Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About aeverett

  • Rank

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. Gendry doesn't have the education or temperament to rule the Stormlands. He'd be as bad as Tytos Lannister was in the Westerlands, be taken advantage of for his naivety, and whoever sits on the Iron Throne would have to send armies to clean up his messes the way Aegon V had to for Tytos. I'm sure there are trueborn fifth cousins a few times removed somewhere to take Storm's End. The Tyrells were also a big family over the centuries. There has to be a few minor ones to reclaim Highgarden. Same with the Martells. Remember that big book Ned learned the truth about Cersei's kids in. That thing doesn't exist for nothing. It's there to keep inheritances straight in case of catastrophe.
  2. Dany punishing Jaime for anything. You can make an argument for other characters, but Dany shouldn't say boo or act like her not murdering him by dragonfire is some sort of mercy or charity. Jaime saved over half a million of her subjects from a firey death when he killed her father. He was doing his duty to his queen and his house when he tried to shiska bob her at Blackwater Rush, after she ambushed him with her Dothraki and Drogon and massacred thousands of Lannister soldiers with dragonfire. That is war, and Jaime owes her no apology for that, nor she him. I could see Jaime apologizing for following orders and allowing her father to brutalize and rape her mother, but other than possibly that, he owes her nothing. Many, many others have a rightful bone to pick, but not Dany.
  3. aeverett

    Tarth's Bannermen?

    I would think that though House Tarth isn't a major house, they must have Bannermen, at least as many as Bear Island. I wonder why Brienne hasn't written Lord Selwyn, explained the Army of the Dead thing, and had them come North. Does anyone know how many men we'd be talking about? I don't know if Tarth's population has ever been discussed.
  4. I've been thinking about the insanity displayed by many of the Targs and have come to a conclusion that runs counter to what most would expect. We know that the Valyrians (Targs included) started out as ordinary goat herders until they discovered dragon eggs. They tended the eggs, and slowly, over time noticed physical changes to themselves (Silver hair, oddly colored eyes, better stamina in hot weather, etc) as well as gained the ability to bond with dragons. This goes on for over five millennia, until Daenys has her dreams (or the Targs get into trouble at court) and the Targ family moves to Dragonstone. The doom happens nearly a century later, and a few years after that Aegon begins his conquest. However, Aegon's sons married outside the Valyrian bloodlines. Several generations of Targs did so, even if most kept the incest tradition. Dany and Jon have the blood of House Hightower, House Blackwood, House Martell, etc. in them, and we readers and viewers tend to see that as a good thing. Non-magical humans suffer horribly when they engage in multiple generations of sibling to sibling inbreeding, but what if it's really the outbreeding, not the inbreeding, that drives Targs like Aerion Brightflame and Aerys II insane? Think about it this way; when they produced offspring with non-Valyrians, their physiology began to revert back to that of normal human beings, but retained enough magic to drive them mad. What's more, it wouldn't strike every Targ as the balance of Valyrian to Westerosi genes would be luck of the draw at conception, like a coin flip. From what we've seen with Robert, Stannis, and Renly, and little Shireen, enough out breeding removes the insanity problem, but takes with it the special magic that gives those with 'the blood of Old Valyria' the ability to control dragons. This would put Dany, Jon, and their descendants in a rough spot. Healthy children with no magic and no dragons, or half their family going mad, but the sane ones taking to the skies and ensuring a permanent dynasty built on fire and blood.
  5. aeverett

    What If Tywin Lied About Casterly Rock?

    Firstly, Tywin doesn't trust Cersei. If she thought it in Myrcella or Tommen's best interests that they know that Casterly rock still has plenty of gold, she's going to blab. He'd want her and Tyrion in the dark as he wouldn't believe either worthy of knowing the truth. As for Jaime, he wouldn't want to tell him till he took his place at Casterly Rock. Kevan would likely be the only other person who knew the truth; So long as the mines of Casterly rock produce, the IIron Bank is the problem. They will lend as much money as the king desires if they believe they can get the Lannisters to pay the debt, that's a blank check to unaccountable, spendthrift kings, with Tywin seated on the sidelines while Robert, and then Joffrey, frittered away generations of Lannister wealth. Faking dry mines would force prudence and responsibility when the Iron Bank curtailed its lending. It would also compel the crown to rely more on him, seeing as much of the debt is owned to his house. As for the Tyrells, it's a good match and leaves open the option of shifting the burden of repayment of outstanding debt to another house. After all, a king has to marry someone and binding the two most powerful houses in marriage would help keep the peace, which again is good for debt repayment.
  6. aeverett

    What If Tywin Lied About Casterly Rock?

    When the Lannister gold mines supposedly ran dry, Robert was still alive and there was no indication that he'd die anytime soon. Joffrey was turning out much like Robert, at least in his lack of self discipline and frugality, and Tywin had no idea of Littlefinger's intentions of starting multiple wars for the sole purpose of destabilizing the realm. And you're right, taking Highgarden by force would have made a lot unnecessary enemies, but marrying into the Tyrells wouldn't given Tywin the wealth of the Reach. Officially Joffrey is a Baratheon, so his marriage to Maergary doesn't directly benefit House Lannister. It anything its benefit is in that it shifts the burden of repayment of the royal debt to House Tyrell, and the Iron Bank won't care which cash cow it gets it's pound of flesh from. Cersei's marriage is even less advantageous for House Lannister, as her children with Loras (assuming they had any) would be Tyrells, No, the purpose of that match was to sideline Cersei so she couldn't get in Tywin's way with her sons; she'd made too many mistakes and failed to contain Joffrey's excesses. Shipping her off to Highgarden solved that problem and would put her in the same household with Olenna Tyrell, who Tywin did respect and whom Cersei might learn a thing or two from. However, my argument was that Tywin wanted to appear to have fewer resources for the Iron Bank to exploit. If taking Highgarden through marriage had been his plan, he would have used his control of Joffrey (or Robert before him) to get Jaime booted out of the Kingsguard against his will and then married off to Maergary, while Joffrey would have married Sansa or some other valuable chess piece. Olenna is old and Mace is dumb. Once Olenna is gone (possibly with a little help), Loras could be heralded into the Kingsguard, or publically exposed for his buggery and sent to the Wall,, leaving the future of House Tyrell firmly in Lannister hands and baring the Lannister name. Unless Mace remarried and had more sons (in the show he only had Loras) at some point, Maergary is heir to Highgarden, and Maergary would have to live with Jaime at Casterly Rock. Her kids, Lannister lions every one, would be the heirs to Highgarden and Casterly Rock. That would be the only way for Tywin to use a marriage to gain the resources of Highgarden, and by extension the Reach, under the permanent control of House Lannister. Yet he didn't take that route either. Again, from what I'm seeing, I can't see a scenario where Tywin's maneuvers make sense if Casterly Rock's gold reserves are truly defunct.
  7. I just had a thought while rewatching the scene where Highgarden is taken by the Lannisters and Olenna drinks the poison. Something she said got me thinking. She asks why Tywin didn't just invade Highgarden when the gold mines of Casterly Rock ran dry, then says offhandedly that she'd be able to ask him soon enough. That made me question why didn't Tywin invade? It seems like a move he'd make with his family on the Iron Throne and him as hand, and yet he didn't. Then it hit me; what if the mines under Casterly Rock aren't really dry? What if he stopped mining operations in such a way that it looked like the mines had gone dry, but really there was plenty of gold still there? Might sound crazy, but think about what we know. Tyrion mentioned that the crown owes Tywin a lot of money, but that the Iron Bank is owed way more. What if Tywin tried to curtail Robert's spending by limiting how much he'd loan the crown, but the Iron Bank stepped in, knowing that Tywin would do anything to keep his family in power and his grandchildren on the throne after Robert. That meant they could lend to Robert endlessly and no matter how much the king spent, Casterly Rock's fortune would always be there to pay the debt, lest the bank turn on the current regime. That put Tywin in a pickle and likely brought back bad memories of all the bad loans his father lent out. So Tywin stopped mining the rock and made it look like there was no more gold. Tywin was through co-signing for Robert, and he could plainly see that Joffrey would be no more frugal. The gold would always be there, and future Lannisters could dig it up once their royal dynasty was secure and a more disciplined king sat the throne. Taking Highgarden would have just given the Iron Bank a new target for its predatory lending at House Lannister's expence, which is why the Tyrells kept it as long as they did. So, what do you all think?
  8. aeverett

    Do D&D hate feminity?

    In the books, you get POV, that is you can hear the thoughts of the characters in question. Television is primarily a visual medium, where actions speak loudest and garner the best audience response. Yes, some of the dialogue could be tweaked to make these characters' motivations more clear, but the medium limits the message here, especially in a show world where people rarely speak freely or honestly.
  9. aeverett

    Do D&D hate feminity?

    I don't see it so much as hating femininity, but the natural outcome of so many of the male leaders being killed off. This happened in the War of the Roses which George used as a template for a lot of the dynastic conflict. When so many men die off in a feudal society, either highborn women take a larger and larger share of the power or lower ranked men step into their deceased higher ranked peers shoes. In RL you had a combo of these two phenomenon, and the same holds for GoT. Davos, Gendry, Bronn etc were, as far as we know, low born and they've risen. Women who were highborn to begin with, but limited due to their sex, loose the restrictions and act on their own in lieu of their male relations. Brienne and Arya were unfeminine from the start, but once there were fewer barriers to their be accepted in those traditionally masculine rolls, they were able to shine. Brienne is the perfect example. Look how men treat her in Season 2, when most of the highborn men, though at war, are still around and giving orders, and look at her now. She's grown as a character, yes, but the world has also changed around her at the same time.
  10. aeverett

    Who Will the Lannister Army Follow?

    Not necessarily. The higher ranking officers in the Lannister army would know what Jaime looks like, even without his lion armor, especially with his golden hand. still attached. His choice of not wearing Lannister armor is an attempt to not draw too much attention to himself on the road. Remember, Cersei is likely going to send someone after him, or put out a bounty or something. Heading to the remains of the Lannister forces in his armor would bring too much unnecessary trouble. As for the succession, Cersei comes after Jaime and Tyrion, but before any other Lannister men who aren't Tywin's legitimate progeny. Remember, Westeros works slightly differently than it did in RL history. Women inherit after their brothers, yes, but are not passed over for every other male relative.
  11. I was rewatching 'The Lion and the Wolf' and it occurred to me that while Cersei might wear the crown, Jaime has always commanded the Lannister Army since his father's death. As terrifying as the Mountain is, I doubt the entire army fears him, so why exactly would the remaining forces follow Cersei? Jaime has been with them on the battlefield from Day 1. He's one of them. Cersei is a semi-legal queen, and technically, Jaime is now the head of House Lannister since he's no longer a kingsguard/queensguard and he's the first born male. It just doesn't make sense that they'd follow her. Am I missing something?
  12. aeverett

    [Book Spoilers] Jaime & Brienne- What's going on?

    Yeah. I see the same although I think to make the point that he's completely committed to her and not Cersei, Jamie will die in Brienne's arms. My hope is that she has a little lion cub in the oven by then, so it's not a total loss for her.
  13. aeverett

    What is the role of Gendry?

    From a political POV, legitimizing Gendry would be a VERY dumb move. Anyone who doesn't like House Targaryen could use the Baratheon claim to the Iron Throne to mount a rebellion somewhere down the line, even if Gendry refutes he has any right to it. Dany is far too politically savy to do that, unless, as I suspect, she marries Gendry to unify the only two remaining, legitimate claims. She may love Jon Snow, but if he doesn't survive, as a queen she'll need a consort, and I believe she and Gendry would get along, even if there was no love there. If GoT is based on the War of the Roses, that would be how things go. Henry Tudor's claim was weak; Elizabeth of York's was much stronger, but she was a woman. They started the Tudor dynasty, and England didn't have another civil war for centuries. It was a political move, but they grew to love each other, much the same way that Ned and Catelyn Stark fell in love.
  14. aeverett

    Season 8 Predictions?

    1. Jon Snow will die in the Great War, and Dany will legitimize Gendry and marry him in order to secure the Iron Throne, thus merging the two legit claims, Targaryen and Baratheon, into one like Henry Tudor and Elizabeth of York did in the War of the Roses. It won't be a love match, but they will get along and respect each other. Dany will do most of the ruling, as she was raised to rule. 2. Nymeria will move her large wolf pack from the Riverlands to fight the Night King with the human and dragon warriors in the Great War against the Whitewalkers and the army of the undead. 3. Jamie Lannister will be the one to strike the fatal blow to the Night King, thus reforming his title of Kingslayer into a positive. Like Hodor's renaming from Willis, the name's true meaning is a foreshadowing of Jamie's destiny, not his past. This is not to say he's the Prince that is Promised or anything, only that the last blow that kills the Night King will be his. 4. Once Arya finishes her list, she will claim that she is finally 'no one'. She won't go back to the Faceless Men, but she'll feel empty and purposeless. 5. Cersei will carry her new baby to term, but be killed before she can deliver. The baby will be cut out of her body and survive, thus fulfilling the prophesy that she would have three children, as she didn't live to give birth to the forth. The baby will be a sign of a new age and new hope for the Lannister family and Tyrion will raise him or her to be better than their forebearers.