Ghostlydragon

It seems the web site is down, pending renewal. Does anyone have the coloured A FEAST WITH DRAGONS correct reading order they can post here? I was planning to do my reread soon and wanted to do it in the chronological order but will be unable to.

And the only 'top tier actor on the commentary is Emilia Clarke. Clearly most people don't want anything to do with the show any more. I bet they pretty much begged her to do this commentary with them.

Gods that's insane. He'd have never gotten away with that or even thought about doing that when Robb was their king. King Robb even hanged someone for just watching murders take place. Why is Jon so useless. Did his strength and authority die with him at Castle Black or something?

Because season 5 onwards Tyrion is such a good guy that he finds all forms of violence wrong and must never hold a weapon or do any kind of fighting ever again

Oh I know. Season 5 is where it really starts going wrong. 4 had some bad moments but had far more good than bad. I just meant that despite 5, 6 and 7 being awful, they still got generally good reviews. It wasn't until 8 that even the people who ignored the problems finally saw through it all. That's what I meant by 8 being the point where the ratings and reviews were really low compared to what came before.

Has a final season of any other show been that low after what came before was a lot higher. I'd bet on How I Met Your Mother but that started sliding a few years before the final season. Although the final season was by far the worst.

Stark, Lannister, Baratheon and Targaryen houses so pretty much all the major characters

A dream of spring would be awesome but Queen of the Ashes seems likely after last week

You know the whole issue around the lack ofproof on Jon's birth really annoys me. I really thought we would get Howland Reed to confirm it as well as a few flashbacks. I mean they have the actors from season 6 and 7. Why not have Jon take Bran's hand and touch a weirwood tree together so we can get Raegar and Lyanna's life together. There is so much material there and it's been totally ignored. I can't be the only one who wanted to see them meet, talk about prophecy, why they never went public with their romance to try to stop the war thathad started. But much like how we never saw the Bran tell the other Starks about Jon's birth, our wise and self-important showrunners obviously didn'tthink it matters.

Appalling. Dany can't snap just like that. Because the people didnt worship her? The city had only just surrendered. Wouldn't it take time for the small folk to get to her? None of that made sense. I wonder if she's basically gonna be Queen Rhaenyra Targaryen. The one who was in charge during the first riot of kings landing and was truly hated. I'd hate for Drogon to be killed by the mob though.

Is he kidding? That's ridiculous.

The goofy Euron who didn't wonder how the hell Tyrion could know Cersei is pregnant. Seriously wtf. He better do something logical next week. Like imprison cersei as his sex slave and have the golden company let whatever Lannister men left know who is really in charge. But wait a minute that is way too logical and obvious for what the show has become.

He simply shouldn't have allowed it to be adapted yet. Maybe a year after Winds of Winter came out and he knew Dream of Spring wouldn't be long.

I hope we get this. Tormund mentioning the real north again and confirming his people don't want to live south of the wall, even at The Gift is a strong hint Jon could go there. Even if they go down the mad queen route with Dany and whether she lives or dies, this would be a perfect way for Jon to leave this all behind and prove he has no interest in the throne.

Yep and that turned out to just be a storm. So i guess the snow in kings landing at the end of s7 turned out to be a very minor bit of sleet too. The lack of a real winter in this show is infuriating. The bad weather the walkers bought in ep3 is the closest thing we got to it.