6 months off from his con schedule. He writes at whim, as shown by his publishing of books other than winds
  7. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    I did. Venison is found all over the realm and Bravos is climate wise very similar to the sisters. You are confusing a lack of options in a forum post with fan fic. Trust me, they are different This is in fact fan fic, actively changing the story to make it work for you. And if you are wealthy enough, you can get butter in Braavos. A reply with limited options is not fan fic. Rewriting a story where different characters do things so different that it fundamentally changes the story is fan fic. Analysis is not crackpot, neither is speculation. Tinfoil, crackpot and head canon of things already written is in fact fan fic. True. But this thread is literally one where the story has to be rewritten to work. Lets keep the discussion about the op The mods have better things to do Yes, and I am doing that next step. Yet here we are.......... You mentioned me, not the other way around. So start from there. You could be discussing the op, yet here you are......... Choices go both ways. you are an equal participant with me. Own it. Also, I should be thanked for making otherwise droll threads "hot"
  8. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    Except those who do.
  9. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    I bet you're glad you chose to quote me in a reply and draw me into conversation. And this is the crux of it all. While she as an artist has no issue with it, the author of the books that gave this forum its name does not like it at all. I can promise you I will never be caught dead on a potter forum much less lecturing folks about fan fic
  10. Dorian Martell's son

    What if Lysa Tully birthed her child with Petyr?

    the child would have to die soon after birth so the story can continue as written
  11. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    No thanks necessary Ma'am . I'm here to help It is a rewrite, but it is really focusing on your life. My presence in it is and incidental, and your choice. so my opinion on fan fic does not mater here. You are correct though, this isn't fan fic because you are writing about your own life. Unlike the GRRM, you seem to have no problem with fan fic so it will never be an issue, no matter what scenario you create for yourself. I would love to comment but I don't read kids books these days so I have no opinion on your hypothetical. Also, what does Mrs Rowling think about fan fc?
  12. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    A rewrite, even in an outline format in the westeros forms is still a rewrite. Robb marching south to warn Ned as an Idea would require you to rewrite the story to engage that hypothetical. That is the whole point of these threads. What if the story was written differently? That is in fact fan fic
  13. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    It does, and when the author finds it acceptable, I will read it on occasion
  14. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    The mods seem to take a pretty hands off approach to this place, but using the T word is a capital offense. Beware. Except it is rewriting the story, which is fan fic Except it is.
  15. Dorian Martell's son

    Robb instead of Catelyn

    The difference is between what has been written and what hasn't. And that is huge.