Jump to content

SerArthurHeath

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,407

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by SerArthurHeath

  1. SerArthurHeath
    Mel has reason to lie to Jon though, and I think she's about as trustworthy as Baelish...
  2. SerArthurHeath
    Maybe he knows Bloodraven left but doesn't want to reveal that he broke his vows to protect him so doesn't talk about him.
  3. SerArthurHeath
    I technically did this ages ago but I feel far more attached and involved in teh forum recently- I'm a recently finished med student/ recently qualified doctor from the UK. I love rugby, musicals and performing music in addition to books. I read ASOIAF because someone on a WoT site said they were basically necessary to read ages ago. I didn't get into the books until a fair way through Clash, now I love them of course. I also follow the show. I apologise for any flippancy or sarcasm, or pedantry and strong opinions, on my part
  4. SerArthurHeath
    Both pleasant and appropriate
  5. SerArthurHeath
    Thorne IS a formidable fighter in the books and show, he's a seasoned NW man, chosen to train the troops (though he may fail at that) and was a seasoned knight before that. There's no evidence that Slynt is a fighter at all
  6. SerArthurHeath
    Nah, late 2015 and I didn't see any such implication in what GRRM's editor said at all.
  7. SerArthurHeath
    Bit harsh but I agree that they are in no way boring for me. Action smacktion, pacing shmacing
  8. SerArthurHeath
    I dunno, he came across pretty well in Jon's chapters too, and Asha's
  9. SerArthurHeath
    45 ish on camera, at least another half a dozen unless Ygritte's an awful shot
  10. SerArthurHeath
    9. Not much wrong with it at all
  11. SerArthurHeath
    Not really, no
  12. SerArthurHeath
    It's Styr
  13. SerArthurHeath
    Nah he's not, just a Thenn Warg. Varamyr is being casted for season 5
  14. SerArthurHeath
    It's not quite the same with an episode that will be followed 1 week later, and a movie followed a year later...
  15. SerArthurHeath
    Mance specifically didn't send anything like his full strength in attack. He's trying to get an idea of the Watch's strength, he does it in the books too...
  16. SerArthurHeath
    I liked all the Jon changes especially re Mance at the end. And he's not THAT great with a sword in the books, and Styr has an axe with a sword breaker in it, it's pretty much designed to disarm swordsmen. However, thanks to what they did to Jaime's swordmanship and look like they will keep on with, I feel you pain Edit/ sorry was meant to be a reply to the person you are quoting!
  17. SerArthurHeath
    Doesn't the new Awoiaf reading imply at least that Aemon and BR went to the wall by choice, possibly to ensure they couldn't be used against Egg?
  18. SerArthurHeath
    Do they have space to do everything next episode?!?!
  19. SerArthurHeath
    [quote name="YorEmixam" post="5866699" timestamp=" That speach will get his purpose with Jaime - wont he take riverun without a drop of blood and being all " okay war as made enough victim" ?
  20. SerArthurHeath
    OMG, Bloodraven is Warging Sansa
  21. SerArthurHeath
    Because it's a symptom of that? The hint's in the word hysterical, it implies brokenness in itself
  22. SerArthurHeath
    So you think lying and manipulating several parties (including the king of lying) in that way to protect herself and being that convincing wasn't badass? Truly?
  23. SerArthurHeath
    I think it's best she does. She's not in many scenes anyway, and it will have less impact and might confuse people if it's not clearly Michelle. Certain more than Asha-Osha would have. This isn't the Mountain or Daario, people we have no emotional attachment to (well, except hate now for the Mountain). This is a woman whose death really upset a lot of viewers
  24. SerArthurHeath
    That would make 10...
  25. SerArthurHeath
    Some of it makes good viewing but I imagine they will invent threats
×
×
  • Create New...