Jump to content

Chista

Members
  • Posts

    8
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Female

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

Chista's Achievements

Commoner

Commoner (1/8)

  1. i obviously meant the only sensible person.
  2. has anyone here read a song for lya short story? let me show you what it says about it in wikipedia these characters are worlds apart, but their personalities as well as their names seem to be the same. and even though they are very different, i tend to parallel Robb with Robert Baratheon. i wonder why grrm has used similar names. it really seems like an alternative universe. Lyanna Stark's story has had a strong effect on the story and characters in asoiaf, yet as a character we don't have that much information about her. it makes me wonder if the Lyanna in a song for Lya could unravel more of her personality for us asoiaf readers. and more than that, could this be how Robert/Lyanna relationship would've worked out if they had been married, without Lyanna running off/being stolen? what do you think? but forget about characters, i wanna talk about the fucking Greeshka. it's not just the Greeshka, even the alian race Shkeen sound similar to the children of the forest. comparing the ending of Lyanna in these two universes/stories, in a song for Lya, in asoiaf Lyanna asks Ned to bury her in Winterfel. could this mean that the vaults in Winterfel have a connection to the weirwood trees and the scary caves of children of the forest? also, a great story and a great storyteller. if you're waiting for the winds and haven't read a song for Lya, i recommend you read it. the universes are different for sure, but the writing, the shape of the story, it's atmosphere and aesthetic all feel the same.
  3. I'm sorry to break it to you but Jon was the only one
  4. no idea. i guess the only thing she would have to give would be herself, and there's no way i could see her become a FM. i agree with all you said there. most likely even if she goes to the house of black and white they'd send her someplace safe to stay and have a happy normal life. i hope.
  5. a thought came to me while rereading a storm of swords. i came by this passage at the end of Arya1 we know from the old bear that "the things we love destroy us everytime". hunting was what King Robert loved and it killed him. and grrm seems to kill his characters while protecting people they love, or doing the things they love. like the way Eddard confessed committing treason before he died, because he was threatened with Sansa's life. we know that Ramsay Snow loves hunting, though his is a much uglier type. the sentence i quoted reminds me of Ramsay and his hunting. could his downfall be something close to this? while he thinks he is hunting another victim while in truth he is being hunted? by Arya, maybe through Nymeria? though i don't see how her pack could get so far north, or she herself. it is only this sentence that gives me such an idea. i wanted to see how you fellow asoiaf inthusiasts think about this somewhat theory. i've also heard theories where The Faceless Men give Arya the job of killing Cercei, which doesn't make sense imo because she knows Cercei and FM don't kill people they know. yet there is s1 in westeros who she doesn't know, whose victim is asumed to be heading to braavos in the winds by asoiaf fans. if the theory is that Arya can't leave the FM that easily and the most likely way she leaves them for westeros is getting a job to kill someone there (i heard that in YouTube), why not Ramsay? what if Jeyne Pool goes to braavos in winds and asks the FM to kill the monster she was forced to marry? and Arya doesn't know Ramsay, yet it's very unlikely they'd send an acolyte for something like that but it's at the very least more likely than Cercei. also Jeyne going to the FM is unlikely in the first place. anyways. again i'd like to hear what you guys think
  6. a thought came to me while rereading a storm of swords. i came by this passage at the end of Arya1 we know from the old bear that "the things we love destroy us everytime". hunting was what King Robert loved and it killed him. and grrm seems to kill his characters while protecting people they love, or doing the things they love. like the way Eddard confessed committing treason before he died, because he was threatened with Sansa's life. we know that Ramsay Snow loves hunting, though his is a much uglier type. the sentence i quoted reminds me of Ramsay and his hunting. could his downfall be something close to this? while he thinks he is hunting another victim while in truth he is being hunted? by Arya, maybe through Nymeria? though i don't see how her pack could get so far north, or she herself. it is only this sentence that gives me such an idea. i wanted to see how you fellow asoiaf inthusiasts think about this somewhat theory. i've also heard theories where The Faceless Men give Arya the job of killing Cercei, which doesn't make sense imo because she knows Cercei and FM don't kill people they know. yet there is s1 in westeros who she doesn't know, whose victim is asumed to be heading to braavos in the winds by asoiaf fans. if the theory is that Arya can't leave the FM that easily and the most likely way she leaves them for westeros is getting a job to kill someone there (i heard that in YouTube), why not Ramsay? what if Jeyne Pool goes to braavos in winds and asks the FM to kill the monster she was forced to marry? and Arya doesn't know Ramsay, yet it's very unlikely they'd send an acolyte for something like that but it's at the very least more likely than Cercei. also Jeyne going to the FM is unlikely in the first place. anyways. again i'd like to hear what you guys think
  7. a thought came to me while rereading a storm of swords. i came by this passage at the end of Arya1 we know from the old bear that "the things we love destroy us everytime". hunting was what King Robert loved and it killed him. and grrm seems to kill his characters while protecting people they love, or doing the things they love. like the way Eddard confessed committing treason before he died, because he was threatened with Sansa's life. we know that Ramsay Snow loves hunting, though his is a much uglier type. the sentence i quoted reminds me of Ramsay and his hunting. could his downfall be something close to this? while he thinks he is hunting another victim while in truth he is being hunted? by Arya, maybe through Nymeria? though i don't see how her pack could get so far north, or she herself. it is only this sentence that gives me such an idea. i wanted to see how you fellow asoiaf inthusiasts think about this somewhat theory. i've also heard theories where The Faceless Men give Arya the job of killing Cercei, which doesn't make sense imo because she knows Cercei and FM don't kill people they know. yet there is s1 in westeros who she doesn't know, whose victim is asumed to be heading to braavos in the winds by asoiaf fans. if the theory is that Arya can't leave the FM that easily and the most likely way she leaves them for westeros is getting a job to kill someone there (i heard that in YouTube), why not Ramsay? what if Jeyne Pool goes to braavos in winds and asks the FM to kill the monster she was forced to marry? and Arya doesn't know Ramsay, yet it's very unlikely they'd send an acolyte for something like that but it's at the very least more likely than Cercei. also Jeyne going to the FM is unlikely in the first place. anyways. again i'd like to hear what you guys think.
  8. I'm sorry for this silly bit but i think there's this minor flaw i would be thrilled if it was fixed. i was going through the major characters pages and oddly i found whilst they are referred as 'one of the major POV characters in a song of ice and fire' in their wiki page, Arya Stark is simply written as 'a POV character in a song of ice and fire'. that led me to thinking she's not one of the major characters untill i read this: Here she is mentioned as 'some major characters' by grrm so she is among them. I'd be very happy if someone cared to fix this
×
×
  • Create New...