GOTgirl

Had to give it a 9, I thought it was great but not as good as Blackwater! Although many people have valid gripes with the HOTU scenes (I myself would have liked to see more but understand that's not going to happen) ...I liked it and found it rather emotional. Loved seeing Dany in the Throne room! And lets face it...they've already messed her storyline up a great deal this season...I was actually expecting less from this part of the story. Was hoping to see Rhaegar though! The Jon scene I wish they had done differently. As they've done it I think many non-book readers are left wondering what the heck Jon is doing? If they had taken just a few moments and lines of dialouge more they truly could have explained it and given Qhuorin Halfhand a more honorable death which truly showed the sacrifice made for the Nights Watch...the scene would have ended up better with a more emotional impact. And where the heck is Ghost? Yes overall a 9 because unlike other episodes this season this one left me wanting more. I truly liked it a lot! And I must say the White Walkers looked bad ass this time!

Phenomenal episode!!! If GRRM was already finished writing the Book Series I would be campaigning for him to be writing each and every episode! Now that is how a real writer does it!

I agree...leaving quite a bit out about how much planning Tryrion really did do.

Where's the Weasel soup?! Was looking forward to that scene...disappointed not to see it. Liked the Asha (Yara) & Theon scene.