NickSnow

I gave it a 7/10. I don't know why I didn't like it as much as a lot of you guys did. I thought it was a bit slow, and it didn't feel as coherant as the previous episode. There were some good moments thought: Brienne and Jaime; Arya and the Brotherhood; Margaery, Sansa, and Olenna; and yes...I actually liked the Reeds. But there was one moment that i hated. CATELYN'S SCENE. Its not the actresses fault (I love the actress), but the writers decided to completely ruin her character. AACCK. God. I feel like Im not going ot care during the red wedding, because they are making Robb and Catelyn totally despicable and stupid. They nedd to develop both of them WAY MORE

Rating: 8 out of 10 A very solid first episode I think. There didn't think that there was anything particularly cringe-worthy. GOOD: -Davos. Very good stuff. His conversation with Sallador Saan is very good as well as his interactions with Stannis and Melisandre -Daenerys. Dany had a VERY BAD season last year, but everything seems to be improving. The Unsullied are great as well as Kranzys and Missandei. AND A VERY GOOD ENDING with Barristan!! -King's Landing. Everything in King's Landing was very good as well. I particularly liked the scenes with Margaery, Lancel, Joffrey, and Cersei. The dynamic between the Lannisters and the Tyrells is very well done. Also, Tyrion's conversation with Tywin was very good indeed. BAD: -Jon Snow and Mance Rayder. Meh. I wasn't too impressed with the Wildlings. Mance Rayder did not have the necessary charisma to make me convinced that he had become the leader of all these Wildlings. And Tormund Giantsbane was underwhelming as well. -Catelyn and Robb. There wasn't a lot of Robb and Cat in this episode, and whatever is there is fairly underwhelming as well. They arrive in Harrenhal (?) and meet Qyburn (?). Huh? UGLY: -Again, I didn't flip any tables in this epsidode. I thought it was very good.

Praise the gods for Hmadkour!!! We now know the answer to one loose end. YAY, only 70401 answers left to go. WOOHOO! (WOW, I hope your'e able to answer some of these questions, not create more of them)

ugghgh... This was most certainly my worst favourite episode of this season. So many dumb changes that made absolutely no sense at all. 1. Ros is going to be a spy for Varys. WHAT!? 2. Robb is married under oath of the Seven. WHAT!? 3. Dagmar Clefreek. Who even burned Winterfell? Him or the horn blowers? WHAT!? 4. No prophecies in the HotU. WHAT!? 5. Doreah sleeping with Xaro. WHAT!? eeek. So many problems... I really only liked three scenes in this episode. 1. Stannis and Melisandre. Really creepy and awesome. 2. Theon and Maester Luwyin. Awesome acting. 3. Attack on the Fist of the First Men. 4/10 rating from me. Super dissapointed

WOW!!! That was absolutely fantastic. I had no issues with this episode at all. It was perfect. I think that GRRM just redeemed this season for me.

WOW!!! That was absolutely fantastic. I had no issues with this episode at all. It was perfect. I think that GRRM just redeemed this season for me.

Alright, I've gotten used to the fact that this is an ADAPTATION of the books, and changes have to be made. As a reader of the books, I am trying to not be nitpicky when it comes to the changes. When looking at the show from that kind of point of view, I definitely thought that this episode was the best episode of the season so far. It was just one awesome scene after the other. 10/10