Jump to content

LordSeaSnake

Members
  • Posts

    50
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by LordSeaSnake

  1. Time for an extremely minor nitpick I have with the worldbuilding is the name consistency. European noble families picked first names from a relatively small pool of names, and often used the same ones repeatedly. From a writing standpoint, I understand it, as it would be painful if literally every Stark was named Brandon. By and large, it's typically fine with the Starks as we have a pool of Brandon, Benjen, Rickard, Rickon, etc. but then you get random wildcard names like Walton and Rodwell, which don't really seem to fit and almost take you out of it with how disparate the name appears to be. Then with the Arryns, we get an Arnold and a Darnold, and Eldric and an Elbert, and not one name of a King of the Vale is repeated by any post-Conquest Arryns. The Lannisters don't have a single repeating name amongst the lords of Casterly Rock, but at least they generally use a consistent naming scheme with Gerold, Jason, Loreon (though why Loren?), and Damon being used by other members of the house. The most jarring for me was the names of Daemon Velaryon's three sons: Corwyn, Jorgen, and Victor. Corwyn was used twice by Corbrays, so I could see maybe Daemon wed an Arryn or prominent Vale lady, and she named their children. But Jorgen and Victor???? For Valyrians??? Otherwise, I enjoy how the Velaryons seem to have their own pool of Valyrian names with only a few being shared with the Targaryens. And we are told Jacaerys is a common name amongst the Velaryons, yet we only see it once, though at least see two Daemons, Corlys, and Lucerys. I would have appreciated a pool of names for each region, with some crossover between neighbouring regions, or maybe the south, Dorne, Iron Islands, and the north/First Men houses having a relatively consistent pool of names. It would feel more immersive if we had nobility from the westerlands more often than not named Tybolt or Jason or Gerold rather than Erwin or Podrick or Antario. The maesters have their own issue where a good portion of maesters likely come from nobility, but their first names are virtually never seen amongst the landed nobility of Westeros. I couldn't imagine seeing a Alfador Westerling, or a Yandel Smallwood, or a Aethelmure Roote. I just always find it odd how the maester names seem to be picked from another continent. Anyways, bizarre and nitpicky rant over. Probably hypocritical, but I have grown a bit fond of the Dance-era Tully names.
  2. Agreed with the lovers field. I think it would look cleaner if the predecessors/successors fields were replaced with a succession template similar to Wikipedia's, for example see the very bottom of this Wikipedia page where the Duke of Buckingham's noble titles and offices are listed with the predecessors and successors. Perhaps this isn't needed for offices like master of coin and such, as there are existing templates, but I think it looks cleaner than having it all in the infobox.
  3. Agreed, infoboxes are meant to provide a brief overview about a character. If a predecessor/successor field is deemed necessary, it should be modeled off of Wikipedia's method, where it's located at the bottom of the page.
  4. I found an interesting line from The World of Ice & Fire that may help to resolve the relation between Loren the Last and Lord Lyman Lannister. This indicates that Lyman was a son of Loren the Last. This seems to be in-line with Tyrion's statement that Loren did not have children until after Aegon's Conquest. As for Loren's eldest son and heir that wed a Redwyne, perhaps Lyman is a second son or remarried to Jocasta Tarbeck. We can probably work in a note about this in Loren's and Lyman's Family section on the wiki.
  5. I added a little note on Raymont's wiki page about his canonical status. I suppose we will have to wait for the final word from Ran about whether or not Raymont is being permanently removed from canon. Even if he is, I think we should leave his wiki article and just make it out-of-universe detailing that the character has been removed, in case someone with an old copy of TWOIAF tries searching for him.
  6. Ibben was once ruled by a god-king, but is now ruled by a council of nobles and merchants. Each city in the Kingdom of Sarnor was ruled by a king, all ruled in turn by a high king. It's unknown if Saath, the surviving Sarnoi city, is still ruled by a king. By the beginning of ASOIAF, the Kingdom of Omber is still ruled by kings.
×
×
  • Create New...