Jump to content

Back door hodor

Members
  • Content count

    212
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Back door hodor

  1. Back door hodor

    Why did Benjen take the black?

    Oh yea i get it, I was simply saying I get the point of view that the alliances seem a bit contrived, and I agree that something probably happened with Ned and Ashara, maybe not an official bethothal, but the other Dornish ladies we have meet are not bothered by such things, so it's no great a stretch to say Ashara wouldn't be either, but yes there is something there. I think something is up with Edmure as well, perhaps another alliance that feel through?
  2. Back door hodor

    Why did Benjen take the black?

    This is interesting, and you are right to a degree I think, the bethothals don't make much sense except for plot convenience, to set the sides for Robert's Rebellion. For example I think a double marriage between Stark and Tully makes more sense, if Rickards intent was to bring the riverlands under his rule,(which is not certain), meaning Brandon and Cat and Edumure And Lyanna, so this way the next generation of both houses would be tied(the way Daeron the good brought Dorne into the realm btw). However even those factions are loosely defined and in flux, not to mention the fact that thier may or may not be a third faction, led by Tywin and Reagar, that is also possibly working to build political power to oppose Aerys. It all gets real messy and to me the only thing certain is that there are several pieces of very important information still missing. As for Ben specifically, he does not seem resentful or bitter with his lot in life(the watch), in fact, he seems content if not happy in the limited interaction that Jon has with him. So right now, I would say he definitely went there of his own free will, like Jon, I am not sure exactly why though.
  3. Back door hodor

    Why did Benjen take the black?

    He is Neds Heir before Robb is born
  4. No...... Littlefinger became the manipulating dick that he is, primarily due to his childhood at riverrun and the duel with Brandon, he wasn't born that way, so no, outright manipulation of Lords paramount and the IT is simply not in his playbook at this time
  5. Back door hodor

    Targaryen fleet destroyed...

    I'd say yes, the fact that house Velayron is depicted as much more powerful and influential in the world book and FaB, than in the main series, in which they are barely mentioned, suggests such a recent setback is not only possible, but likely They go from a family that can challenge the free cities for supremacy in the narrow sea without official support of the IT, to simply one of Stannis' barely significant bannermen, a very big change.
  6. Back door hodor

    the honeyed locusts...

    Honestly my main thoughts from this is the mathematical conversion in the first half of your post... If 20 stone=280 pounds that mean that... At 40 stone, The mountain weighs in at 560 pounds... Holy fuck
  7. Back door hodor

    Who's the worst human being, Tywin Lannister or Roose Bolton

    Nailed it Haha for real though, both are terrible, but no worse or better than Jon Arryn or Hoster Tully, a couple of "good guy" patriarchs, so it's all relative I think Edit: actually, of the four I mentioned, by modern standards, Tully is far and away the worst, the other 3 were ruthless to thier enemies, Hoster forcibly aborted his own grandchild to save face.
  8. Back door hodor

    Where does the Iron in the Iron Isles come from?

    There are mines In the hills on great wick, aeron complains that lord(I think goodfoot, but I cant remember off the top) holdfast is inland, away from the sea, he also muses that thier smallfolk are miners and such, I'll look up specifics if anyone is interested, this is just from memory
  9. Back door hodor

    Poll: Has Myrcella Already Died Off-Page?

    no, not yet, but she will doe soon I think
  10. Back door hodor

    How are they gonna get outta this one??

    I admit I could be very wrong about this, but my feeling is that if Theon was going to die he would have already done so, at this point, living and facing those he has wronged is a greater punishment for him than dieing. No Godless man may sit the seastone chair..... The name Theon literally translates to of God or godly...so yea.. theon is in it for the long haul
  11. The timelines in the world book are definitely suspect. The Andals claim they learned iron working from the Smith himself, most likely both they and the Valyrians learned from the Rhoynar. The world book dates the the destruction of the Rhoynar and Nymerias exile at between 700 to 1000 years ago. Most likely the Andal date of colonization is closer to this timeframe than the 4000, tbh 2k even seems high given this context. The Andals themselves claim the Seven themselves lead them to Westeros for no reason other than it was thier "promised land" and make no mention of fleeing from dragon fire. The Rhoynar exodus and wars are much better documented. I believe all the free cities save Bravos where founded by Valyria, meaning there may have been much smaller settlements where Pentos and Lorath are now, and only grew to thier size and influence with Valyrian influence and support. I regards to Bravos, to support a Navy and city that size, they simply must control some part on mainland essos for resources, everything cant be brought in by trade. It is never mentioned but I would definitely assume that any andals left in essos after the Doom, either were absorbed by one of the growing free cities(and due to Geographic convenience, pentos makes the most sense) or wiped out by the dothraki, there is simply no where else they could go.
  12. Back door hodor

    Weirdwood tree seeds?

    It really is
  13. Back door hodor

    Future Centers of Power in a Democratic Westeros/Systems of Government

    The most likely scenario I think is some sort of constitutional monarchy in which the lords do not give up all thier power, but do make concessions. Like the house of commons and the house of Lords in the British parliament or something like that
  14. Back door hodor

    Weirdwood tree seeds?

    There is real world precedent for this, there is an entire forest in the American southwest that is a single organism connected at the root system, no individual tree is over 300 years old, and are all genetic clones, but the organism itself estimated to have been alive at least 80,000 years. Edit. Many grasses and herbs grow in this manner but are not nearly as old. Also, I don't know the scientific name of the tree but they are colloquially called pando clones, and I read a very interesting article in National Geographic about them. The pando forest is located in south central Utah and takes up approximately 106 acres of land above ground, it theoretically could spread out further underground, in addition to being one of the oldest know living organism, it is also the one of heaviest at an estimated 6 million kgs
  15. Back door hodor

    Who are these People?

    That is definitely one of the better guesses I've seen
  16. Back door hodor

    The Ghost of High Heart, and a promised... “Prince”?

    So if I understand you correctly you are having a hard time with the the ghosts vision recommending or condoning inscest? I don't think that this, or any or her dreams, reccomend or condone any course of action. They simply say what will be, they don't say do x and y will happen, they just say x will happen. The ones you quoted anyway, and sadly we have no direct quote from the ghost to Jahearys to confirm this but my guess is it follows the same pattern. It is a wildcard because it is a prophecy about another(most likely misinterpreted) prophecy. The Ghost herself has an almost unbelievable success rate with the dreams she tells the BWB. So in my opinion she is likely right and everyone around her was interpreting things incorrectly or perhaps incompletely. Aemon seems to come to a similar conclusion on his deathbed, but there is every possibility he( and I)could be very wrong.
  17. Back door hodor

    The Updated Exodus Theory and its Corollaries

    Personally, I think dani has learned her lesson with meereen, she might cross essos and leave a string of burning cities in her wake, but she will no longer attempt to rule them, this could still work for your theory though.
  18. Back door hodor

    Is Asha pregnant?

    Gonna be honest I had not really thought much about this one before but I kinda like it, especially the whole salt hisband thing
  19. Back door hodor

    Poll: Is Lemore Actually Ashara?

    No
  20. Back door hodor

    How far south will the Others get?

    Winterfell, I honestly don't think there is enough time(well really space, and by that I mean only 2 books left) for them to get any further south than that without a whole lot of action happening "off page"
  21. Back door hodor

    Predict her future: Penny

    Honestly as a likeable ancillary character, worst case she dies like Syrio, best case she disappears into the background and escapes the game of thrones like hot pie.
  22. For me Dani, Sansa and Brienne are the top candidates, while I think Cersei herself may have been threatened by Sansa(I certainly think so but Cersies POVs do not start until after Sansa leaves the city so we see no direct interaction from Cersei POV), and definitely Marge, based on her thoughts and actions in her Chapters. I think the other part of the prophecy(about Cerseis kids dieing) rules out Myrcella as a possibility, so I don't think its her. We also don't technically know if Val or Asha(I think she's younger than Cersei but as far as I remember we don't know her age) is actually younger than Cersei. I mention this because the younger part seems the more important/easiest factor to identify of said prophecy. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder after all P.S. I'm a big fan of the Martells and Arianne specifically, for this reason solely, I'm convinced they are all going to die, and have no Hope's for thier future.
  23. Back door hodor

    Minor/offscreen characters you want to see more of

    Hugo Wull....who wants to be six and twenty again. Edit: lots of IB hate up top but I like them, particularly Theon,(not as a person, I find his arc interesting, and feel like it's not over.)and Roderick the reader, and I think Euron is an interesting, compelling and sufficiently dangerous and/or mysterious character to be a worthwhile villain going forward.
  24. Back door hodor

    Which minor houses do you want to see more of?

    Reanyra's maybe Velaryon sons all rode dragons. So did Adam, brother of Alyn Oakenfist,( who was most likely the Seasnakes bastard) all died during the Dance. There might have been a couple before them, I forget off the top of my head Dragon riders, not Dragonlords.
  25. I'm not sure, I think Ned would not have moved against Robert's trueborn son, but I also don't think he would simply let everything lie with the Lannisters when he thinks that they tried to kill Bran. I this scenario I honestly think it's much more likely he takes Renly up on his original offer to take Joffery in hand by force, but Ned is truly not a great player of the game, the outcome would probably be the same in the end, sadly.
×