Jump to content

Righteous Indecision

  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Righteous Indecision

  1. I second that. Frankly, I've never completely forgiven Ned Stark for the killing of Sansa's direwolf. Killing cannines is never something I like, and when they're the symbol of your house (and your culture is into symbolism).... it was bad politics too. I suspect GRRM never thought much of Ned Stark - too noble, too pliant, and not enough bite. Anyway, the more direwolves that make it, the happier I am.
  2. It's almost impossible to import food into The North on a meaningful scale. The north is roughly analogous to Russia. It's shaped a bit like the Scottish highlands, but it's much, much, bigger. If you take a map of the seven kingdoms, and use the wall as your scale (it's 100 leagues -> 300 miles -> 482km) you can start measuring the rest of the country. Long story short, the north seems to be around two million square kilometres - 50% the size of European Russia. Two million square kilometres is over three Ukraines, or four Spains. It's 1.66 times all of Scandinavia (including Finland and Iceland). The distance from the Wall in the farthest north, to Oldcastle on the south coast (of North) is over 1700km. That's around the distance from Copenhagen, to the top of Norway in the Arctic Circle - so it's about as tall as Scandinavia, but better filled-out landwise. But it won't be filled out in terms of people. Most medieval folk didn't live in cities. They lived where they could grow or hunt food - all spread out. Kingsroad aside, Medieval roads were often swampy or axle-breakingly uneven, and moving goods along them could be hard because wagons don't go up hills very easily, or down them very safely. Importing food is easiest if you have modern technology, or a lot of sea/river access compared to your landmass (like Britain). The North is just too big.
  3. I have a slightly different perspective than Cersei being stupid or being clever; she has a need. I think Cersei needs to be in control, and overwhelming control is her vice. Joffrey is the same, he needs to dominate utterly. When Joffrey changes Ned's sentence to execution - because he wants to - he's demonstrating that overwhelming power. He's satisfying his need, and satisfying her need as well because he is a manifestation of her power. So she does nothing.
  4. I distinctly remember Jaime remembering how Tywin diligently helped him overcome his reading difficulties. That's the work of a parent. Perhaps it's one of the few really warm things about Tywin, but there it is. As for Cersei... she's regarded as overestimating her own abilities by some of her contemporaries. I can't remember if it was Varys or Littlefinger, but I'm inclined to think the former. Basically he/they said that her attractive femininity was her biggest asset rather and her mind. From her own internal monologue she seems to have believed the opposite: her femininity was the only thing holding her back. Unfortunately for Cersei, she doesn't appear to be as clever as Olenna Tyrell. Not stupid, but not particularly exceptional. So Cersei's resentment of her father, from reading, does look more like a conceit. I do think she went through life looking down on others. Refusing to acknowledge Tyrion's abilities even as she seemed threatened by them (and his position as hand of the King) seems consistent. But worst of all, Cersei definitely inherited her father's desire/need to dominate and to control. People with such needs aren't likely to feel good about themselves unless they have their worth externally validated through domination, they are - in a sense - weak. I don't think trauma serves as a cause, as plenty of people in worse situations have not manifested domineering tendencies, while people in good situations still do. Tyrion was treated worse than her. Danny, likewise (though I'm aware she may get nastier... not a huge TV fan). John Snow had it worse in some ways than Cersei too. With that domineering need, Cersei's exercise of power was therefore always personal, rather than professional. That acute need had to be sated regularly, and because it was strong she sometimes satisfied it to the detriment of her own interests (never mind the interests of others). So no, I don't think Tywin traumatised Cersei as we would commonly accept it. She just felt horrible when meeting someone she couldn't control. And with Tywin, she never felt close to doing that.
  • Create New...