Morky_Pep

I really don't think the writers put that much thought into the scene. Off vacationing ? In my last post I mentioned how they JUST got caught walking around the premises and attacked for doing NOTHING sneaky. Those were GUARDS. But they have only two guards at the building where ALL THEIR LEADERS are at. It boggles my mind how many hoops people will jump through to explain this stuff. It's fine if you don't care about these convenient plots. But how can you honestly sit there and say that this was a coherent and amazingly executed scene.

Comes at me for my spelling. Woooooooo.... Ya I can see stealth maybe being possible. It stretches credulity though. I mean they literally just got caught a few scenes before just wandering doing nothing sneaky. But now they can get up right to the Dothraki's important temple and bar the door with ALL the khals inside. I guess your one of the people that thought Ramsey's 20 good men made perfect sense. :/ How did they apply the oil in the building ? None of this was shown? I guess Dario and Jorah broke into the temple before the audience and applied it ? Dang these guys are good.

Oh this is new. Where did this accelerant come from ? And um idk, because there is 100k dothraki in the vicinity and the only weapon they have is a small knife. Nobody is watching? The khals bloodriders aren't there protecting their khal ? I think they showed like one body ? They had one guard outside lol. Comon man, your going to have to do better than that to hand-wave this away.

Your seriously going to compare this scene to that season 1 scene ? Night and Day quality difference in tone, believability, and effectiveness. Her being immune to fire is not why I think the scene is dumb. It is dumb because the idea that she can take out all the khals by knocking over a brazier is stupid. To think that the place would erupt into flames with 10 seconds before the khals at the very least snapped her neck before they burned to death is stupid. The idea that Jorah and Dario can walk up to this temple and bar the doors in a camp of 100k Dothraki is stupid. Literally turn to your friend and tell them Dany's plan out loud as if she was telling Dario and Jorah. If it doesn't sound stupid to your ears, than I really can't help you. Now you don't have to care that it is stupid, that is fine. But lets call it what it is. The whole scene wreaks of plot contrivance and weak writing.

Again, I am all for character development and make Dany a more strong ruler and character. That shouldn't be at the expense of a interesting and logical plot though. Like I said in a previous post, they would have already had that change if they had kept the Daznak Pit scene from the book. Instead, Dany looked worthless in the scene. If instead she had whipped Drogon into submission like in the book. Using him to cow the Khals would then be a part of her empowerment and not a cop out of her being saved by Drogon.

The point is that this amazing plan could be so easily thwarted. It was a silly PLAN. I wish they had put the scene in where she tells this plan to Jorah and Dario, I really would'a liked to have seen their reactions to it. "Hey, so u guys watch outside and I'm gunna go in there and push over some brazier to burn the place down" lolll

quality over quantity my friend. in my opinion atleast.

I don't know but I have faith that Martin will come up with something better than knockin over some braziers. Also, last we saw Dany in hte books she had Drogon right beside her when the khalasar rolls up. Something tells me shes going to be treated much differently by the Dothraki in the book than the show. But I guess we will have to wait and see.

Alright man the point is that is still not a great plan. It just wreaked of lazy writing. I used to think this show was great, and tonight I thought it was returning to form but that scene wreaked of scenes like Dorne, and Shireen last season. It clear to me that while the show can still be good. It is certainly not great IMO.

Past posters in the thread were saying this was a good scene because it would have been lame if she need to be saved like a "damsel in distress" by Drogon. I was simply using their term.

Dude, what if they moved em ? What if she was bound (which would probably make sense). It's silly no matter how you slice it. Your betting your entire life on the idea that you can push over some fire-pots(or whatever the hell they are). I guess she don't got much choice, but don't sit here and make it seem like Dany is some mastermind over this lol.

I'm all for giving Dany agency, and not having her constantly be saved by her dragon. But the problem with this scene is that it was completely idiotic. Lets look past all these "repetitive" comments and realize this was basically the exact same scene from Season 1. How did this plan make any sense at all? What if the lanterns were up on the sides of the shelter and not in the middle ? What if she was tied up and not let freely walk around? How does this plan make ANY sense. She could have died so easily. I struggle to see how anyone can watch this and think Dany looked good from that scene. She looked like an idiot lol. And also, having Drogon swoop in to save her wouldn't be repetitive if you know, they actually used the Pit scene from the book. They made THAT scene all about deus ex drogon and not about Dany's strength and power. So they had to make THIS scene idiotic. I don't give the writers a pass. If the scene doesn't work than come up with something better. How can anyone think this was a believable scene ? The rest of the episode was mediocre to great. I loved the Jon and Sansa scenes. It gave me hope for the show, until the end.

Hey guys, I've never resurrected somebody before, but I'm sure if I chant some random shit and give him a haircut and a shower he will definitely come back to life. Ill burn the hair because I really wouldn't want to make a mess of this lovely chamber. What a thrilling resurrection :/ Hey guys, I've served gratefully and loyally my entire life to a man and I think something really bad might have happened to him but I'm not going to ask any questions. Especially not to the person who I distrust and was with him last. Also there was his daughter who taught me how to read and who I care especially for, but shes not important. I'm more concerned about this guy I met for 2 seconds who died, and I'm going to try to convince the woman who wanted to burn the little girl I loved to save him. I am totally in character. :/ Hey guys, I've never seen a dragon before and I know their super dangerous but I'm going to go down to the cell where they are chained, because they are known to be extremely violent, and say hello. I know they wont hurt me because I read in a book that detailed creatures from over a hundred years ago that they finished their grade 10, and will know I mean to help them. Just in case, I will bring my eunuch friend, who has never seen a dragon either, for protection and definitely not the woman who we just established has some trust with the dragons. OUU I told them a happy story and was very gentle like; they definitely liked me. And when i unchained them they decided to go sleep in the cave instead of leaving. I guess I used my saintlyness to make them obedient. Tomorrow I will go back down and riding lessons will commence. I wonder what cock joke I'll use tomorrow. :/ Hey guys, you might not know me but I'm actually a big zombie. So my job is usually to guard my queen Cersei. Shes so awesome. On my time off, I wander around the streets trying to find people who are making fun of her, and then I smash their head into walls. FUN :/ Hey guys, I am actually more than one person. I am the hive mind of the Night's Watch. I was like tote's angry when I found out about the lord commanders murder. I definitely know nothing about the white walkers or the wights who get summoned when people die north of the wall. What army is coming to kill us all ? All I know is those damn wildlings are so annoyingly hairy. So when Thorne said he did it and i was like "tote's cool" I'm totally down to kill all the other brothers who decided to take the lord commanders body out of the freezing cold. But then the wildling's came and i was like "totes cool" Thorne is bad. So now I'm totally gonna guard Jon's body too !!! This is fun !!! :/