TyrionFan82

I gave it a 10. I know it's a controversial rating but I really enjoyed it. I was expecting a bloodbath, my dad asked me what I expected to happen and I said Tyrion's going to die first and I'm so glad I was wrong. I'm glad Sansa wasn't chosen, she would've been Cersei 2.0 probably given that much power at least they made a reasonable compromise and gave her the North, which was appropriate. I liked seeing Arya go off on her own it reminded me of the adventures that were discussed on F&B about Corlys Velaryon. I'm glad Bran got it. I like Jon but that would've been....idk. I wouldn't have minded it but Bran has the most ability to do it well. OMG! I was so happy to see Jon and Ghost reunited. esp. after that last scene w/them. Hopefully he finds a nice wildling woman. Plus he would've hated being king and this was his dream...freedom. I felt for Drogon. That was so sad more for him than Dany honestly and who knew he was one of the most rational characters on the show. He realized this throne has caused nothing but problems. And as a HUGE Tyrion fan I'm glad to see him survive & really be chosen because he has humbled himself.

Best episode of the season, 10/10 for me. I'm not sure where to start. I loved the action, that goes w/o saying, but I loved some of the emotion we got too, for instance with Tyrion & Jaime. I liked how Sandor told Arya to go unless she wanted to be like him, it was touching. I LOVED seeing the Iron Fleet burned. I was hoping Euron would get killed there but the fight w/Jaime was good enough. I have to say I had a little WTH moment when she started going nuts on the city but within a second thought, well that makes sense. I do worry for Tyrion due to his freeing Jaime. I think next week will be interesting. What'll Jon say? What'll happen with Cersei? Where's Arya going? Visually it was awesome & I liked seeing the fear of God put into Cersei,

Oh yea if he goes back and just falls under Cersei's thrall AGAIN it'll be like well what a waste. I'm sooooo anticipating to have Euron taken by surprise and defeated. He's awful.

I actually really liked it. 9/10. The beginning gave the characters room to breathe before the next big battle. Sure from the previous trailer it gave the impression of more but I liked what I saw. I liked the strategizing sessions. I'm worried about Dany now however. I have mixed feelings on Jon as king as well. I liked Brienne and Jaime. It was sad seeing him leave but....well it's Jaime's twisted idea of loyalty though. I want to see Sandor and Arya to kill Gregor & Cersei respectively. O think that was set up well. I am so wanting to see Euron killed! You just know Yara's gonna bring the cavalry in take him out. At this point I'm not shocked by deaths but still was saddened by Missandei's death. BTW now you know who not to tell a secret to.

Yea, 9/10 for me. I liked all you liked and LOVED the scene where Brienne was knighted. It was the culmination in their relationship. Just great episode!

8/10 I give this for plot mostly. I was on the edge of my seat. The fight scenes got me though. Some you couldn't tell who was fighting, who was dying, too dark. As far as plot, as I said, I loved the suspense. I wasn't upset with Bran but kept thinking we'd get some answers. Maybe we will later? I really liked Mel's scenes and thought they added a lot. Okay, now I'm sorry I liked Arya killing the NK. When Dany attacked him and he was still there I thought OMG what's gonna kill him so thought the end was still cool. I'm anxiously awaiting next week.

8/10 for me. I think it's a good start to the season. We see all of the players & conflicts set up. There's not much to go on now but I'm sure it'll get better each week. I did like Sansa & Tyrion's scenes as well.

I'm not really new here, but new to this thread. I'm a fan of comic books, mostly Marvel & DC, TV, and movies. I do like cable channels more honestly like HBO, Showtime, etc. More of the good shows are there now. I'm also a fan of Netflix. I read A LOT. I haven't reread ASOIAF but do read other related material when available. I read nonfiction bios and history. SW novels as well. That's about it for now.

Great episode! So here are some of my thoughts: - I really liked seeing Sandor get in Gregor's face. I keep wanting to call him Robert Strong. - The Theon scene was awesome. I guess being a eunuch is helpful after all. - LF getting called out & killed was awesome. I knew they were playing him. It's nice to see Bran be used more too. - Sam! I like how when everyone meets Bran they're all "...Yeah okay." We all knew that was coming or suspected it that R+L=J. I was earlier today thinking if you were a casual viewer or only a show fan how important that'd be for you. I liked it. - Finally Jaime got some guts. He was starting to resemble an Unsullied. - That end!!!!!!! I don't want to wait a year! HBO you are cruel. 10/10

I agree, I found it very good for other reasons. The scenes beyond the Wall were awesome and honestly I didn't know what'd happen. I didn't know it was a longer episode so I thought well this might be it for a lot of them. When Dany came I was psyched. I know it was reminiscent of the last time but it was cool nonetheless. I was heartbroken when Viserion got taken down as well ! I really liked the scenes with Dany and Jon and esp. at the end. I want to see how that plays out. I also liked the scenes at Winterfell. I think LF may go next episode. I don't have a clear opinion on what's happening with them but I have to watch that scene at the end again. I don't think he has as much sway as he think he does but those scenes were still suspenseful. 10/10

I think this was a good episode, not as much action as last week, but a lot happened. From the get go we see house Tarly evaporated...literally & Sam will need to step up. I'm sure Jon will vouch for him. We saw Gendry again, how awesome was that? I also loved the scene w/Drogon and Jon. I think our show canon is showing us R+L=J and I'm cool with that. The Tyrion/Jamie scene didn't progress the story much IMO but at the same time it didn't detract enough to affect my rating. I liked the scenes at Winterfell and I can't help but wonder what is LF's plan. Arya's pretty smart too so there might be a battle of wits that'll happen. Can someone tell me what the not said too, I missed that? 9/10

Easily a 10, BEST EPISODE YET! Oh man, where to start? Arya coming back to Winterfell and her reunion w/Bran & Sansa was heartwarming. On top of that her showing how much of a badass she's become while LF and Sansa watched...man. She can hold her own against Brienne! The scenes on Dragonstone w/Dany and Jon were awesome...can't wait for more. THAT BATTLE!!!!! Ah man, how cool was that??? I knew when the pounding started I thought oh no they don't know what they're in for! And then when the dragons came and started lighting whole lines of men up. As a Dany fan it was an awesome night. I also liked Tyrion's saying of Jamie you idiot.

I'm going to be honest, at first I didn't think much of it. Jon and Dany seemed stilted. I did like when Missandei said Dany's whole title and Davos said this in Jon Snow, he's King of the North. It got better though. Afterwards ...WOW a lot happened!! The Unsullied, Cersei, Tycho. Sam, Sansa & Bran.....THE END! Pieces are moving, ones I don't like but still. So I say 9.

Thanks.

I put 7, but lean towards 7.5. I liked seeing the Sand Snakes (RIP, I love them in the books and were given...not as good a portrayal in the show. I also LOVED seeing Lady Olena and Tyrion's plan would've been great. Obviously Cersei did listen to Euron, as I said previously I thought he was full of it The Wall and Jon's reaction w/Sansa & Littlefinger were cool. Again seeing Arya was cool but am disappointed that wolf wasn't Nymeria. I'm still rooting for Dany though. #TeamDany. AGGH, who else's teth were gritting during the seen at the Citadel?

Bump I can't figure this out either. I'm connected through FB so that may be part of it but even at that there should be a way. Also, what's the exact pixel amount we need to upload? When I have tried to upload it comes in too big and as far as that goes when you go to profile that option is provided there. This still is confusing.

I agree. I can see where some say Theon wasn't in it and I sympathize there, but we got ALMOST everyone and every place of import covered. It was a very strategic episode, setting up things to come. I think in retrospect as this season progresses we'll see how important this ep is.

I gave this a solid 8. Like others have said I want to wait for the 10s later. So here are my reasons: * The opening scene was awesome, we all knew w/the Freys there oh man it's going down! Seeing Arya first was awesome! *The scenes at The Wall were good in that we see foreshadowing & what might happen there w/Jon, Sansa, etc. *Cersei & Jamie was nothing special, more set up, which is obvious and I like their thinking both might know what to do. I also liked the tension there w/their kids. *Being an apprentice master looks gross, I mean give Sam some respect lol! He's got a partner and kid. His find was great and we see things early on converging on Dragonstone. *Seeing Sandor and Beric was cool but yet to see where it's going. *It was interesting seeing Arya w/the other Freys & her reactions. *DANNNNNYYYY! Awesome scene, 'nuff said,

I gave it a 10. I loved the episode. Funny thing is, and I want to ask if anyone else felt this way, as a reader knowing what was coming I still was shocked and taken back to when I read it. Did anyone else feel that way? I read as if it was a movie/show in my head so I could picture all the gory details, but it was still something else and well done.

This episode was AWESOME! I loved the wildfire scene....they really captured that. The fight scenes were amazing. I loved when Sandor was fighting and saw the flames, and you could just see the fear in his eyes. Him telling Joffrey to go fuck himself was an added bonus. I loved the end when Tyrion got cut even though he was on a ship in the book it was done well. 10/10

This was the best so far, I gave it a 10! I liked how a lot happened, but at the same time it gave us book fans some surprises likes the Dothraki's who got murdered & dragon's kidnapped. I'm really enjoying that aspect of it as well. I loved Jaqen doing his thing and Sandor kicking some serious ass. That event and scenes were ones I was really waiting to see. Also I liked seeing Theon and Bran, poor Rodrik! And last but not least Ygrette was so fun to watch and very close to how I pictured her.

Awesome episode! Renly's death was done magnificently & Brienne showed how much of a badass she is. That was really cool. I loved the scenes in Qarth & seeing Drogon. Even though the chapters in ACOK were kinda boirng, the show's doing a good job of showing the people and geography of Qarth. I liked Bronn's lines to the pyromancer too, very Bronn-like even though they weren't in the book and Arya's scenes were awesome too, but was disappointed Jaqen killed the Tickler and not someone else, who'll she kill next season then? Overall I loved it though.

I gave it a 9. I did like Harrenhal's look, much how I expected it, but I was disappointed Tywin and not Roose was there. I mean I understand some story alterations, but others seem unnecessary. I liked seeing Littlefinger though, he's such a compelling character I'll make excuses for him lol. Let's see....what else....the scene w/Mel at the end was crazy. I wasn't sure how that'd be done, but thought it was done well, every part.

I think I recall that now, since it's only briefly alluded to it's easy to forget those things in the rush of all the other styff happening surrounding Stannis. Thanks.

Can someone point out how in ACOK the extent of Mel & Stannis's relationship is implied besides the fact that she carries his banners and other stuff like killing Renly and....the othee guy at Storms' End (name escapes me)? I found him to be a very stern figure and not very sexual at all. In the book he does make a comment to Renly regarding his homosexuality, so I see that, but if someone can help me out on my question I'd appreciate it.