Jump to content

Former Lord of Winterfell

Members
  • Content count

    13,681
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Former Lord of Winterfell

  • Rank
    Council Member

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Not Telling

Recent Profile Visitors

4,685 profile views
  1. Former Lord of Winterfell

    Guy Gavriel Kay

    That - and even more so the sympathetic portray of the female lead - aggravated me so much I've never picked up another GGK book since.
  2. Former Lord of Winterfell

    Glen Cooks The Black Company series

    Skip the Books of the South, and jump to the Glittering Stone. I really liked Water Sleeps.
  3. Former Lord of Winterfell

    Glen Cooks The Black Company series

    I like the older Dread Empire series more than Instrumentalities, which almost seems like Cook's attempt to complicate things ala Bakker/Erikson. He's always got that war-weary, generally good guy but with human failings leader at the core of his stories -- Bragi Ragnarson from Dread Empire and Piper Hecht from Instrumentalities are both a similar riff on Croaker. Dread Empire is a lot of fun, though I thought the recently-published conclusion to the entire series was weak. You can stop before then and not miss much. And instrumentalities is still good and worth a read. I'm really partial to the end of Soldiers Live too. Can't recall a fantasy series that had such an appropriate ending other than the "well, I'm back" at the end of Lord of the Rings. I thought some of the Books of the South dragged a bit -- Murgen as narrator lacks Croaker's personality.
  4. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP310 Discussion

    Glad you said this because I thought the exact same thing. I really didn't like his portrayal of Jon earlier on, but I think he's gotten better, and he nailed that scene. The exact kind of passionate, not quite the right words, emotive outburst that seemed very real to me. It was clearly an incredible awkward moment for the character, completely torn between two loves/duties, and I bought it 100%.
  5. Former Lord of Winterfell

    How would you rate episode 310?

    Gave it a 7, which is kind of low for me. I didn't judge it on how faithful to the book it was -- just on how well it stood on its own merits. A lot of the individual scenes were really good -- Arya/Hound, Tywin/Joffrey, Theon/Bastard, Jon/Ygritte, Tyrion/Sansa, Sam/Bran, and Walder Frey in particular was wonderful again. But as an episode, it was cobbled-together bits and pieces of "wrap-up", and too obviously so. Did not like a few scenes. The Jaime/Cersei scene was like a cheesy romantic homecoming of a war hero, but this is supposed to be a twisted incestuous relationship at its core. There was no sense of wrongness at all, and they've been good on that in prior Jaime/Cersei scenes. The Shae scene didn't work for me because I still don't think they've set up why she would really love him. She clearly does, but it still makes no sense. But the biggest problem for me was the Danaery's scene. Yes, it was cheesy, but I just don't think Emilia Clarke is very good at all. She's the exact same in every scene -- slightly superior look, with an undertone of being very pleased with herself after pronouncing a few words of Valyrian. Wooden as hell, IMHO.
  6. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    I think you are right about this. However, I think it is possible that a 15-16 year old Robb might have miscontrued how is father would have acted. Especially if he was sporting a boner. I mean, realistically, it is quite possible that "I had to marry her for the sake of honor" was as much a rationalization for marrying the woman he wanted as it was the actual truth. Admittedly, that's not something I think GRRM himself implied in the text, though. I think that may just be Roose mocking the whole thing, though not openly enough to cause an issue.
  7. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    Just want to clarify that "shotgun wedding" doesn't mean a wedding that happened fast. It's a wedding that happened because the bride got pregnant (perhaps you can stretch it to had sex). The "shotgun" comes from the image of the father of the bride forcing a marriage at the point of a shotgun to prevent the embarassment/abandonment of his daughter. Robb and Talisa weren't a shotgun wedding, and neither were Robb and Jeyne, although that one was a lot closer to the actual definition.
  8. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    Well, the problem is that if they really wanted to make it a truly fleshed-out romance, with a truly-fleshed out Talisa, that would have taken a lot more screen-time than they were understandably willing to commit to what was essentially a plot device. They needed to come up with something that wouldn't take a ton of screentime, but that might be convincing. So, they decided to give her the kind of noble, "good-guy" story that would also reflect well on Robb for loving her for that reason. I actually thought that worked as well as anything else they could have done given the time constraints.
  9. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    And my point is her pretty face wasn't the reason he fell for her. He fell for her, very clearly, right when she told him about her past. Part of the problem here is that Robb is so much older than in the books. It's easier to imagine a 15-16 guy falling hard for a girl based on what we were given than it is a guy who appears to be more than 10 years older. And that really applies both to book Robb and show Robb. No matter how they did it, it wasn't going to make much sense. Although personally, if they were going to adapt it, a smarter change may have been him not just having sex with Jeyne, but her actually becoming pregnant as being the reason Robb felt compelled to marry her. Not just because of her honor, but because he's seen what it means to be born a bastard.
  10. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    It's not because she's just "not horrible". How many other noble-born characters do we see who deliberately give up their wealth and privilege to serve the less fortunate, without any expectation of fame or glory, and without being on the run from some worse fate? Like her or not (and I personally found her annoying and not all that attractive), her story is very unusual, and as I said, hits Robb right in his idealistic sweet-spot.
  11. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    No, you don't have to love her -- only Robb had to. In their first meeting, she spouted off against slavery, and about leaving a life of luxury to do good. She was an idealist in the same way that Robb was, and it was very clear to me that was the core of her appeal to him. To him, she seemed to have a "Stark-like" code, which got him right in his weak spot.
  12. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    If you perceived Michelle as having "absolutely dominated" that scene, then isn't it quite likely that's exactly what the writers and director intended? Unless you're going to argue that they didn't know what they'd filmed. If the writers had made their "best attempts to focus solely on the poor doomed couple", as you claim, then Michelle couldn't have dominated that last scene because she wouldn't have had the lines. In fact, from the moment the first bolt was fired, the writers gave Talisa no lines at all. Had they truly wanted Michelle to be in the background, they'd have had her shot first, given her no lines, and then had the rest of the scene taken up by Talisa and Robb saying their last words to each other. But that's not how it was written. The point of stabbing Talisa in the womb wasn't just the shock of the physical attack -- it was to kill Robb's heir. The message was "we are wiping out your family". And while it is true that the focus was on Robb and Talisa at that particular moment in the scene, the entire rest of the scene was written around Catelyn, and they deliberately made her the enduring, last image of the entire episode. The idea that Fairley somehow shone in spite of how the scene was written ignores the reality that she was given all the lines, and the most screen-time. I'd say it was certainly Cat's POV when she was standing at the window in Riverrun talking to her uncle about waiting for Hoster Tully to come home, and then breaking down because Bran and Rickon were gone. And then again when she was knitting and talking about Jon. Talisa was a plot device, an appendage to Robb's character. She didn't have a single scene, in any episode, that didn't involve Robb, except the one with Catelyn knitting. Catelyn, on the other hand, had tons of scenes with all sorts of different characters.
  13. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    His last word in the show was "mother", and he died standing and looking at her. His last words in the book was about his wolf, so I really don't get the claim that show Robb didn't care enough about his mother.
  14. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    They may well have filmed unCat's resurrection before filming the RW, so I don't put much stock in Michelle leaving right after the shooting of that scene. As for Maisie, UnCat has comparatively few scenes, which likely can be filled on a quick "guest" basis. So, most of the other castmembers likely won't see her, especially since Maisie probably isn't even going to be filming in the same country. As for when UnCat would be revealed, she actually get resurrected only a couple of days after the RW, so it would make sense to show her right away. My guess is that her body is found by the Blackfish, who runs into the BwB while trying to bring it back to Riverrun.
  15. Former Lord of Winterfell

    [Book Spoilers] EP309 Discussion

    One can, one should, and one did. Catelyn rocked.
×