Jump to content

WolfBitch

Members
  • Content count

    17
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About WolfBitch

  • Rank
    Commoner

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Can’t see that happening. Sansa’s in the Vale, going to a tournament where “interesting things will happen” according to Martin’s own words, she’ll hypothetically marry Harry and reveal herself as Sansa, get the needed support and head North. Then there’s the whole plot of her being Littlefinger’s doom. I doubt Arya will steal a face from the FM or be tasked to go to Westeros. She’s just an acolyte, and far from the best one. And also I don’t think Arya will be Sansa’s “catspaw”, Sansa’s guard, Sansa’s personal killer or any kind of servent. And I can’t see her going to KL, there’s nothing for her there besides Cersei, but Arya is wanted as a prisoner. KL is far from the safest place, that’s why I think she’ll go to Saltspan, reunite with Gendry and Nymeria then go to the North with her pack and Robb’s crown.
  2. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    I believe Arya will kill Stoneheart, head North with Robb’s crown then crown Jon herself just like Visenya did to Aegon. Do you remember when Jon said to Arya that women get the arms but not the swords and bastards get the swords but not the arms? Still, he gave Arya a sword, now it’s time to give him the arms. But Jon’s resurrection probably won’t be like Stoneheart’s since he warged Ghost after he died. I strongly believe Arya will sail back to Saltpans and not the North because she needs to find Nymeria’s pack again (Martin said the pack is very important) and they’re in the Trident.
  3. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    I guess I’d agree with you if the Mountain lived, but now there’s only Robert Strong now? I mean, in Bran’s vision he said that there was nothing inside the helmet. Sometimes I think that Ser Robert might be headless? Qyburn is kind of a scientist-necromancer, while Beric gave Catelyn the kiss of life, so she has a spark of R’hllor’s fire within. But perhaps each case of resurrection is different.
  4. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    The Un-Cat lives for vengeance. It’s not all about her, it’s also about the innocent who suffer with her fury. Arya can recognize when someone is lying and when someone is telling the truth. Stoneheart can not and does not care. How wouldn’t it be merciful to give what’s left of her mother some rest? A proper funeral? When Catelyn was alive she even said she wanted to reunite with Ned as long as her children lived. What do you mean “sending her soul to hell”? Like wtf. This is a huge and weird assumption. Martin said she’s an important part of the >>>>>whole<<<<< book. There’s plenty of time for Arya and her to meet. Besides, Arya felt like she had no heart because she associates her family with her heart, her heart where “her brothers once lived”. This is not something she can’t recover, for seven’s sake. Bran, Rickon and Sansa are very much alive, and Jon will be resurrected. They will meet again, that’s a fact. “The wolves will come again” just like Jojen said. Stoneheart’s death by Arya’s hands is symbolic. Is putting revenge aside, is giving mercy to innocent people and rest to her mother. Is the Hound’s words coming to light. Is preparing her body just like she learned at the HoB&W. Everything leads to this. Is just a matter of interpretation.
  5. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Besides, is hard to consider this “kinslaying” since George himself said that Catelyn is already dead.
  6. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    I agree with you, Arya was always there and she said she can’t let go of Arya, but by staying in Braavos and at the House of B&W she still tries to deny her nature. Is about time for her to find out that this is impossible. For me the perfect moment for her leaving is the 10th day of The Unmasking of Uthero.
  7. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Indeed is pretty weird. But I guess each case of resurrection is different, like Beric, Stoneheart, Drogo, Gregor... I still believe that they all can be killed somehow.
  8. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Arya killed innocents like the stableboy in self defense and she hated it. She felt sad about it. She took no pleasure from it. That’s why Arya will never be a Faceless Man, because she kills for specific reasons. Her own reasons. Arya doesn’t even understand the concept of Valar Morghulis, she doesn’t understand why her father had to die while bad people still live. Her arc with the Faceless Men serve as a way to show us that Arya’s story is about recovering her identity and not loosing it. Mercy’s chapter shows that, Cat’s chapters shows that, Blind Beth chapters shows that. And Arya >doesn’t want< to kill innocent people. She’s very much a people’s person, Sansa herself said that and that never changed. Arya is all about recovering her identity and understanding that vengeance is an unworthy dark path. Nothing better to show her that than Lady Stoneheart, the personification of vengeance.
  9. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Well, Catelyn died without knowing the truth about Jon’s paternity. She died with no love or consideration for him, and I don’t think is possible for Lady Stoneheart to develop those feelings at this point. Just like Lem said, all she wants is her children alive and to feed the ravens with corpses.
  10. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    The major point of Arya is to recognize that this is not right. While she wants to do justice killing specific people who did terrible things, Stoneheart wants to kill anyone associated with the Freys and Lannisters, even the innocent. The biggest part of Arya’s list is based on people who’ve harmed others, not her; but the innocent. The thing she needs to understand is that this is something that would never end, just like Ellaria said.
  11. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Actually her killings are arbitrary. That’s why Brienne went to Jaime, because Stoneheart’s threatened to kill Podrick, who was only Tyrion’s squire, and a child of 12. Thoros himself said that the Brotherhood is not about justice anymore as they were before, they are all about blind vengeance. And Sansa probably won’t meet her. Her arc is in the Vale, Arya’s the one who has maaaany business unsolved at the Riverlands. The only thing I can imagine besides Arya is Bran seeing her through a vision. “After Catelyn’s resurrection, it was Lady Stoneheart who became a vengeful and merciless killer.” - GRRM And about Arya not having problems with this... well, you should read her chapters. She hates killing innocent people even for self defense. He has nightmares about it. She’s not a killing machine who’s totally ok with the murdering of children.
  12. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    You actually can kill the undead. Beric died many times. Of course his situation was different, but that’s because Catelyn was found 3 days latter. Still, she can be killed. Arya will likely stick Needle in her stoneheart since her throat is already cut. That’s the Hound’s teaching where the heart is, because Arya almost always cut throats to kill.
  13. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Disagree. The Uncloaking of Uthero is the reflection of Arya taking off her mask and going back to Westeros. Braavos is described as a city of fogs and masks and secrets. Braavos represents the part of the Heroe’s Journey where the character finds himself (herself) again. And Arya never learned how to change her face. The Kindly Man himself said that this takes >years< to learn. If Arya’s to go to Westeros wearing other face she’d have to steal from the temple and they wouldn’t be okay with this. This is not the show. I personally think she’ll meet Justin Massey who was tasked to go to Braavos and he’ll probably bring Jeyne Poole with him) Jon wanted to send Arya to Braavos, plot twist). She’ll return to Saltpans but not as Nan, Salty, Mercy, Cat, Weasel or Beth, but as Arya. And also I don’t think Gendry will become KG only because he did “brave things”. Of course I agree Arya’s attracted to bravery, but Gendry is still a bastard and he wasn’t even an acknowledged bastard or son of a noble woman like his brother Edric, who was raised as a highborn. People are doubting of Aegon, and only Varys could have a proof of Gendry’s paternity, and I honestly can’t see Varys doing this.
  14. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    Catelyn is dead. Lady Stoneheart rose in her place as an avenging zombie. She was resurrected with the fire of R’hllor. And she’s creating a genocide in the Riverlands.
  15. WolfBitch

    WHY ARYA WILL BE THE ONE TO KILL LADY STONEHEART

    I don’t think she’ll infiltrate. She’ll come back to Westeros as Arya.
×