Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About NestorMakhnosLovechild

  • Rank
    You Should Watch What You Say To People

Profile Information

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

3,944 profile views
  1. NestorMakhnosLovechild

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    Pretty sure that The Beast had a very unconvincing extra pinky finger attached to his hands.
  2. NestorMakhnosLovechild

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    I have not read the books, but my understanding from reading the Wiki is that the loops works basically the same way. SOMEONE is learning something from the loops - it's just not the main characters. Specifically, Jane Chatwin is fiddling with the group to see whether any of the changes put them in a better position to stop The Beast. As I understand it, both the books and the show have picked up this theme of deconstructing the "chosen one" narrative, which is part of why Quentin comes to realize this episode that he is actually not the person in a best position to kill The Beast. The revelation that Quentin and his friends have much less agency than we thought, and are in fact pawns in a larger game, actually works on the same level of subversion.
  3. NestorMakhnosLovechild

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    From my recollection, Tom Cruise in Edge of Tomorrow operates exactly like Bill Murray's character in Groundhog Day - which is to say, they each remember everything that happened in their prior days, but everyone else "reset" with no knowledge. The only way that Emily Blunt's character learned anything about what happened is because Tom Cruise's character told her. I don't think there's any indication that Julia or Quentin or any of the Brakebills kids have any recollection or retained anything they learned from the prior loops. Basically, they're pawns in a giant puzzle the only thing that's really changing is Jane Chatwin rearranging them at the beginning to try to prod them in different directions.
  4. NestorMakhnosLovechild

    The Magicians - SyFy [SHOW SPOILERS ONLY]

    FB, You must be an... interesting person to watch television shows with. Quentin, Julia, Penny Alice, Margot and Eliot don't remember their 39 previous deaths. They know OF the time loop because Quentin informed them, after he truth serumed it out of the Dean, but they don't have any personal memory of it. The comments made by the Brakebills students about it being unpleasant to die were the result of them experiencing their own deaths via the "probability magic" they cast - not because they were remembering their prior time loops. Based on what we've seen in the show, only beings of great magical power can actually remember the past time loops - The Beast seems to remember the prior loops, as does Ember. The Dean seems to have some remembrance of the prior loops as well, judging by his reference to the number of times that Quentin has slipped him truth serum (you'd think he would be a little more cautious at this point). In the prior timelines, Julia got into Brakebills. There's no reason to believe that she joined the hedges in summoning Reynard in the prior timelines, because her not getting into Brakebills was the whole reason she went down the hedge path and tried to summon a goddess. To the best of the information we have, she never had a mind block put into place on her, because she never summoned Reynard in the prior timelines because she had always gotten into Brakebills. There is no indication that any of the Brakebills students or Julia have any retained memories of the prior time loops. In fact, there's plenty of evidence otherwise - Quentin and Julia end up having to re-learn magic all over again each time, and they start out as total beginners. I admit - nobody knows exactly why Ember said that usually Quentin had killed Julia by this point. He might mean that he personally killed her. He might mean that he had gotten Julia killed. I admit that it's a mystery. But other than that one concession, I think you are misreading the show pretty significantly.
  5. If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then I am well and truly flattered.