Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by KingMudd

  1. KingMudd

    Fair Compensation for House Frey

    Yeah I agree, you pretty much said the same as me, not sure why you seem to think we have differeing views.
  2. KingMudd

    Jon Snow's Real Name

    I could see Ned saying to Jon "He may have been your father, boy. But he wasn't your daddy."
  3. KingMudd

    Fair Compensation for House Frey

    There are laws and Ned Stark actually does exactly what you say can't happen. He sends Berric Dondarrion out to arrest Gregor Clegane to put him on trial. There's also Tyrions trials as well. Trial by combat is just another way of trying to prove innocence (which was actually real in Germanic law). People don't just "do whatever they want" you're cherry picking things to make your argument fit. The only reason the Freys got away with it was because it was sanctioned by Tywin and carried out against a rebel army.
  4. KingMudd

    I hate the Starks, should I keep reading?

    Why read something you despise? just stop reading and move onto something you like. There are literally thousands of fantasy books out there. Amazon has 50,000 books listed in their fantasy section.
  5. KingMudd

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    Just my opinion
  6. The same then. He says the same as the show? Different? Yes and no. So the same then. It'll be a bit different as there are more characters but the general outcome will be the same. I guess well see when he finishes it.
  7. Yeah keep telling yourself that. I've read all the books he's released. GRRM has said the endings will be the same but whatever man I don't really care if you believe that or not.
  8. What a load of bullshit. If you think the books are ending differently you have a shock coming. GRRM has said they end the same. The books will have more detail but the outcome will be the same.
  9. KingMudd

    Would Lyanna start a war for Robert if Rhaegar kidnapped him?

    Shed more than likely start a war if he wasn't kidnapped by Rhaegar.
  10. KingMudd

    Faceless Men

    In A Game of Thrones during the small council meeting about assassinating Daenerys Grand Maester Pycell suggests hiring the faceless men to do it. Littlefinger then says it would cost twice the price of hiring an army. So they do kill for gold.
  11. KingMudd

    Riverlands house and military

    I was always under the impression that Harrenhal is so big that it's actually a burden to the current lord. If the Riverlands could find a very rich family to take on Harrenhal, restore it and use it to its fullest potential it would probably rival Kings Landing.
  12. I see you have only quoted half of what I actually said, it was a good ending but needed more time. That's your opinion and I've stated my opinion. I didn't need to put my brain on standby to enjoy it. I saw the flaws and chose to just enjoy it for what it was. I don't see why you feel the need to tell me that my opinion is wrong and try to insult people who enjoyed the ending.
  13. KingMudd

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    Um, that's how theories and facts are obtained. You have to search through the material. They found what they were looking for as well so it's quite credible. The hints are there even if you don't believe them. Just like the hints are there for Jon's parentage.
  14. KingMudd

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    I don't mind Daenerys as a character. I enjoyed her the most after Drogo died and and the dragons were still young and small. I'm of the opinion if it's a good story then I don't mind what happens. I have my favourite characters but don't mind if they turn out evil or die off because that's the story that GRRM wants to tell. It's your opinion that it's a poor storyline. I'm guessing there are many people who think the opposite and that's fine. If you're only in it for a select few characters then you are going to be angry and upset like you when something you don't like happens to them. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean that it's a bad story.
  15. KingMudd

    Dany the Mad Queen was a terrible idea

    The fact that quite a lot of readers have theorised that Daenerys will become the villain and go "mad" means that the signs have been there all along. I like that she becomes a villian in the end and Jon is left wondering if he has done the right thing by killing her. I read something I like on here that basically said Jon brought everyone together to stop ICE (the army of the dead) and then stopped FIRE (by killing Daenerys) and I think that's a good way to end it.
  16. KingMudd

    Jon is a hypocrite

    Because that's not him. What Jon done was completely in character and it's what he would have done all throguhout the series. It's the same reason Ned had for warning Cersei that he was going to tell Robert about the incest and it's the same reason Robb had for beheading Rickard Karstark. All three could have just not bothered but thier honour made them do it.
  17. No. The books are still great. I do believe the ending will be generally the same. The show ending was good and just needed more time to flesh it out a bit which won't be a problem for the books. I'm not a huge fan of Bran as King but it's not that bad. The show was awesome untill season 5 and after that it was still a great show, just not as good as it had been. I'll still rewatch the show because I still love it and I'll re-read the books and continue to wait for TWoW and ADoS to see how GRRM ends it himself.
  18. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    Ned didn't want Jon to join the wall. That was Benjen and Catelyn.
  19. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    That's what I done. Had A Game of Thrones for a while, read it and then bought A Clash of Kings and read that, and so on. It means you can read other stuff in between if you get burnt out. I think if I had all the book before reading them it would make me think I have to read them all one after the other.
  20. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    You should read them. They are a great read.
  21. KingMudd

    Jon killing Dany doesn’t work for me

    You have completely misunderstood Ned as a character. Ned loved Jon as much as his own children. He didn't want another war and wanted to protect Jon. He couldn't care less about ending the Targaryens becasue if he did he would have been on board with what Tywin done to Aegon and Rhaenys and he would have been fine with assassinating Daenerys. Throughout the time we see Ned he has given us no reason to think he wanted the Targaryens extinct. You are completely making this up to fit your own view.
  22. KingMudd

    Jon is a hypocrite

    We get it, you hate the character Jon. You can stop creating pretty much the same thread over and over again.
  23. KingMudd

    [Book Spoilers] R+L=J, A+J=T and other theories on HBO V.4

    I disagree. I have seen worse finales and shows that are a hell of a lot worse that Game of Thrones.