Jump to content


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About LugaJetboyGirl-irra

  • Rank
    Council Member
  • Birthday 06/24/1978

Profile Information

  • Gender

Recent Profile Visitors

10,094 profile views
  1. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Hugo Nominations and Awards - Onwards to 2020

    Oh, and George Martin's Wild Cards is eligible for Best Series due to Low Chicago, etc.
  2. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    YA Hugo Nominations, 2019 Dublin

    Kelly York & Rowan Altwood's A Light Amongst Shadow's was very spooky. More eligible titles have been collected here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pWyD-eQP_O6grT6aEUFJxm_qLcn7MCnTKQdFA4ajCu0/edit#gid=1905433534
  3. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Hugo Nominations and Awards - Onwards to 2020

    For those who still have some spots on their nomination ballot, here's an open spreadsheet where people put their recs: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pWyD-eQP_O6grT6aEUFJxm_qLcn7MCnTKQdFA4ajCu0/edit#gid=0
  4. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Guess who's coming to (thanksgiving) dinner? NYC edition

    Oh man, I would love to see you guys. Sadly I will not be in PA over Thanksgiving.
  5. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Hugo Nominations and Awards - Onwards to 2020

    I just finished Spinning Silver. I thought it was much better than Uprooted. I really enjoyed it (though I wouldn't call it groundbreaking). I wouldn't really characterize it as YA and think it is better nominated for the Hugo, not to mention the publisher lists it as adult lit (arbitrary, I know). I do agree that both it and Binti do blur the line, though, Binti especially, since it was much more a 'coming of age' story than Silver. Edit: I also suggest KD Edwards' The Last Sun (Novel and for the Campbell), for a solid urban fantasy.
  6. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Hugo Nominations and Awards - Onwards to 2020

    Ehn. I thought it was very entertaining but not Hugo worthy. It's a standard urban fantasy (inspired by one particular cultural tradition that has been generally overlooked), and it had some serious plot and characterization problems. It's got a five star average on Amazon which I just really don't think is warranted given its 'first novel' weaknesses.
  7. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Katrina at 13: A Backwards Timeline

    I was in the Panhandle of Florida, just about to move out of state to start a PhD program. Classes hadn't started yet, so I spent the week at my friend's house watching the news projected on a wall in huge format, and freaking out. I've got family there, who left their cat behind because everyone said it would only take a couple of days to get back. The cat was rescued and shipped out of town by the ASPCA. Fast forward two weeks and it turns out the cat had been shipped to my new state. Got the cat, housed it for a while, then put it on a plane to my family members, where it is still loved and happy today. But from my family I've heard lots of terrible things about the what corporate interests and unrestrained capitalism have done to the city. Makes you think that part of disaster planning should include an urban planning for rebuilding and restoring.
  8. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Hugo Nominations and Awards - Onwards to 2020

    I recommend for nomination Adam Whitehead (Werthead) and the Wertzone for Best Fan Writer.
  9. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    YA Hugo Nominations, 2019 Dublin

    Here is the list of works that (as of now) will be considered for the Hal Clement YA award for science fiction: https://sfnotables.org/about-the-lists/2018-list/
  10. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    YA Hugo Nominations, 2019 Dublin

    Goodreads will also have the best of 2018 SF at the end of the year. Their normal YA list at the moment is gigantic, though. Here's some other lists: B & N Teen Sci-fi: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/blog/teen/13-anticipated-science-fiction-novels-2018/ B & N Teen Fantasy: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/blog/teen/anticipated-ya-fantasy-novels-2018/ Another longer B & N Teen Fantasy list: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/blog/teen/50-of-our-most-anticipated-ya-fantasy-novels-of-2018-july-to-december/ A blogger's anticipated YA sci-fi list: https://vickywhoreads.wordpress.com/2018/01/08/most-anticipated-ya-sci-fi-novels-of-2018/
  11. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    The Lodestar Award

    Okay, I've read back through this thread and now that the vote is over, I feel okay about posting. Just one quick request, for those who helped with the award and also post on the Board, please avoid specifically referring to their roles in order to avoid publicly compromising their Board handles About the naming of the award. 1) It should have been named the Hugo Award for Best Young Adult Novel. There are many reasons that such did not happen. In my mind, the most significant reasons were: (a) many people at the Business Meeting honestly did not think people at Worldcon cared about YA, (b) the submission of the YA Hugo proposal at San Antonio was a hack job and (rightly, I think now) pissed off so many people that it created enormous bad blood and hostility to any award, and (c) there were some bureaucratic rules-y things that some people could not let go (to make it a Hugo). The committee in their first active year was easily able to surmount (a) with some research and education at the Business Meeting. Overcoming (b) would have been impossible without bowing to (c). I think (c) on its own could have been solved eventually, but because of (b), there was a mountainous road block from the beginning. 2) About naming the thing after a person. @Ran, we've talked about some of this before, but I'll say my piece here. The committee put out an open survey to collect award names with no qualifications, just to see what they'd get. They didn't say, "here's some of the issues that we have noticed in our discussions that you may want to think about." So, people got psyched and suggested all kinds of stuff without thinking about the larger issues (or even doing basic Google searches), but many who'd suggested person names on the survey were later convinced by the committee's report that a person name wasn't a good idea. The only way to have percentage numbers to prove that would be do ANOTHER survey of people who had read the full report, and that wasn't possible. I personally witnessed these conversations, for example: "Yeah, I said on the survey I wanted it to be named Heinlein! Oh, you mean people under 50 don't think he's the best possibility? Oooh, yeah, I guess a lot of women really don't think he's the best option for good reason. Shoot, wish I could rescind my suggestion." "I suggested Octavia Butler on the survey! Oh crap, you're right, she does have a book where an 11-year old has sex repeatedly with a 24-year old and many other adults. Yikes, not a good name for a teen book award. Good thing you caught that." I think the committee decided not to include all that stuff in their reports because they didn't want it to turn into a big free-for-all about why each author sucked as an option for reason X, Y, and Z; that would publicly draw an already-not-secure award into an ugly public discussion and would go a long way to NOT honoring the authors. So the reports phrased the objections very vaguely without naming names ("inappropriate teen-adult sexual relationships"). Having another survey of just authors, as Ran suggested, would still require those specific objections to be aired in order to achieve a balanced response ("Author A, whose books are beloved for x,y, and z reasons, and who fat-shames teen girls continuously"). As for the L'Engle discussion at the Business Meeting, it was pretty brief and maybe more discussion would have been better, but I'm not sure it would have changed much. I saw someone say to a committee person in the hall afterwards: "When the debate started I definitely wanted it to be L'Engle, no question, but once I heard the speaker explain that stuff about L'Engle's relationship to homosexuality, I changed my mind. Thank goodness they brought that up because we dodged a bullet there." And just a reminder, the recent decision to change the World Fantasy Award's trophy from a a bust of white supremacist HP Lovecraft caused a firestorm of painful arguments and accusations. Just a few months ago, Laura Ingalls Wilder's name was removed from a major children's book award (for its racist and prejudiced representation of minorities and indigenous exploitation); it was reported on by the New York Times, NPR, and others. So, (I personally think that for the good of the award) it's better to avoid that stuff from the get-go.
  12. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    The Lodestar Award

    Oh man, I am loving the idea of a Retro YA thing for Twitter. It would be fun as a general game, but I imagine it would be rather difficult to get a representative short list. And if you threw it out there to get nominations you'd probably just end up with a lot of Heinlein juveniles and nothing else.
  13. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Lost Brotherhood Without Banners Edition

    @Stego will definitely be waking our asses up with the sun to run up and down the beaches, in order that we will be fit enough to survive running from smoke monsters. This seems anathema to BwB congregations. Although running on the beaches would burn a lot of calories, so I do hope Stego knows about edible paleo island foods or something.
  14. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    YA Hugo Nominations, 2019 Dublin

    I've also thought that was a great cover. I think this is a good point. We could also keep track of YA related fan art, professional art, and covers that we think should be nominated. I will update the OP.
  15. LugaJetboyGirl-irra

    Urban Fantasy/Paranormal Romance v. 3.0

    Recently finished THE LAST SUN by K.D. Edwards. It's set in the present day, but a little while after a civil war between the families of previously hidden Atlantis wrecked the world. The Atlanteans now live in a new city on the US east coast because Atlantis is no longer inhabitable. They are organized into the Houses of the Tarot, with the family's head the Arcana. The Arcana are basically the closest thing to gods on the planet, with vast powers. The main character is the Scion of Sun House (the heir), but his entire House was destroyed when he was a teen and his family wiped out. He's barely started coming into his sun powers and has limited magic, so he and his best friend/body guard Brand support themselves by solving mysteries/problems as mercenaries (not military style, just find-lost-things or steal-shit-mercenaries). Meanwhile, all the Houses compete with each other as they get up to trouble in New Atlantis. I thought the world-building was very richly done, with an interesting social and cultural reality, magic system, and cast of characters. There's good queer representation. For a debut novel I think it was quite well done, although I am still not convinced on who the main love interest is supposed to be, which irks me, because I am firmly on one particular Team. Definitely recommend. (Content warning for sexual violence, though.)